Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 January 2015

Ericsson adds LTE in unlicensed spectrum to product line

Funnily enough when the world hears about the Marriott hotel being involved in a WiFi jamming scandal (see separate piece) it seems obvious that the move is somehow wrong. But when an equipment vendor like Ericsson decides to push a cellular technology which is designed to effectively jam WiFi, no-one blinks so much as an eyelid.

Using CES to announce that it will support what cellular is laughingly calling Licensed Assisted Access with a new product, Ericsson has decided to target small businesses and the home with what will end up as an expensive Picocell, stating that it is adding LAA to its indoor small cell portfolio for smaller buildings under 50,000 square feet.

Can you imagine in an SME what would happen if your IT department are called out to find out why WiFi (which is relied upon for access to an enterprises core applications) is sudden blocked (or is now going at half speed) on the third floor, after installing one of these things? All hell would break loose. It would be like introducing WiFi jamming in a hotel lobby or conference room.

Worst still, the modern WiFi chips on show at CES this week might offer 1.7 Gbps using a single 160 MHz slot in unlicensed 5 GHz spectrum, whereas this Ericsson devices uses a single antenna and offers just 150 Mbps extra to a struggling cellular network. It would, of course, backhaul through the same enterprise backhaul as the WiFi, and effectively knacker 1.7 Mbps of WiFi throughput.

In a home it would be doing much the same, reducing the throughput and  charging for it, and using your own paid for backhaul to get the traffic back to the cellular core. The only difference is that there would be no IT department to fix the problem by identifying what is happening and switching the thing off.

LAA was designed to be used in the most congested cellphone environments, outdoors where lots of people are speaking on their phones or using it for data. It should augment LTE, by offering carrier aggregation including in 5.0 GHz. Even then the idea is daft, as 5.0 GHz can only reach a fraction of the distance that cellular frequencies can reach, so by switching it on, you only take a few people off the cellular structure, but don’t prevent the entire base station from being busy, only those 300 feet from the base station get relief.

The key thing is that because the consumer is not on WiFi, they do not expect to get access for free, so cellcos can a) compete and therefore interfere with WiFi b) prevent any customers of rival operators using the same spectrum and c) charge for access, all without actually making a difference to their network performance, but all the while making more money. From the consumer point of view it makes a lot more sense to use this for WiFi.

LAA will be incorporated in the Ericsson RBS 6402 Indoor Picocell and is expected to be available in late 2015. It is about the size of a tablet computer and Ericsson is also adding LAA to its existing Radio Dot System for medium and large buildings. LAA technology will also need changes to existing smartphones for them to work with it.

We think regulators should prevent this from happening. Ericsson says that it only uses 4% of the 5 GHz spectrum, which can’t be right because that would be a single 20 MHz channel and you cannot get 150 Mbps in a 20 MHz channel, only in an 80 MHz one, and if you take 80 MHz out in an area that already has 160 GHz of WiFi working in it and a radar channel or two as well, interference is almost a certainty.

T-Mobile USA was said to be looking carefully at the technology before Christmas with a view to using it this year. Let’s hope it’s not that dumb.