Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

13 October 2011

EU call for private Broadband cash is not passing the buck

Given that the European Union (EU) may for all we know cease to exist in its present form depending on the outcome of the current financial turmoil, it might make sense to pass the buck for investment in high speed broadband back to member states and onto private investors. After all pushing fiber deeper is an expensive business whose cost increases almost exponentially the closer it gets to the home, especially in less densely populated areas.

Yet we do not think the EU is passing the buck. What we do detect, judging from recent utterances by Neelie Kroes, the European Commissioner responsible for the EU’s Digital Agenda, is a rebalancing of emphasis away from the Telcos towards cable TV operators, as well as third party operators via local loop unbundling agreements.

We reported last week how Telcos will not be excused having to open their networks to rivals in return for replacing copper with fiber in their access and backhaul networks. It now appears that the EU is adopting a strategy of encouraging cable operators to invest in fiber through a combination of seed corn investments where appropriate, combined with relaxations in any regulations that impede such deployment. Telcos meanwhile may be eligible for some financial support as well and will also benefit from the regulatory relaxations, but will to a larger degree be expected to build fiber anyway. The idea is that growing competition from cable companies will provide all the incentives Telcos need to continue their fiber build outs without additional sweeteners such as being able to renege on previous unbundling arrangements.

Exactly what form both the financial incentives and regulatory changes will take is not clear yet, for the EU has not made up its mind and may not declare its hand finally until September 2012. That is when the EU’s rules on the public financing of broadband infrastructure are due to be revised in the light of continuing technical advances and regulatory shifts. The current guidelines, adopted in September 2009, already provide a framework for stimulating deployment of high and very-high speed broadband in Europe. Definitions of what constitutes high and very high speed broadband vary, but let us say 5 Mbps and 100 Mbps respectively.
The European Commission then published a questionnaire seeking views on contentious issues such as how to revise access conditions on subsidised next generation networks. A major goal was to accelerate both public and private investment in high speed broadband, as well as stimulating competition in the sector.
The Commission has stated it regards the earlier guidelines as having been partially successful, speeding up decisions over pro-competitive state aid, which exceeded €1.8 billion in 2010. But the guidelines have failed to persuade private investors to stump up the €270 billion estimated by Kroes as necessary for Europe to match parts of the US and Asia for fiber roll out. She has also hinted that some large Telco incumbents are delaying their investments in fiber in order to avoid cannibalizing their existing broadband business based on DSL access over copper.

This may be rather unfair and missing the point. While we agree with EU suggestions that Telcos should lower the price of entry to rivals that want to use their networks via unbundling agreements, it is misleading to assume that only Fiber To The Home (FTTH) can deliver super-fast broadband.

Until and unless photonics replaces electronics in computers, TVs and other consumer devices, which is a distant prospect at best, there will always be at least a short copper loop between the equipment and fiber termination point. From the point of view of bandwidth it just depends on how long that loop is.

Technologies that improve bit rates over copper of a given length are still improving quite rapidly by exploiting progress in signal processing combined with algorithms that eliminate cross talk between neighboring twisted pair copper circuits in a single bundle. A significant move here came last month when Alcatel-Lucent launched its vectoring technology for Fiber To The Cabinet deployments using VDSL2 technology over copper lengths up to around 400 meters. This enables up to at least 100 Mbps over such copper lengths, with potential to triple this by bonding two copper pairs combined with a mechanism called Phantom Mode that overlays a third signal on top of the two pairs to create an additional virtual channel. In effect in Phantom Mode each of the two twisted pairs operates as a single circuit within a larger bonded four pair circuit, in addition to the normal twisted pair operation.

Such technical improvements gel with investment to push fiber further out towards the consumer in street cabinets, but also highlight how there is no need for panic. Indeed as the copper loops are reduced in length they will support faster access speeds even in the absence of further technical improvements. In this way investment in fiber and copper technologies can go hand in hand, combining to deliver the increase in broadband speeds that the EU is striving for.

The EU should not kowtow too much to the fiber lobby therefore. Indeed the reason for diverting some funds for fiber deployment to the cable operators is that they have been successful delivering high speed broadband over their Hybrid Fiber Coax (HFC) infrastructures. Coax has a higher intrinsic transmission capacity than twisted pair copper largely because it is thicker and better shielded from interference, which is why cablecos have enjoyed an edge in broadband and TV over Telcos so far. But they do exemplify the benefits of a gradual extension of fiber, pushing the nodes closer to the customer so that the coaxial segments are shared by fewer homes, increasing the number of unicast channels each one can receive.

In both cable and Telco networks it will be a long term before fiber reaches many homes away from urban areas, and there is no need to worry unduly about that.