Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

19 October 2005

EU changes on music royalty collections a breath of fresh air

Within all the gobbledegook language contained in the European Commission statement about the revision of online musical rights in Europe, sits a fairly far reaching set of changes that are likely to obliterate a number of the weaker collections agencies and radically slash the costs of licensing music in Europe.

The hodge podge approach whereby each agency claims a small piece of Europe and separately levies its own overhead charges against localized collections revenues, is notoriously inefficient and absorbs something like 20% of all music royalties in red tape.

The EC changes potentially free up much of that revenue to flow back to online services, where it can be carved up between the service, the record label and the artists.

Many readers will immediately wonder why it matters that this is done efficiently, in the end surely it will just make the record labels richer, especially now that piracy is on the wane. That may be true, but simplicity of licensing should mean that online music services are not solely the preserve of large corporations that have the time and money to cut through red tape.

It will also have an effect on the nascent online film distribution market, given that every time a film is sold, it has some element of musical licensing with it and this would previously have to go through the massively complex right agencies that have been embedded in European culture for the past few hundred years.

What the Commission is adopting is a combination allowing each collections society to grant an EU-wide license covering the other societies’ repertoires and giving right-holders the choice to appoint a collective rights manager for the entire EU.

Royalties for music used to be collected on a strict territorial basis, and collections for say France were allocated to one agency, and the UK another, and Belgium another. With 25 separate countries now in the European Union, this makes negotiating and policing royalty payments unnecessarily complicated. Now rights holders will have a choice of either letting all of their existing agencies collect anywhere in Europe and co-operate, or they can appoint a single agency to collect for them in all European territories.

The recommendation also includes provisions on governance and more importantly transparency. It will also create a dispute settlement process and provide for accountability from rights managers.

These agencies previously were a law unto themselves, creaming off often unspecified amount of payments for ‘administration’ and opening their books to very few entities. The EU is likely to receive a storm of protest over its aims of transparency.