As boring a subject at intellectual property law can be, patents in particular, the future of the western world as we know it is based on the ability for European and US companies to hold intellectual property and get paid royalties for it. If not, then China and its allies would overrun our economies with mimicked products.
So it is always worth sitting up and listening when new patent laws are being drawn up. The re-write of copyright law internationally around the US inspired Digital Millenium Copyright Act (in our view a poor law) caused a huge change in the way 179 countries managed their copyrights and much the same process has been going on since 1999 in patent law.
Back in July 2005 the European Commission tried to introduce a single unified directive for creating separate patent laws in European countries that would allow software and business models to be patented. This was in line with US laws. It was thrown out by a vote in the European parliament.
Usually the European Parliament just rubber stamps directives that force new laws on European Union members, but this legislation raised everyone’s hackles because it seemed to be leading to far more patent litigation in Europe, and fears that the patent engines of all the major corporations would have gobbled up all the ‘obvious’ business model ideas and charged every smaller business a royalty to conduct existing business models, something that happens routinely in the US.
The European Patent Office is known to be in favor of software patents and has already adopted the fundamentals proposed by the failed directive for years and has issued 30,000 patents involving software, none of which are really defensible in European law.
Now Europe is faced with a different issue, one about unifying patent laws and creating a single place where patents can be registered, along with a single appeals process for patent litigation that is streamlined and Europe wide. Such a patent process would be the envy of even the US, and could wield huge international power. The trouble is everyone is terrified that it will lead to passing the software directive by the back door.
The change is proposed by the European Commission, the same body that was utterly inflexible in listening to member states over the last issue, and it may be likely that the European Patent Office, which has been issuing software patents, would form the basis of any future European Patent Litigation Agreement.
Which is why this legislation, likely to pass as it may be, will not have an easy journey and why there are a huge number of changes being called for in its draft format, including assurances of the independence of judges and clarity on the costs of litigation.
The whole point is that litigation should be cheaper, done once for all 31 countries. But that was the point of the European Patent Office, which still sits with national patents offices as an extra cost, not a single consolidated cost for Europe.
What has happened recently is that the there was a last minute compromise between various political groups at the European Parliament level, so that instead of the important consolidation of European patents being scrapped, they will look at re-wording the Agreement something which Services Commission Charlie McCreevy agreed to, saying there were legitimate concerns and that it was better to rework the document than have it sunk without trace.
The rewording will focus on ensuring that patent costs won’t go up or hurt small businesses and will not allow software or business model patents in by the back door. Also there will be changes to ensure democratic control, meaning that a system of bureaucracy shouldn’t emerge in patents where no elected official can challenge the interpretation of any given process.
It is unlikely to re-emerge as a European Parliamentary issue for the remainder of this year, and perhaps next.