Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

19 July 2005

EU plans for controlling internet advertising to face a rocky ride

We usually have a lot of time for the European Union and its stipulations about technology. Be that as it may, it has, in the past, foisted the hugely unpopular Digital Millenium Copyright Act on an unwilling world, in the form of an endorsement of the World Copyright Treaty based on the flawed US legislation, and has recently failed horribly to push through a directive related to software and business model patents, also copied from US legislation.

But this week the European Commission has widely been written up as getting ready to regulate content on the Internet, something that is largely impractical, technically difficult and which will be vastly unpopular. How, for instance will anyone regulate a web site hosted outside of the EU?

But what Viviane Reding, the European Information Commissioner, is really setting out, is a code of conduct for advertisers on the internet, which is something that is vastly different from regulating content.

It is being done under the guise of a review of the European wide TV regulations, that were first set in 1989, and TV is being redefined as the delivery of moving pictures to the general public by electronic networks. This means that the resulting legislation will apply equally to the internet, broadcasting and mobile TV networks.

The European Commission will run a consultation until September 5 this year, then work towards a Directive which should be used as a basis for making laws in each of the member countries.

Reding has been quoted as saying she is considering regulating areas such as taste and decency, accuracy and impartiality for internet broadcasters.

But in her papers it only talks about the protection of minors, and human dignity (Europe could not impose a ban on pornography because of the widely varying attitude to it across Europe, but it might ban it in advertising and ban both pornography and gratuitous violence in web content aimed at children); making it clear when an advert is an advert, having a code of conduct for advertising to be truthful, offering a right of reply on news statements and for each publication to make it clear what it is by having a masthead or logo.

It will be pretty difficult to equate TV ideas such as a 9.00 pm watershed for sex and violence to the internet, which operates 24/7.

Also, given the way that internet advertising is beginning to grow at the expense of TV advertising, this may be used as an excuse to even up the pressures on the various forms of advertising in Europe. The TV broadcasters would love to have regulations relaxed on how frequently they can show advertising and would even more love the idea of internet advertising being regulated in the same way, to make it less capable of stealing TV’s advertising customers. It is being suggested that the existing TV time limit of 12 minutes of advertising for each hour be scrapped.

But at the same time advertising for alcohol and tobacco would have to be regulated in some way on the internet, where currently there are no such rules (but again only in terms of video advertising, not text or static graphics).

Reding unveiled five ‘issues papers’ one on ‘non-linear audio-visual content’ or television downloads, one on the statutory right of reply on a web site, and others designed to improve the protection of Children using the internet. A draft directive will be produced at the end of this year and put to vote by the European Parliament, which will presumably vote down anything if it is too restrictive.

Even the criteria that is likely to be used to decide which member country has jurisdiction is going to lead to problems. It is either the country where the editorial decisions concerning services are taken or it is the place where the content service provider is established. For most web sites viewed in the EU neither of these would be in the EU.