More stress for LTE wannabe LightSquared ‘ the European Commission has joined in the chorus of criticisms that its LTE services in mobile satellite spectrum will interfere with GPS signals. The wholesale 4G plan poses a ‘grave threat’ to Europe’s rival to GPS, Galileo, an EC official said in a statement to the FCC.
Heinz Zourek, head of the Commission’s industry department, said research carried out in Europe, including by the European Space Agency, showed that LightSquared’s base stations had “considerable potential to cause harmful interference” to Europe’s Galileo satellite positioning system, which should be operational by 2014 or 2015. Like GPS, Galileo uses spectrum that is next to the L-band LightSquared owns, and will be interoperable with the US-owned platform. Russia and China also have their own satellite location systems underway.
Zourek added that LightSquared’s network could also potentially harm European aviation systems. The FCC is currently reviewing a modified network plan, submitted by LightSquared on June 30, which would concentrate roll-out in the lower portion of its L-band holdings, which is further from GPS frequencies. However, the GPS community is still critical of the new approach, since the lower L-band, from 1526MHz to 1536MHz, is used by GPS augmentation services, which send additional location data to GPS receivers that require more precise bearings, particularly for applications like agriculture, mapping and surveying.
In the upper band, neither the LightSquared base stations nor the GPS satellites transmit outside their assigned frequencies, but interference has still been detected ‘ though the two sides disagree on why this should be so. GPS backers say it is because the LTE network signals are so much more powerful than those from distant satellites, while LightSquared blames GPS vendors for not equipping their receivers with stronger filters to tune out signals in adjacent bands.
“There has never been, nor will there ever be, a filter than can block out signals in an immediately adjacent band that are so much more powerful,” the Coalition to Save Our GPS said in a written response to LightSquared’s plan. GPS satellites broadcast a 50-watt signal from 12,000 miles up, across an entire continent, it explained, while LTE base stations can create signals of up to 1,600 watts within about a mile of GPS receivers.