Very few European broadcasters are now building their own CDNs, reflecting the ability of third party providers to deliver better end to end QoS. This emerged from the recent EBU (European Broadcasting Union) Broad Thinking 2014 seminar, which was notable for a shift in sentiment away from the Build Your Own approach in the year since the 2013 event.
Last year one of the most highly acclaimed presentations from Martin Boronski, CTO of French channel M6Web, was entitled Building your own CDN : a broadcaster’s perspective on why and how one of the most important French TV channels developed its own CDN for OTT distribution. M6 is a subsidiary of German broadcaster RTL and had been developing a video distribution infrastructure for delivery of live, catchup and VOD content to a range of devices, including PCs, set tops, smartphones, tablets and games consoles.
With 50 million views per month, IP transit cost was a major factor in the decision by M6 to build its own CDN, resulting in 30% savings compared with a global CDN such as Akamai. Martin also cited insufficient connectivity with local ISPs, lack of local support and lack of HTTP ABR delivery as other drawbacks of commercial CDNs. M6 bundled its own CDN in a single POP (Point of Presence), using commodity-hardware caching servers, Isilon storage, Juniper routers and open source software, such as Nginx for long form content, and Varnish for short-form items.
The question then was why few other other European broadcasters, apart from NPO of the Netherlands, had taken the same line. One of the reasons emerging from the Broad Thinking conference this year was that the CDN scene has changed significantly over the last one to two years as the major global providers have got their act together over end to end QoS. They will have noted how Netflix was migrating to its own CDN and reaching arrangements with local ISPs to deliver guaranteed end to end SLAs.
Akamai in particular has been active after reversing its earlier strategy by entering the operator CDN market. Previously Akamai had regarded Telcos as potential competitors and so avoided supplying them with capabilities that would enable them to offer end to end CDN services themselves. But as Telcos entered this field Akamai released there was no point cutting of its nose to spite its face and started partnering with them.
Most recently it struck a strategic alliance with Telefonica to deliver its suite of CDN services to the carrier’s enterprise customers, but with delivery of video services in Spanish speaking countries during the forthcoming FIFA World Cup and 2016 Olympic Games in mind. This deal followed similar agreements between Akamai and both AT&T and Orange in 2012.
Akamai had already identified the Telco threat then and attempted to neutralize it by turning rivals into partners. This was evidenced in particular by the acquisition in 2012 of Verivue, a relatively small specialist in licensing CDN software to Telcos. This helped Akamai bring to market its Aura Network Solutions product line, a licensed CDN software service, which enables service providers to build their own CDN capabilities using off-the-shelf hardware.
Ironically Akamai’s cause in the US was probably helped by Verizon’s acquisition of Edgecast, a major competitor in the carrier CDN arena, on the basis that Telcos are reluctant to license or resell CDN services provided by a direct rival.
Akamai has meanwhile also moved to improve the performance of its own CDN infrastructure, most notably with its purchase of FastSoft in September 2012, gaining a TCP congestion avoidance algorithm in the process. This had been developed at the California Institute of Technology specifically to optimize video transmission across long distance high latency links.
Like other methods it works by adjusting the IP packet flow rate according to traffic conditions, slowing down when there is congestion. It attempts to maintain constant queue sizes, which optimizes the balance between dropped packets and latency. Its unique property, enshrouded in several patents, is that as the queue size approaches its target level the rate at which transmission into the queue is adjusted slows down. This makes the process more stable and more likely to converge and maintain equilibrium.
Akamai was talking up the benefits of this algorithm at the Broad Thinking seminar and to judge from the responses is on the right track, even if many of the broadcasters present have opted for rival CDN suppliers.