Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

11 December 2014

European Commission seems hellbent on market-led consolidation

One of the things we warned about in the run up to the European Commission allowing the merger between Liberty Global and Ziggo in the Netherlands, was that it was setting a precedent that every corner of the European Telecommunications world, would want to emulate.

Just a scant month after that decision, the floodgates are open, and the Commission will have a hard time keeping to its stated task of ensuring that sufficient competition continues to exist in cellular, broadband and pay TV.

Say yes to one merger, and no to another, and you leave yourself open to accusations that you are playing favorites, so letting Liberty Global buy Ziggo and land 65% of all pay TV in the Netherlands, plus close to 50% of broadband, makes 65% the magic number for dominance. In the past it has been 34% – one percentage point above a third of the market, today it is 1% below two thirds, and whether that was what the Commission wanted or not, it is now seen as a “gung ho” administration that has invited all the consolidation throughout Europe. To extend an old Dutch image of the boy with his finger in the dyke, by taking its finger out, it has initiated a flow that appears to be unstoppable.

The GSMA waded in this week, with a call not only to allow mergers, but to be careful not to weigh them down with commitments that may make the ensuing merged entity unstable and unable to remain competitive. Luckily its word carries little weight and if its voice is going to continue to be so ill-considered as this, then long may that remain the case.

Apply that logic in Denmark, where last week TeliaSonera and Telenor were the ones asking for permission to merge, to fight off the alarmingly strong local incumbent TDC. This is a market of 5.6 million people and even more phones and the combined operation might have 3.4 million or some 40% of the market. With TDC on just 2.1 million, but with all the usual benefits of both a telco and a dominant cable operator, that leaves just 1 million customers at the other cellco, 3 Group..

The new merged entity would also have 270,000 broadband lines compared to TDC’s 1.1 million, plus 200,000 fixed voice customers compared to TDC’s 756,000 and no pay TV customers, compared to TDC’s 1.4 million. Hutchinson’s 3 has no broadband lines or WiFi support or pay TV offering.

TDC is often talked about as a minnow when compared to TeliaSonera and especially Telenor. The same thing can be said regarding 3 on a global basis, but realistically TDC is in too strong a position within Denmark.

Given that regulators can only say yes or no to a merger, not suggest their own mergers, does this mean that the local regulator or the European Commission should block this merger? Let’s face it, if this merger goes through we are asking for a duopoly as 3 disappears as a force. It would be better if 3 merged with one of the others, but 3 is not up for sale.

It could be that the time has come to apply different rules. Instead of looking at one dimension, such as just broadband or mobile or pay TV, we look at total triple play reach, or quad play, within a given territory. That would immediately make it obvious in Denmark that TDC may have to divest itself of its cable interests, before any balance could be restored

The current regulations in most European countries are that a specific service should not have a single dominant supplier created through a merger or other transaction, which risks distorting consumer pricing and competition. So a company as large as Vodafone, which is strong but not dominant in mobile in say Spain, can buy ONO with impunity, because it has never before been in pay TV or broadband (it is in broadband, but not in cable, and anyway another player is dominant).

The situation means that it has the cash to distort the market, but not the market share to do this profitably.

Interestingly Free in France disrupted the market there, not by dominant market power, but it used tied pricing to create a cheaper product in mobile. Tying is illegal where a company is dominant, and clearly Orange is the closest to a dominant company in France, in fact the regulator made Orange roam with Free, as part of the 4th cellular license, because of that dominance.

Suddenly with the use of WiFi to offload data from a cellular network, Free can sell cellular for less than the cost price among any of its rivals. So this is a form of bundling or tying of one service to another. It would not be possible for a stand-alone cellular operator, even if it had dominant market share to price at €2 a month for basic cellular. It is only possible for a quad play operator which also has very low marketing costs, because it is marketing to its existing loyal customer base directly.

A new economic formula which takes in that disruptive pricing, relying on existing customer dominance, might be used to prevent this type of situation. We want market innovation, but not competition that kills all the other players off in a kind of cultural suicide pact.

So if you could imagine such an economic test for a minute, it would be fine for two cellular operators to merge to create a stronger cellular company, even if it was the market leader, but only if the merged entity, like this Telia-Telenor entity in Denmark, remained overall weaker than at least one player across all communications services.

But then again Ziggo and UPC in the Netherlands had almost no cellular customers, but did things the right way around, merged two triple plays first, and now they will go over a WiFi First mobile service, to kill the other quad play operators in the country.

If you equate each service as having power by a sector margin multiplied by the number of customers, then you might get a “Quad play” competitive number for UPC and for Ziggo. And given that mobile is so much more profitable than fixed line telephony, broadband and pay TV put together, then perhaps this merger WAS okay.

In which case you have to ask, is such a set of economic rules already operating internally at the European Commission. And is it communicating those rules or guidelines to incumbents and is that why mergers are appearing just about everywhere across Europe right now?

BT has confirmed this week that it will continue to evaluate bids for one of two UK cellcos, while rivals such as Vodafone, may have backed off its potential bid for Liberty Global, but that is only so that it is not rushed into anything overnight. It was considered about buying Kabel Deutschland (it was on and off for four years) and its wants to be considered, once again.

Com Hem this week came into the same merger news, as Denmark’s TDC was said to be considering a bid for the Swedish cable company, the largest cable operator there, and one that is also controlled by another private equity group. The company carried out an IPO on the back of a determined comeback in pay TV, driven by UI improvements through partnership with TiVo. The only other cable player of note is owned by Telenor and already the regulator there has prevented these two from being merged. It would be interesting to know if it would block such a move once again?

Because if you applied the same rules that were applied to Ziggo and UPC then it should also have been allowed to merge all cable in Sweden.

The change is the appointment of Jean-Claude Juncker as the President of the European Commission who has made his position clear that he wants to spend up to €300 billion on infrastructure improvement and mentions broadband first whenever he speaks about it.

He campaigned on the notion that the borderless nature of digital technologies means it no longer makes sense for each EU country to have its own rules for telecommunications services, copyright, data protection, or the management of radio spectrum and last month he appointed Margrethe Vestager, ironically a Dane, as the European commissioner for competition.

We are forced to conclude from what he says publicly and what deals have been allowed, that the new Commission will welcome a situation where there are four or five Europe-wide telecommunications companies which each have quad plays. In which case Europeans would no longer be consistently at the mercy of larger US and potentially in the future, Chinese or even Latin American companies – which can boss them about in terms of financial muscle and size.

And if this is where the European Commission wants to get to, then it had will almost certainly take its local regulators in hand and that includes the German Kartel Office. Its position has always been that it has no intention of letting German cable merge back into a single whole ever again, and this has being echoed in the past about cable by regulators in the Nordics. If this has changed, someone ought to be saying so openly and to everyone including the public, not just mutter it behind closed doors.

But it is this which has been as much a starting gun as its first decision in the Liberty Global Ziggo case and the entire European Telecommunications arena has now become a jungle, where some deals are allowed and some are not, but no-one is quite sure by which rules we are playing.

If, as you may be excused for thinking, the days of excess profitability has gone out of fixed lines forever, then why cannot Deutsche Telekom begin the buyout of British Telecom and France Telecom, and apply economies of scale and push profits into the wireless end of the Quad play? The answer may be that while companies like Free can wreak havoc within a single European market, it is not safe for that to happen.

In the meantime, why would Liberty Global not merge with Vodafone before the two of them cast an envious eye at Sky? Because these companies only have one mobile champion and two that are strong in broadband and pay TV, but in different places with overlap only in Germany. But of course it is in Germany that Juncker will meet his biggest opposition from the Kartel Office.

If these larger mergers between incumbent telcos are ready to happen, then if that has been decided, then let’s fire the starting gun. If not then can someone please state the conditions that are fine for mergers, the new rules of engagement, if you like. It should be a level playing field that everyone is aware of.

There remain about 30 cable companies worth tidying up, and being drawn into bigger piles of chips, and these have genuine value in any scenario that relies on a far larger number of backhaul points (small cells) or upon existing installed WiFi. Right now there is a perceived scramble for fixed line capability, to plug alongside cellular capability, because the business case has now, more or less, been proven.

We have seen an alliance between cable and cellular in Germany and in the UK at Virgin, and at Numericable in France with SFR. It is only where the incumbent telco has been allowed to acquire the local single cable operator (Denmark) that we have seen a market that is overly dominated by a single player.

But here there is a problem. Is each country destined to be a Cable, Telco duopoly? Or does the development of the European marketplace need to fragment further, given how strongly confident the industry is right now that there needs to be at least 3 operators in cellular per territory, in order to retain competition. Not one country is down to just two.

It has fallen to three cellcos in Gemany and gone from five to four in the UK, with the prospect of falling further. The danger in a market of three players is that there are no more mergers left to be done once a third placed player falls foul of genuine competition and can no longer support the required and growing capex burden created by multiple layers of new technology.

There is continued talk of a drop to three players in France, and yet in the US, where the cellular environment is still largely uncompetitive and excessively profitable, its Justice Department had the sense to prevent a reduction to three players, when AT&T wanted to buy T-Mobile, leaving two larger players with one of them, Sprint, excessively weak.

Then logically this consolidation must either be stopped, or allowed to go to its ultimate conclusion and follow the Chinese model, where three providers, each with a different technical emphasis and background, are allowed to thrive and consolidate across the United State of Europe. Maybe one pure mobile player, one telco and one cableco.

In which case we would not put money against two of them being Vodafone and Deutsche Telekom, which leaves the question, what needs to happen to Orange and Telefonica and who is the third player if it is not Liberty Global.

It will take another 25 years we think to reach that kind of “clarification” of the European market, but only then would these players be safe from a rampaging America Movile or AT&T or a China Mobile which had broken out of China, and perhaps that‘s what occupies the thoughts of the new European Commission President. But we would not like to be a consumer in that dystopian future, and what happens when these monoliths turn their attention to broadcasters and other forms of entertainment? Are we to let them run all things in Communications?