Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

7 June 2006

Failure to sell Movielink stems from the reasons for its creation

The original film downloading site Movielink appears to be coming towards the end of the road. The studios that own it want to sell it off, but have managed to frighten away all of its ideal partners.

Sources this week, including Hollywood Reporter and BusinessWeek, reveal how the studios that own the site have argued constantly over what Movielink can or cannot do, and as a result have failed to make the acquisition look worthwhile for Blockbuster, Comcast and AT&T, as well as some prominent individuals, and these have now all falling out of the running.

Movielink came into existence in 2001 and began renting movies in 2002, but only on a time limited, single device basis. Movies could be stored for 30 days, but would expire within 24 hours of beginning to view them. Through 2003 and 2004 Movielink chased internet traffic with ISP deals, but very little progress came of it. Today it is thought to do around $20 million in revenues, and this after some $150 million in start up cash has been burned.

The problem for Movielink is all about the motives for setting it up. Five studios, Paramount, Sony, Universal, Warner Brothers and MGM are all equal founders and content from Fox and Disney was added later. It has only ever offered films that are already in the pay per view window and has never hosted a huge archive of classics.

The motives should have been the same motives as iTunes, that is to offer a neat alternative to piracy, by making movies, cheap and easily available and fun to use. The company has never written a piece of Windows software to automate the download like iTunes, it has never really made it easy to view its films on a TV instead of a PC, and it has always overpriced its offerings.

In other words Movielink was set up so that it would prove to people for a year or so, that downloading films doesn’t work and give Hollywood a few years thinking time to see what it really wanted to do. In our view it was set up to fail so that the studios could say to others ‘don’t launch downloading services, we’ve proved they don’t work,’ even if that wasn’t the conscious thought processes that the studio executives went through.

Recently there has begin to be some movement in the strategy of Movielink with its signing a deal to offer its films through Akimbo, which allows downloads straight to a set top for viewing on a TV, not a PC, and with a new deal announced to allow Movielink to actually sell movies.

This was struck in April, and although the movies can’t be burned into a real DVD, they can be burnt in PC format video onto a DVD, and played on three PCs in total. This new deal offers new films at between $20 to $30 and older titles at $10 to $20, so that’s downloads which have limited applicability which cost more than DVDs from Amazon, which makes little economic sense.

Long suffering Movielink CEO Jim Ramo, is now putting his own efforts behind selling the company, adding to the efforts of Salem and Partners, the investment bank commissioned to engineer a sale.

The sticking point appears to be guaranteeing that Movielink will continue to allow films to be sold. What appears to be behind the respective strategies of the movie studios is that they sell off Movielink with a one year deal to sell DVD files, and then rescind it as they launch their own initiatives. Those terms are not very encouraging and while that remains the attitude of the parents, Movielink is unlikely to find a home.

It is supposed to have one year’s cash in the bank, so it can continue in business, but appears to have no viable future strategy. Perhaps a competitor like CinemaNow or Apple should buy it?

Many of the studios have an online plan of sorts, Sony has several, with its Connect service picking up momentum and soon to include video to phones, PCs and the PlayStation Portable; MGM is of course now controlled by Sony; and Warner Brothers and Universal have initiatives with AOL, and only Paramount has yet to make its online route to market clear (could it buy Movielink itself?). Of course both Fox and Disney have multiple initiatives, with Fox promising a download film service by the end of this year in the US and Disney taking investment on board for a new version of its Moviebeam service.

Despite this, there remains a looming fear that the $20 billion DVD market which is based on big retailers like Amazon and Wal-Mart, could be popped if online films begin to sell. But trying to stop online film sales by restricting Movielink is like trying to hold back the sea with your arms.

Already Starz Vongo, iTunes itself, and competing film services from Google, Sony, Clear Channel; 4Flix and Blinkx in the US plus Arvato, BSkyB, LoveFilm and NTL in Europe and Amazon is preparing a launch in this sector, not to mention Netflix and Blockbuster’s interest, plus the online efforts of all the studios and TV broadcasters, means that internet video downloading is already a fact of life.

For Movielink the shareholding studios either capitulate and let the service have the kind of terms that could make it a strong future player, or they quietly wait for the service to run out of customers and close down.