With Nasdaq flying high, up 2.7% last week, the Faultline Fifty was left slightly in its wake, pushed ahead by the consumer electronics and chips sector, but held back by the doubts that surround all forms of operators and content companies.
In some way that concern is well placed, Telcos and cable companies and satellite operators have a clearly defined war, and in wars people get hurt. It is likely that there will be no major recovery in these sectors until clear winners and losers emerge from the triple play wars, and that may be well into 2007
There was a host of reports this week including Conexant, Qwest, Gemstar, Comcast, Liberty, DirecTV, Time Warner, NTL, Vivendi, Cisco, EchoStar and Cablevision and we can’t cover them all, but will pick out a few highlights. Also there was continued movement among XM Satellite Radio and Sirius, who reported a week earlier.
It still baffles us exactly why US analysts like Sirius better than XM, with XM having 5 million subscribers and revenues of $153 million, while Sirius has just over 2 million and revenues of $66.8 million for the quarter. Perhaps it’s all about the rate at which they are adding subscribers with Sirius adding 359,294 subscribers, while XM added 617,152, so no it’s not that. Both companies are running at a continued and considerable loss with Sirius burning through $180.4 million this last quarter and XM though $131.9 million, so it’s not this either.
Sirius has costs per gross subscriber addition of $149, XM measures this slightly differently and calls it something else but its Cost Per Gross Addition is $89, so it doesn’t appear to be that either.
Perhaps it’s the deals that each of them do with car manufacturers, perhaps it’s the deals cut with the talent, such as Howard Stern, the biggest talk show property in the US, which kicks off next quarter on Sirius.
Sirius announced deals with DaimlerChrysler, BMW and Ford while XM relies on its relationship with General Motors and innovates elsewhere with Hotel chains and overseas partnerships.
Whatever is the secret ingredient, and it may purely be spectrum, Sirius rose this week 5.9% to be valued at over $9 billion, while XM rose 6.6% to reach a value of $6.5 billion.
Comcast was off $3 billion after results that show that the giant cable company’s momentum is slowing. Its revenues were up 9.4%, but down sequentially from last quarter, and the company then proceeded to take on board $2.25 billion of debt to add to the mountain of debt it already holds.
There was a small rise at Conexant as the chip maker completes something of a recovery after two years in the wilderness, reporting a return to operating profit one quarter early with revenues up 9% to $215 million, but at the GAAP level it still recorded a small loss of $13.1 million. The chip maker, which is an amalgam of Wi-Fi, DSL, set top, VoIP and PON components, cut costs and inventory, and turned its inventory over a record 5.4 times during the quarter.
The company, which incorporated Globespan Virata, which in turn had just acquired the wi-fi arm of Intersil, hit problems virtually the quarter after the deal was cut, as prices in the wi-fi component market slumped. Conexant now says it will be shooting for double digit operating margins within the next calendar year, but it still operates in some pretty competitive markets.
DirecTV’s figures only took its value up 2% on the week, but they were impressive enough, with net income of $95 million compared $1 billion loss this time last year when it had a $903 million net impairment charge. Revenues were $3.23 billion up 13%, despite it being compared with a year when it still owned Hughes Network Systems.
CEO Chase Carey, said ‘Much of this growth was fueled by the 22% increase in revenues along with higher operating margins attained through improved cost management in key areas such as subscriber acquisition and upgrade and retention marketing. Driven by these accomplishments, DirecTV US generated $230 million of free cash flow in the quarter compared to a negative $151 million in last year’s third quarter.’
Gross subscriber additions were 1.1 million taking the company close to 15 million customers, and it says that the credit profiles of those 15 million is way better than it used to be, so they are more likely to be able to afford the service long term.
The monthly churn rate of 1.89% remains unacceptably high but it says much of this is still down to DirecTV getting rid of high credit risk customers and not because people are canceling. DirecTV in the US added 263,000 net subscribers in the quarter to reach 14.93 million.
Another big mover this week is Matsushita, still rising on a positive report from last week. It picked up another 10% to $46 billion in value, a huge rise for a CE stock that has been languishing around the $33 billion mark for the past 3 years, when it was valued at less than 50% of its revenues.
Apple has also risen $2 billion, some 5% this week, on the back of the company’s recent announcements regarding the video iPod and the sales of its first 1 million videos. But we still feel Apple is in uncharted territory and it will only take a change in sentiment to bring the stock down a ways. Apple is now valued at around 3.3 times its prospective revenue for the year, and that’s now a higher multiple than any similar companies, except Microsoft. Faultline predicted it would go to three times revenues, but its current fundamentals cannot sustain it above a valuation of $50 billion and from here on in, it is all sentiment. However if sales continue to climb, we have said that Apple’s value might reach $60 billion in a year or so.
Finally the only real faller in content this week is Vivendi, but it took down the entire sector, down $2 billion despite stronger than expected revenues up 12% to €4.87 billion ($5.73 billion) with its cellular phone arm SFR the star of the show, increasing revenues by 20%. Its music arm Universal Music Group was the only segment where revenue fell 4% €1.12 billion ($1.34 billion). It has not yet given net income figures.