The Faultline Fifty rose 0.1% this week, as the Nasdaq continued its fourth week in descent, falling by 1.38%. This is the first time in four weeks that the Fifty out performed Nasdaq.
Nasdaq trading began slow on inflation fears and trepidation in automotive, where Delphi filed for bankruptcy, in turn hurting General Motors. The market ended the week with a small rebound, not enough to return it to where it began the week.
The weakest sector in the Faultline Fifty (see attached spreadsheet) were satellite and cable operators, with Comcast losing just over $2 billion from its total value and smaller losses at both Cablevision and EchoStar to take the entire segment down 2.77% on the week. Even the effervescent satellite radio stocks drifted down with the market, where they usually outperform it.
Content and chips were also down (respectively 0.65% and 0.46%) with the biggest movements being weakness at Disney and yet more softening at Intel.
The strongest segment, up 1.88% was what we call Technology, driven by a bounce at Microsoft after recent falls and Apple recovering from its quarterly report on the back of the video iPod launch (see separate story).
The CE sector also rose, but on nothing discernible, with Sony and Matsushita gaining.
Other individual stock movements of note included a fall at Motorola.
What our colleagues over at RiderResearch pointed out this week is that the three largest US telephone services saw their share price hit annual lows.
At one point in the past 12 months Verizon had hit a market capital of $113 billion, and now it sits under $83 billion, a 26% fall from its top valuation.
The decline in residential phone lines, with the three largest RBOCs collectively losing 2.2 million such lines in the second quarter alone, and with Verizon taking losses of 1.2 million of those, is one of the key factors. This comes as much from the mostly imagined triple play from the cable companies (except Cablevision which appears to be the real deal) and from low cost or free VoIP services including Vonage and Skype, switchover to purely mobile telephony, just as Internet giants Yahoo, AOL, and Microsoft enter the fray for free VoIP. Residential voice erosion is expected to accelerate, not slow down
This is supposed to be offset by a growth in broadband, but here prices have collapsed from around $40 a month to as low as $15 a month, which, at least for the time being substantially reduces margins.
As cities such as Philadelphia and San Francisco have taken decisions to build their own broadband metro zones with partners from the portal market who are either charging less or in the case of Google’s bid, nothing at all, this also threatens this new growth.
Each of the RBOCs in one way or another are investing large amounts of money in building out fiber networks, whether it is to the home, in Verizon’s case, or just closer to the home, in Bellsouth and SBC’s case.
But the slow speed of the buildout, coupled with the high cost, put the RBOCs in the worst bind, with high spending and low early returns.
At the same time broadband wireless competitors are entering the marketplace and analysts are questioning the wisdom of physical fiber in the world where wireless fiber is faster to build and where copper cables are having more and more bandwidth squeezed out of them with technologies such as ADSL2+ and VDSL2.
Finally the threat to each company’s cellular subsidiaries, from both a freshly merged Sprint-Nextel, and from wi-fi voice completes a scenario that has played on the minds of US financial analysts who cannot discern a clear plan of action from the RBOCs, hence their price falls.
The only potential for reversal in favor of the RBOCs is a triple play all of their own, which has been slow in coming and which largely rests with Microsoft’s assistance in its IPTV services, which due to the slow unraveling into actual services, appears delayed, even where it isn’t.