The FCC is considering a “hybrid” approach to solve the US net neutrality controversy that continues to rumble on. Under the proposal, the FCC would class ISP to consumer connections as Retail broadband, and all traffic from the source up to that point as Wholesale (from Netflix to the Comcast network, for example). The story first came out in the Wall Street journal which cited sources close to the discussions.
Details remain scant, and it turns out that this is just one of four potential approaches which the FCC is considering. On the surface, this arrangement would do very little if nothing at all to solve the monopolistic stranglehold that the ISPs in the US have on the last mile connection – from which arise the main complaints of traffic throttling and paid prioritization. But it might solve some of the more specific problems like charging Netflix for connectivity.
Title II (Two) rules would apply to the wholesale arrangement, and this means the wholesale side of ISPs would be considered common carriers, which in turn means that the FCC would be able to intervene if a dispute or abuse arose, and its word would be final.
This may be the best shot that the FCC has at taking a stand on net neutrality. If this had already been in place when the Netflix-Comcast dispute arose, the FCC could have intervened, depending on the precise rules of how this is managed.
Comcast refused to use Netflix’s own OpenConnect CDN, free of charge. Instead, Comcast forced Netflix to sign an interconnection agreement to handle the volume of traffic flowing from Netflix to Comcast customers. Overnight, the deal saw the average connection speed reported by Netflix increase. Clearly Comcast was limiting the streaming speeds available to its internet customers either deliberately or by omission, in the sense that it was not providing enough bandwidth for interconnection. The proposed FCC hybrid approach puts this within the FCC’s remit to examine and regulate these kinds of agreement.
The question would be whether or not the Netflix traffic was moved to a server rack containing its library, and whether or not that would be part of the wholesale relationship where Title II would apply, or would it be inside the retail segment?
Mozilla is thought to have been one of the influences that has suggested this move as a solution and even in its blogs on the subject there is no absolute clarity about how the rules might work.
If Comcast is supplying a wholesale service, whereby it brings traffic from Netflix, what will it charge for this and could it still slow it down once it is on the “other” side of its network, without this being part of the wholesale delivery?
And if Netflix is going to the trouble of building the CDN, and bypassing the internet, isn’t it the company that is doing the wholesale work? Why should it pay to connect when it gets there. And what happens to all the traffic that is passed using peering arrangements, are they given the same treatment as something that was sent wholesale?
If the FCC opts to only apply the Title II classification to wholesale it would have to provide answers to all these questions or it will have the same potential to be reversed in a US court as its previous net neutrality rule-making was.
As it is, the move looks like an attempt to appease the public which has crashed the FCC website multiple times due to the volume of complaints filed in the wake of the Comcast-TWC merger news. This hybrid approach lacks details and may lack teeth, and until we see the FCC make a successful intervention over an ISP, one which is not thrown out by a court, this approach will remain in the dock.
The fear is that double-dipping becomes the norm where Comcast can charge Netflix and its clients for delivering the same data, with only one side of the equation regulated.
And we come back to this idea that the report mentions 3 other possible plans. So is this an orchestrated leak to gauge public reaction? The backlash inspired should give chairman Wheeler a pretty big hint about the general public mood; consumers may well want Title II reclassification. However all politically aware Americans will be opposed to anything that implies MORE, rather than LESS regulation around the internet.