It was the language it was couched in, as much as the actual data that was requested, which seems to suggest that the FCC’s latest call for data from Comcast comes with a big dollop of disapproval.
This week the FCC asked for data relating to bundling success rates, churn of bundled customers, the sell through rates of extra services, a list of other pay TV operators who have contracted for Comcast owned cable channels and separately for its NBC content, how much business those channels do with Online Video Providers and what on earth is it doing with Canoe ventures and who else can use Canoe’s technology.
These questions will lead directly to the objections which opponents to the merger between Comcast and Time Warner Cable have been pointing to over the past weeks and months as they attempt to pull down and discredit this merger. We have to say, we are largely in agreement with these critics.
Beyond this the questions ask outright if Comcast would like to hang itself completely over the terms of its purchase of NBC.
The lengthy list of questions includes a request to list any agreements to acquire programming since January, 2011, which contained provisions forbidding, or in any way limiting the provision of the same programming to OVDs. This is completely against the terms which the FCC imposed when Comcast was allowed to acquire NBC and we think it’s rather subtle.
There are so many people against the merger that the entire content community is probably happy to share the terms of confidential deals if it means this deal will go away. So Comcast cannot be sure that the FCC is not “already” aware of multiple occasions when it may have broken at least the spirit of the NBC deal, if not the word.
If Comcast does not own up to an instance, it risks an FCC “fait accompli” in that if it says it HAS such contracts, the FCC could say that it does not observe its agreements and so the merger is off, and if it says no, but the FCC has evidence of such an instance it might say the deal is off and here’s a bloody great fine for lying to us. It forces Comcast to take a long hard look at whether or not it has truly observed the terms of the NBC deal, something which has been broadly denied by the community at large.
If Comcast has not observed the letter of its agreements, that would lead to there being some form of monitoring required for any similar deal, which would involve someone with access to internal management meetings, reporting to the FCC over observance of terms – at least this is what would happen in Europe, we’re not so sure in the US.
When this was the case with IBM in the 1970s, it led to the creation of a new internal team called Business Practices, which had to report to the Justice Department on any new form of business contracts inside IBM for years. IBMers universally said that Business Practices made the company less competitive and employees lived in awe of the department and feared coming within its ambit. Anyway some “observer role” may have to be written into the deal.
The FCC did not stop there, but also asked Comcast to hang itself over dealings with the public, including but not limited to the ongoing scripts that were highlighted so ably by a YouTube conversation that was recorded with a Comcast help desk employee, who simply refused to cancel service for a customer, despite him asking repeatedly.
The other customer care issues it wants to know about are what are people instructed to say when a customer of Netflix or any OTT service like it, calls up and says his Comcast broadband line is too slow, blaming Comcast for problem. The suggestion is that there may be evidence that Comcast tells customers it is because Netflix is technically inferior or too slow, and if that’s the case, and yet it has forced Netflix to pay it cash to improve that connection, it would have been misleading its customers.
Again it’s no good if Comcast shreds all the evidence, because those phone calls may well have been recorded and sit on YouTube servers to contradict it. So what does happen, asks the FCC, when a customer expresses their intent to discontinue their Internet Access Service subscription because of concerns about viewing a rival OVD service?
Has Comcast ever agreed to supply content to Dish, Amazon, Sony, Intel, Apple, Google or Verizon Communications for distribution via mobile or the Internet. And if not why not? The FCC plans to find out, and given that each of these will, or already operates an OTT service, if Comcast has never supplied them or supplied them on tougher terms than everyone else, the FCC can ask why and create a remedy for it.
The FCC wants to know if Comcast has cut deals with the major broadcast channels, which of course it has, including CBS, Disney, Discovery, Viacom, , 21st Century Fox, Univision, Time Warner, NBC Universal and many others and wants to know what happens to those deals if these channels are provided over an alternative distribution method and what broadcast window they are given and what Most Favored Nation clauses are in those contracts? It also wants to know shared advertising arrangements with all the major broadcasters and pay TV rivals who own their own TV channels and whether or not these also deal with Canoe Ventures.
If I was a senior Comcast executive and I couldn’t let these deals be known to the world at large, because there was some breach of the NBC deal or some promise broken to the FCC, then I would give up on Time Warner Cable and tell the FCC I no longer want to do the deal. If Comcast has put one foot wrong anywhere along this road, we suspect it will fuel already adamant opposition to the Comcast Time Warner Cable deal, and give the FCC an excuse to kill it, and publicly denounce Comcast at the same time.
There remains a chance that the FCC collects all this data and still feels like going ahead with merger clearance with some conditions. Among those conditions might be the same list as those which applied to the Liberty Global Ziggo merger in the Netherlands, in Europe.
To remind you, the merged entity had to remove any clauses for the next 8 years in content contracts that prevent a TV channel from both selling to LGI-Ziggo AND going on its own Over the Top or to OTT partners. It said that LGI-Ziggo could not block content, and must provide adequate interconnection capacity for OTT services and it said it must sell off a movie channel because it was too dominant in movies.
Apply that to Comcast and it gives Netflix its connection money back and speeds up the connections to Netflix, and it takes out that “you and no-one else can ever deliver this over the internet” clause from almost every content contract it has. It may also have to sell off parts of NBCUniversal.
Then the FCC may allow the largest force in US broadband history to be created, hobbled by Net Neutrality consent rules. But right now the FCC and Congress (see other story in this issue) are trying other ways to solve the Neutrality debate, and if they find a way, then the FCC will no longer need to curry favor with Comcast in such a way, and might just choose to block the deal anyway.