Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

3 April 2014

FCC moves swiftly to open up more 5GHz for WiFi

The FCC this week has signed a ruling which increases the radiated power that can be applied in parts of the 5 GHz unlicensed spectrum, removed the indoor only requirements in the 100 MHz from 5.150-5.250 GHz band and extended the 5.8 GHz band by an extra 25 MHz ,from a prior 5.825 GHz upper limit to 5.85 GHz. Some of this is in keeping with other regimes across the world, while others come as a result of two key things ‘ cable industry lobbying pressure and a period of experience where no real complaints against unlicensed usage have been upheld.

In the rulings each and every case of interference registered in the past has now been attributed to equipment that was either faulty or which did not adhere to the standard, proving that unlicensed spectrum works and is safely managed.

And with that, all of the FCC commissioners promised to make at least another 195 MHz of further spectrum available in the 5 GHz band, along with the creation of more unlicensed spectrum use in the 3.5 GHz band and in 600 MHz spectrum, being freed up under FCC incentive by broadcasters.

Today’s order allows WiFi equipment to target above 1 Gbps performance in operation and as further chunks of spectrum are made available, it could one day reach double that.

There are a few important things to take away from this move. Firstly that the rest of the world will mostly follow. WiFi spectrum is not unified, but there is a commitment across the globe for regulators to try their best to make it easy to export devices from one part of the world to another, with minimal adjustment. Where this has not yet been done in other parts of the world, it will follow. Secondly the speed at which this came about shows that those lobbying in favor of WiFi are strong and the economic benefits of having lots of unlicensed spectrum for WiFi and other technologies, are measurable and good for any country issuing more.

Thirdly this sends a message to the cellular community that the water is fine, come on in. Efforts, led by Qualcomm, to demonstrate 4G in this same unlicensed spectrum is one way to go, pushing WiFi out of its own space by major multinational MNOs building out 4G in some territories. This is still legal and is likely to remain technically legal, but it looks to us like this will be largely frowned upon. The cellular community, if it were to offer 4G in this spectrum, would crush down the effectiveness of this new spectrum, by creating interference (despite what Qualcomm says) and by making investment in WiFi less profitable.

This order from the FCC makes it clear that MNOs would be welcome to build out their own WiFi, but then like all WiFi, it needs to be for the benefit of everyone, not a single MNO customer base. This powerful WiFi lobbying community would explode if 4G limited its options to a single MNO in any of the major western territories.

While the IEEE 802.11ac standard is still in its infancy, the large 80 MHz and 160 MHz slices of spectrum that it can commandeer leave little left for neighboring Access Points, especially in areas where WiFi also has to avoid radar systems. This extra will make it easier for two or more systems to co-exist without reducing the effectiveness of the standard, something that is vital as the world shifts to the ac variant which is entirely 5.0 GHz focused.

The chances are many chip vendors will be able to retrofit this into their designs with a few tiny modifications, possibly in software. However devices that have already shipped may need to be replaced or at least returned to base for amendment, since we can’t imagine this can all be done via a remote software update.

As the 3.5 MHz option comes into play, we expect completely new equipment will need to be designed and that combinations of 5GHz, 3.5GHz and 2.4 GHz will need to be approved within the WiFi standards bodies.

Any spectrum freed up within the US 600 MHz range is not likely to be accommodated globally, as this is still being used for TV broadcast or has been shifted to cellular already, so this may well only appear on the far horizon, at a point when WiFi starts to run out of steam in the future.

Right now the industry can easily accommodate these changes and the next 195 MHz that the FCC thinks can be made available, and after that there may need to be a radical period of innovation in unlicensed spectrum. For instance there exist today outdoor combinations which use 2.4 GHz for connections to devices and 5 GHz for self-backhaul, and by adding 3.5 GHz to this the combinations become more complex, and compelling for mesh networks in particular.