Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

12 October 2005

Finland ushers in WCT inspired law on copyright

Finland is the latest country to enact the WIPO Copyright Treaty (WCT) into local legislation. WIPO is the World Intellectual Property Organization and it built the WCT with 179 signatories based on the US Digital Millenium Copyright Act, a piece of legislation that we have always felt is fatally flawed.

The UK and about a third of Europe have passed laws that adhere to the treaty. The key difference is that any legislation based on the WCT makes it illegal to break copy protection on a piece of content, even if it is for legal purposes and even if it is trivial to achieve.

It was the lack of such legislation in Norway that made safe from prosecution the famous (infamous?) DVD Jon, then a 14 year old Norwegian schoolboy (in the end). He put a simple bypass program he’d written called DeCSS onto web sites for people to download to break copy protection on DVDs. He said he did it because he wanted to play the content on his Linux system.

The Finnish government says it does not plan to pursue users who circumvent DRM technologies for personal use and has suggested to the music and film industries that they won’t get much joy in a courtroom for doing so. But it is unlikely that this will stop the Recording Industry Association of America, which were effectively the authors of the legislation (through the US Patent and Trade Mark Office).

The flaw in the DMCA is that personal use copying is enshrined as a right in most legal frameworks, and the DMCA makes this impossible so the laws contradict each other.