Talk this week that Apple is finally getting its iTunes video effort into gear falls well short of the mark. Apple has put its first movie on the system by turning to its favorite content company, Disney.
US newspapers and some specialist Apple web sites were reporting this week that Apple would put the Disney Channel film “High School Musical” onto iTunes for a $9.99 download price.
Technically, although this is a movie, it is really a made for TV movie and the music soundtrack is already a big seller on iTunes, so it was a natural step for Apple to put it onto iTunes. The movie has gone out on iTunes prior to its DVD release.
Four months ago, when the video iPod was launched, Faultline was hugely disappointed, and remains that way. We thought that Apple had a genuine shot at tying up the video market in one go, in the same way that it tied up the music market, but felt that it missed its chance.
We criticized it at the time for not shooting for the movie market and today Apple has made almost no progress here, focusing instead on ‘catch up TV’ itself a highly lucrative market, but one that is also suited to web TV services. It’s pretty obvious, given the price of $9.99 that movies would be more than welcome on iTunes, but they haven’t yet materialized.
At the launch we asked ‘Would all the movie studios call Apple CEO Steve Jobs the day after the video iPod launch and ask to join in?’ and the answer is that they haven’t called.
Compare this success with the success that Sony has had with the PSP in films, selling them on its proprietary Universal Media Disc format, tiny DVD like devices that power video on the PlayStation Portable.
Already they make up 1% of video sales in the UK, and up to 6% for some specific titles.
Sony said that it had shipped around 15 million UMD units and 10 million PSPs worldwide, making an average of 1.5 UMD units shipped per console.
More recently some Studios have said that for any given video this has been less successful, simply because they are under Sony’s projections, but these volumes have been achieved with just a few hundred UMDs available on the market. Sony is also known to be working towards a new version of its Connect platform to deliver videos over broadband lines.
Its true that film negotiations take a long time, longer than music, and that only four months have gone by since the launch, but Apple had a full two years prior to work towards this goal, and the simple fact is that Steve Jobs completely underestimated this market and never set his teams working on it early enough. As a result other businesses are negotiating for films at the same time as Apple, rather than a year or two too late. These include all the video file downloading systems that have been launched or announced since January including services from Starz, Google, Sony, Clear Channel, 4Flix, Blinkx, AOL, Arvato, LoveFilm, BSkyB, NTL and DirecTV, plus the rumor that Amazon is about to conclude a deal to offer its own service later this year, as are Blockbuster and NetFlix
So Apple may miss the market despite there being more iPods than any other handheld device. However, the truth is that less than 20% of new iPods are video capable, and that most iTunes video is watched on the PC, not the iPod. The same thing cannot be said of the Sony PSP because they are all video capable and the UMD ONLY plays on the PSP.
One Apple watching web site concluded that Apple is widely expected to offer an iTunes Movie service in the coming weeks, but we can’t believe that one movie would jump ahead of the rest. Jobs would want to make a big splash by launching such a service and it is more likely that his film has leaked out to suggest that Apple is only days away from such a launch, when in fact it could still be months and months before he has enough content to launch a film service and even then will have to share the content with every other web video and downloading service.
One of the biggest issues for Apple, and for others, is going to be whether or not the downloading experience is as good for a server based system as for a Peer to peer system, which some film services are launching.
The “High School Musical” file takes up around half a Gigabyte and others are suggesting that this is just a one off for Apple and Disney to explore ways of doing business together. We like this explanation and see it as more likely than the imminent movie service idea.
The movie studios will have spoken to the big record labels and can see the downside, as well as the upside, of working with iTunes. The downsides will focus on not ceding the market to a single player, so that the studios can retain their control over price.
Increasingly we see the various studios aligning themselves with particular technology approaches to start with ‘ Disney with Apple; Warner with AOL and Microsoft; CBS with Google etc’ When there is a conspicuous success, like Sony’s PSP, all the studios will work with it.