The most pro-telco FCC in years is facing a major test of its commitment to competition and universal broadband, under what conditions it approves the merger of AT&T and BellSouth. Merger will bring the enlarged AT&T broader coverage and increased control of broadband access and cellular backhaul lines and significant restrictions on the deal seem unlikely. The addition of a new Republican commissioner recently gives that party, which has generally opposed stringent conditions on mergers, a majority in the FCC. Indeed, the only merger restriction that could dent their power and that seems even remotely likely to be imposed by the current Commission, would be divestiture of their broadband wireless spectrum holdings, a measure that any sane regulator should be urgently considering.
Such a condition would be relatively easy to impose, since broadband wireless is a minute part of the current AT&T business, but would provide a real boost to competitors seeking to offer an all-wireless alternative. It was among the suggestions of various lobbyists, including a group of carriers and backbone providers – among the thousands of entities commenting on the proposed merger ‘ which also made the sweeping case that AT&T was creating a monopoly and ‘quickly reassembling the old Bell System.
The FCC needs to say that enough is enough, and stop the incessant effort of AT&T to reestablish its nationwide wireline monopoly by using monopoly profits to gobble up its competitors, rather than by competing for customer loyalty through innovation and service.” This was the comment of Heather Gold, senior vice president of government relations at XO Communications, which was supported by Cbeyond Communications, Grande Communications, NuVox Communications, Supra Telecom, Talk America, and Xspedius Communications.
Other objectors demanded that AT&T/BellSouth should be forced to sell their jointly owned mobile arm Cingular ‘ highly unlikely, and an almost certain deal breaker, given the focus of all large operators on mobilizing their triple plays. The sell-off of the 2.3GHz and 2.5GHz spectrum holdings, suited to broadband wireless, is a far more realistic demand and is backed by the Consumers Union, Consumer Federation of America and many operators.
It may seem relatively trivial, but would actually have potentially far reaching consequences and could help Sprint Nextel to remain a genuine contender to AT&T. When Sprint and Nextel themselves merged last year, opponents called for the divestiture of their huge 2.5GHz spectrum holdings ‘ a demand that was not met, although the combined company was mandated to build a broadband wireless network in the spectrum by 2009, with coverage targets.
This was one of the FCC’s better rulings of the past year, since it set the scene for Sprint to create a viable alternative to the telcos, using its combination of cellular and broadband wireless networks and its joint venture with four major cablecos. But similar latitude should not be given to AT&T in the broadband wireless spectrum issue. Indeed, forcing the giant Bellco to divest its 2.3GHz/2.5GHz holdings ‘ which could then be acquired by a challenger such as Sprint itself or Clearwire ‘ would go some way to redressing the balance of competition.
The two telcos have significantly less broadband wireless spectrum than Sprint Nextel, but both have deployments already in place using pre-WiMAX technology and plans to use such networks to move into territories where they own no wires, and to boost enterprise backhaul services.
Removing these assets would not seriously impact their future revenues, though it would make it more expensive for them to extend their reach still further ‘ at least until Cingular’s HSDPA network becomes suited to true broadband access. But it would put the spectrum into play for an operator that could make far better use of it, by combining it with existing holdings. Sprint Nextel ‘ if permitted by the FCC ‘ or Clearwire could add the licenses to their war chest to enhance their already realistic ability to create a wireless-only quadruple play that could provide genuine competition to Bellco services. Sprint Nextel itself was less focused, in its objections, on the 2.3GHz frequencies and more on the issue of control of backhaul ‘ the cost of which is often the biggest single factor in a cellular or broadband wireless business model.
The operator argues that the $67bn merger will have an extremely negative effect on ‘special access’- dedicated backhaul lines linking base stations and mobile switching centers. ‘The merger of AT&T and Bell- South will maintain and strengthen the combined company’s incentive to use its dominance in the provision of special access to disadvantage its wireline rivals as well as the commercial mobile radio service competitors of Cingular Wireless,’ said Robert Foosaner, Sprint Nextel’s senior vice president of government affairs.
Sprint Nextel believes it will be at an even greater disadvantage if Cingular does not have to compete nationwide for special access services. ‘If it approves the proposed combination the FCC must adopt remedial measures to ensure that competitive local exchange carriers and CMRS providers obtain access to reasonably priced special- access services they need in order to compete with the merged company,’ said Foosaner.
These companies have already won significant victories in protecting their position in wireline broadband, effectively driving independent ISPs such as Earthlink out of this sector, since regulatory changes allowed the Bells to charge virtually anything they like for access to their broadband networks ‘ which has created a far more closed market than in freer regions such as unbundled Europe. This policy revealed an FCC under current chief Kevin Martin that regards the cablecos as the main competitive restraint on the Bells, in contrast to the former administration under Michael Powell, which was far more aware of the need to stimulate further competition to both these groups, primarily via broadband wireless.
The ability to make access to their infrastructure cost prohibitive has strengthened the Bellcos in broadband, but this is not the only area where they hold this advantage. Another less publicized asset ‘ but one that will be increasingly important as mobile networks take their place as equal partners with DSL/cable in the quadruple play model ‘ is control of the backhaul lines.
Sprint Nextel is heading opposition to the AT&T/BellSouth merger, on the basis that this will place this crucial aspect of telecoms in the hands of a virtual duopoly, and enable the enlarged telco to discriminate against rivals that are seeking to compete with its mobile arm, Cingular, or ‘ like Sprint ‘ to use radio networks to create a wireless-only alternative to the AT&T wireline triple play. The Bell companies have long argued that the 1996 Telecommunications Act discriminated against them in favor of the cablecos, allowing the latter to become a potent competitive challenge by easing regulations on them and permitting them to enter the telephone business. However, the same changes are now enabling Verizon and AT&T to enter the television business, challenging the cablecos with IPTV just as the other television threat, from satellite operators DirecTV and Echostar, is also gaining in power.
The proposed new Telecommunications Act, which just passed through the House of Representatives, establishes a national video franchise that will enable broadcast providers to bypass local authorities in introducing their services ‘ a measure that will primarily benefit the Bellcos, since they are the new entrants to TV, and have frequently complained that their efforts have been hindered by local governments. As the Bells plan to add television to their existing bundles of telephony, broadband access and mobile services, the cablecos’ missing piece is wireless, a gap four of them ‘ Time Warner Cable, Comcast, Cox and Advance/Newhouse – are addressing in the short term through an MVNO deal with Sprint Nextel.
In the medium term this will be expanded by using Sprint’s 2.5GHz build-out for enhanced mobile triple play offerings, and by acquiring new spectrum, potentially in the upcoming AWS auctions and the January 2008 sale of 700MHz licenses. All four cablecos are now trialling wireless offerings and Cox Communications’ president Patrick Esser told last week’s GlobalComm conference in Chicago that it would launch commercial services later this year. Cox will offer a multi-tiered tariff, with high bandwidth services such as video streaming carrying higher rates than simple ones such as mobile email.
The current climate at the FCC suggests that only minor concessions will be made to the Sprint argument, in terms of limiting the ability of the Bellcos to set their own rates for access to their backhaul infrastructure. In the absence of intervention from the regulator, the increasingly narrow choice of backhaul providers outside the Bell camp ‘ combined with the exploding requirement for cellular, WiMAX and Wi-Fi network backhaul created by new build-outs and rising bandwidth usage ‘ there will be a boom for the few remaining independents, and an accelerated shift towards wireless.
As with the broadband access issue, which is increasingly driving companies like EarthLink to adopt a wireless alternative to serve their customers, any signs of greed on the part of AT&T will, long term, come back to bite it, since they will drive wireless operators to adopt approaches that could prove highly competitive with Cingular.
The vision of a wireless backlash, as epitomized by Sprint Nextel, hoisting the Bells by their own petard may be an attractive one for those who believe the US market needs greater competition and innovation in telecoms. But short term, only a few very strong players will be able to survive the inherent disadvantages of competing with AT&T and Verizon, whatever the infrastructure choice. Control of the backhaul not only enables these operators to make life expensive for competitors but gives Cingular and Verizon Wireless access to backhaul at extremely competitive rates.
With the rising use of 3G and data services boosting backhaul capacity requirements threefold in the next two years, and this expense already accounting for about one-third of opex costs for a cellco, the economic advantage will be huge ‘ and increasingly important as mobile operators are forced to open up their networks to the open internet, creating higher levels of usage (often of services such as VoIP that generate no direct incremental revenue for the carrier). In this situation, low cost bases will be all important to preserve margin, and with its control of infrastructure and economies of scale, the enlarged AT&T will have a huge head start.