The Wall Street Journal is perhaps the only publication which has sufficient weight to chase around the Comcast side of the bidding war for Fox and get some kind of “off the record” comment from somewhere – it tells us that Comcast is making plans to outbid Disney, and then getting ready to bid once again, if necessary, with $90 billion or so being mentioned at the top end of the bidding, and private equity firms support being lined up to that level. The current bidding is just over $71 billion.
This has come the day after a Fox-leaked confirmation that the Department of Justice will offer approval for the existing $71 billion Disney bid, as long as it is prepared to sell off the 22 regional sports networks within 3 months of closing.
This deal has several more rounds to go with US financial analysts firmly believing that Disney has a better plan of what to do with the Fox assets – take on Netflix globally – than Comcast, which has not articulated any kind of plan to go international, except via traditional broadcasting. In fact CEO Brian Roberts lacked credibility when he first talked about bidding separately for Sky in the UK, saying that he had got the idea from a London taxi driver, and essentially saying that he had never noticed what a good proposition Sky had in Europe before then.
If you agree that Robert’s real motivation for bidding for the 61% of Sky that Fox does not hold, is to damage or kill the Fox-Disney deal, then it is because Robert’s really wants the content assets in the US, not distribution assets in Europe and potentially as far away as India.
But timescales now are getting tight – and while involved in a bidding war, bidders are not allowed to talk to one another – to prevent price collusion – so the idea that actually Comcast really wants Sky, and Disney really wants Fox – is hard to test in that environment, but we think it would be a cinch to let Disney win the main prize and then swoop in and buy what it wants off a debt encumbered Disney. So we think it’s not that simple.
Comcast seems set on winning the main prize and doing so without a clear strategy that it is articulating to the public – perhaps it is clearer what it’s up to in investment circles, but our guess is that this is all about the US market and dominant content control to protect it from AT&T, now that it has bought Time Warner – and not about internationalization at all. There are genuine problems going down that route.
Netflix has made it clear that it might cost if $100 million to create a new original series in the US, for the US, but only $1 million to create one in India for the Indian market. But it can then export that Indian product or Polish or French or Spanish product, around its international markets, and use the margins to underpin the costs of those US programs it makes. Essentially the average cost of programming to Netflix is going down the more international it gets, while the reverse is true for a Disney-Fox merger, which makes almost all its content in the US. That would also be true of an NBC-Universal Fox merger. If Netflix is the target, then this is the wrong strategy for both companies.
For Comcast to make more content for the US, to dominate in skinny bundles and use Xfinity for distribution, makes a lot more sense, and offering its technology and content in partnerships to a captive North American cable market, will work.
When investors hear that the Disney plan is global conquest in markets it only operates in through third parties, investors may not be keen to go the extra mile and we suspect that Comcast is not articulating any such outcome. Instead it can partner with Netflix, offering it content assets, but demand a reasonably high price, because it would become the largest Netflix supplier. The Disney plan seems to starve Netflix out – a strategy that we feel is sure to backfire.
There is talk that the existing Disney Fox deal could be cleared officially by the DoJ in 3 weeks and completed in 3 months. So Comcast would be ill-advised to take too long over its next bid. On the basis that a deal in the hand is worth more, especially one that has cleared DOJ approval, it will take a price per share of at least $42 to gain the Fox investor attention and currently it is sitting at $48 so investors expect more still. Especially with a castrated FCC led by a non-interfering Chairman, so expect no public interest support from that quarter.
There is a lot of suspicion around a DoJ that can make such statements. Letting a company like AT&T which had zero percent of the content market, buy say 20% of it through Time Warner, is one thing – but letting a company that already has 20% of that market and let it add another 20% – giving it dominant control, is entirely another and likely to lead to a market skew. So why the hurry. All the talk about Comcast being a more difficult regulatory purchaser is nonsense – it is precisely the same. Whichever deal gets approval by the DoJ, the European Commission is not going to give it the same treatment.
Netflix is close to meeting the new European directive that 30% of its content must be made in Europe, but any combination of NBC-Universal and Fox or Disney and Fox is going to be a long way from that balance, operating at a huge disadvantage in Europe, with punitive tariffs a certainty.
Sure it might help in a purely US SVoD, but not in the markets where Netflix is currently flying – international.
But the questions don’t end there. What does Verizon do about the content dominance of AT&T – it should buy a US studio or broadcaster. What does Sony do about its movie and TV series subsidiary in the US – how does it shore up this content business? How does CBS compete on an equal footing against companies with a bigger spend than it can now manage? Who does it partner with, and who will give anything for Viacom content? And who can possibly buy those local sports channels from Fox? Comcast cannot do it, it has its own Sports assets to protect, so another sports giant may emerge.
This bidding war, and the answers to those questions above and others surrounding US broadcasting (the Sinclair Tribune broadcasting deal), will change and potentially damage the US content industry far more than the emergence of Netflix – the first challenge to its complacency since Sony bought into the market in 1989.
And an industry which is in thrall to an incumbent US President, and which consolidates into fewer and fewer assets, will find itself dangerously easy to manipulate politically. Then we’ll really have some fake news.