Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

15 December 2011

France picks over regulatory bones of connected TV

Internet connected TVs are booming in France, accounting for over 30% of TVs sold now and growing fast, all of which has led to equally rapidly increasing regulatory scrutiny. This has culminated in a very weighty report just published by the Ministries of Culture, Industry and Digital, assembled by a distinguished sounding group including Marc Tessier, former head of state broadcaster France Television and current owner of Video Futur. Also on the commission was Fr’d’ric Mitterrand, current Minister of Culture and Communication, and nephew of Fran’ois Mitterrand, France’s longest serving president, and the only socialist one in modern times.

This connection is relevant in the sense that this connected report has more than a whiff of socialism, nationalism and xenophobia in its expressed concerns for protection of French content creation against invasion by ‘international actors’ that fail to respect French and European obligations, and for preservation of the French cultural heritage. There is also some rather topical emphasis on France acting in combination with European partners to regulate online video service providers more effectively than any country can on its own. The report urges Europe to take a unified stance on connected TV and avoid any temptation to impose regulations that favor anyone’s interests at the expense of others. This may be playing to the gallery, since in practice most EU member states are good at talking the language of European consensus while actually acting in their national interest. The UK is an exception in that it does not even do the talk well.

Drilling down into the report reveals a pragmatic and honest assessment of the issues and problems involved regulating connected TV. At the heart of the issue is a tension between the desire and arguably need to extend existing rules to connected TV, and the impracticability of achieving this via current regulatory mechanisms. Most reasonable people would agree that that there needs to be some protection for minors against undesirable content, but they would also concede this cannot be done by enforcing the traditional 9pm watershed that used to work in the old days when there were only one or two broadcasters in the land. It is also impractical in an era when a lot of the content is produced outside the country and accessed from multiple platforms and devices. So issues like minors’ protection can only be tackled effectively through international cooperation and to some extent through voluntary agreements among leading global players including social networking sites.

The report says that the emergence of connected TV provides an opportunity and incentive to harmonize national legislation within EU member states not just with European regulatory rules or tools, but also at an international level. The time is over when a country can regulate in isolation over broadcasting and TV, the report insists.

Presumably then the French media regulator CSA is hoping it will achieve international agreement for its plans to extend existing broadcasting rules to online platforms under five core headings. These can be defined loosely as protection for minors, protection for consumers when purchasing content or products, media plurality, obligation for operators to reinvest profits derived from creative works in content production, and support for co-regulation. These will all be more complex to enforce and administer in a connected TV world. Media plurality to ensure that diversity of ownership is maintained will involve examining more intricate inter-relationships between the various players, given the existence of quad play services, and deals between smart TV makers and content creators.

The issue of co-regulation is interesting as it implies that the rules to some extent will be made up as we go along and cannot be known in advance. Co-regulation means mutual evolution in the light of experience and in the case of connected TV makes sense to the extent that some of the issues, threats and opportunities will become clearer when mature services exist.

The CSA also emphasized the need to protect the French movie industry, but to some extent this is addressed by the other rules, such as obligation on distributors to reinvest profits derived from creative content.

At the same time the report did highlight the risk that overzealous regulation could also damage a country’s fledgling connected TV business and as a result fall behind competitors. It drew attention to the UK experience with Project Kangaroo, which has become part of that country’s connected TV folklore. Kangaroo was supposed to be launched in 2008 as an online joint venture between BBC Worldwide, Channel 4 and ITV, but after vehement opposition from the UK’s leading pay TV operator BSkyB was blocked by the Competition Commission. The verdict was that the joint venture would be too much of a threat to competition in this developing market and therefore had to be killed at birth, based on the fact that the three partners between them controlled virtually all UK originated broadcast content, save primarily for the sports transmitted by BSkyB.

Incidentally Kangaroo did not die there, since the founding triumvirate sold it to digital terrestrial company Arqiva for about £8 million, and it was rebranded as SeeSaw. This launched with licensed content in early 2010 with the claim it was attracting 2 million users a month, but then Channel 4 and Channel Five pulled their programs from the site. It was acquired from Arqiva by the Criterion Media Group in July 2011 but the agreed investment was never actually forthcoming and the service was finally closed down in October 2011.

Channel 4 and Channel Five struck the death blow to SeeSaw because they were now involved in Kangaroo’s true successor code named Project Canvas, to be launched in February 2012 as YouView. This has met almost equally strong opposition from BSkyB, but with the crucial difference that this time the Competition Commission has not agreed with them. The Commission has deemed that because for YouView the broadcasters involved, that is the BBC, ITV, Channel 4 and Channel 5, are not making it their platform for accessing their on demand content, it does not threaten competition. Whereas Kangaroo was pitched as a content aggregator, YouView is an Internet connected platform, including a specification for building compliant set top boxes enabling TVs to access web based content.

It is interesting to consider the French view set out in the connected TV report, since it used Kangaroo as an example of the dangers rather than benefits of regulation, indicating it showed how competition regulation could hinder the development of connected TV.

Yet the Competition Commission verdict was supposed to do the opposite and stimulate diversity by removing a source of near monopoly control over premium sourced content. Indeed BSkyB continued to argue that the BBC should not be allowed to go on spending public money on a platform that as a result can compete unfairly with the private sector, although it has now dropped the original argument that it was monopolizing primary online content. BSkyB has lost this argument, but there are still concerns over the fact that the UK is going it alone over connected TV, just as in other matters relating to Europe. In particular the UK’s Intellect Technology Association has stated to the BBC Trust that Project Canvas risks isolating the UK as a ‘technological island’ in a global market by trying to create a standard IPTV set-top box just for that country. This association is a trade body representing UK consumer electronics (CE) vendors and so does have a vested interest in promoting common standards that reduce costs for its members, but nonetheless YouView does risk being left behind as the Hybrid TV Broadcast (HbbTV) platform gathers force in Europe.

This connected TV report has plenty of French ambiguity, but the message is that clumsy regulation should be avoided. Yet the report is wrong to imply that Kangaroo could have delivered on its promise in 2009 for it would have been delayed anyway for technical reasons, just as YouView was. The French too will find that making connected TV into a full broadcast quality service will not be easy.