Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

20 December 2006

France says yes to DTT HD, UK says ok if you can afford spectrum

France’s telecom regulator CSA said this week that it will look at putting high definition programming onto its digital terrestrial system, with the first legal steps being reviewed in early 2007. In the meantime UK regulator Ofcom said that it would not put aside extra spectrum for the same purpose for UK broadcasters, and made it clear that they can bid at auction for the re-purposed UHF TV spectrum as it is retired by analog TV, along with cellular and satellite operators and anyone else that wants to bid.

UK auctions will begin as each part of local spectrum is vacated from 2008 through to 2012.

However the French CSA said that HD must find a place on the new French terrestrial system as it will become the standard for all TV eventually. The implication is that it will ring fence low priced spectrum in the huge UHF range for TV services, mostly between 470 and 700 MHz.

Channel 36, the only remaining UHF channel that is not used for analog TV, is being courted by the big UK mobile operators which want to swap it from airport radar to be used for mobile TV. Mobile TV needs to be unified in UHF to get the full benefits of equipment scale across Europe, whereas radar is a one off equipment cost. That process will take years, require compensation, and equipment replacement and a new suitable spectrum for the radar and the agreement of the British Airports Authority, all of which could take as long as 3 years. Broadcasters would like the same channel to be used for HDTV, but it would only provide one or two HD channels at best and economically it’s unlikely that broadcasters could bid against the powerful cellular lobby.

The decision contrasts with that of the UK’s Ofcom, which this week announced it is prepared to leave the allocation of the spectrum achieved through the digital dividend to market forces.

In order to bring HDTV to the UK’s Freeview digital terrestrial network, broadcasters will have to pay for valuable spectrum, and that will mean that it will have to charge for the HDTV and not be able to offer it free to air, as will now be likely in France.