Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

4 December 2014

French go alone in online video ad management

While other European audience measurement agencies such as BARB in the UK have been making a lot of noise when it comes to online metrics, France’s Médiamétrie has been creating the biggest waves and gaining the greatest global influence. This is particularly the case for online ad performance, where Médiamétrie has broken ranks with the Internet Advertising Bureau (IAB).

The IAB has been working on new guidelines for assessing the success of online video ad campaigns with the aim of making them more accountable. Médiamétrie’s argument is that neither the traditional currency for measuring linear TV ads nor the common practice adopted for the online non-video world are optimal for Internet video. It fails to give an accurate impression of an ad’s true impact, which may be a combination of immediate actions like click to purchase and longer term viral affects conducted through social media.

The traditional currency for spot ads is the GRP (Gross Ratings Point), which combines the proportion of a target audience reached with the average number of viewings per person. This can be confusing in yielding GRP measures well over 100%. Suppose the target demographic was women aged 18 to 30 and that 40% of them saw an ad, but on average viewed it four times. The GRP would by 4 x 40%, which is 160% or 1.6.

It was quickly appreciated early in the public Internet era that GRPs were hopeless for online ads because they failed to take account of how people engaged with them directly through clicks, which were totally irrelevant in linear TV at the time. Online advertisers wanted post-exposure metrics that measured intent, and either engagement or action. GRPs also failed to account for online media’s targeting capabilities on the basis of immediate user behavior, lifestyle and other factors that go beyond age and gender.

The online world decided to measure advertising impact by impressions, leading to trading on the basis of cost per click, or precisely CPM (cost per thousand impressions delivered). But this has itself become dated as online advertising has grown more sophisticated and embraced video. Now people are watching full length movies and TV shows online, making GRPs more relevant again for measuring the span or reach of a campaign.

This started the quest for an online version of GRP, with the likes of Nielsen and comScore coming up with various methods.  One is the viewability measure, which assesses ads according to whether they were fully loaded to the visible page and not just tucked away in the margin or even “below the fold” of the screen. Another is the validation measure to confirm that an ad has been delivered to the desired target audience. According to comScore both are equally important, because according to a survey it conducted 54% of ads either do not load fully, or turn up in areas of the screen effectively invisible to the viewer.

Neither of these measures impact of an ad that has been properly displayed. This is where Médiamétrie in particular and French TV in general believes it has an edge. The key is to measure viewer completion rates as well, which was not possible before the availability of accurate return path data. The measure is a percentage of the people starting a video ad who finish it.

Canal+ introduced completion rates into its online video player back in 2009, with the initial focus on the number of people watching pre-roll ads through to the finish. This figure can be combined with the traditional GRP measure and also the number of impressions, to yield a currency suitable for trading in cross platform advertising. Canal+ believes such a currency, which has been developed by Médiamétrie, is essential for maintaining pay TV operators’ share of total video advertising spend. In France it is likely to become the compulsory grading currency across video advertising as a whole, spanning broadcast and online TV.

Médiamétrie has now issued a RFP (Request for Proposals) for development of an online version of GRP that can then be made available to all operators and broadcasters. This may not be entirely to the liking of operators, since at present measurement systems tend to exaggerate the impact of ads on online platforms such as YouTube, or in France Daily Motion. A move away from CPMs could therefore reduce the price earned per ad if their assumed impact is downgraded. According to Médiamétrie CPMs over-exaggerate the impact of say a five second pre-roll ad played before a YouTube clip compared with longer commercials shown against a TV show viewed in catch up mode.

Meanwhile Médiamétrie’s leadership in audience measurement has led to some significant contracts abroad. In February 2014, in partnership with Dutch digital watermarking vendor Civolution, Médiamétrie won a contract to supply an audience measurement platform to the Indian Broadcast Audience Research Council (BARC). The two companies have since built the technology framework for BARC’s audience measurement platform, covering around 600 million TV viewers. This has just started giving BARC reasonably accurate measurements of digital TV viewing for the first time. It uses Civolution’s audio watermarking technology for automated identification of content being viewed, feeding Médiamétrie’s TV meter system deployed in selected TV panel households. It provides broadcasters with the sort of data already available in developed markets, including number of households tuning in to a program and time spent watching each piece of content.