Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

28 June 2006

French iTunes law falls at the last hurdle with sensible compromise

After all is said and done, the French National Assembly has reached a compromise on its new copyright law, that is likely to mean that not only does Apple’s iTunes not have to leave France, but the status quo is more or less left unchanged. Sorry to say this, but we told you so.

This was all about French independence of thought, something the French pride themselves on, and anger at being instructed to pass a bill that is largely based on the flawed Digital Millenium Copyright Act. The main new element of that bill, mandated by the European Commission, was that it was actually a crime to breach copyright protection, even if no breach of copyright itself ever occurs.

As a result French thinking introduced the idea that if it was to be illegal to break into DRM, then surely DRMs should interoperate. Not an unreasonable idea on the face of it, but totally unworkable in the modern, mostly proprietary, world. iTunes was only one of the likely casualties, smart cards and TV conditional access would have had to be re-architected across all of France.

In the end the French National Assembly is about to vote on a bill that says that DRM operators can opt out of the interoperability elements of the bill, as long as their content suppliers are happy with their DRM.

The new bill makes breaking a DRM a crime with a maximal penalty of 3 years in prison and fine up to €300,000. Online music and video operators can now make it impossible for anyone to make a free player for their services, and where the technology owner and the operator are the same company, as they are in iTunes, then there is a particularly icy grip on the market.

Apple and others will still have to run the gauntlet of a special French ombudsman style official, yet to be named, who will be able to grant the waiver that confirms content owners are happy with the Apple DRM.