Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

30 June 2011

Google begins to move in the same social Circles as Facebook

News this week that Google is about to enter the Social Networking business, against the growing dominance of Facebook, comes just as most other social networks are either up for sale, as in the case of MySpace, or considering how to make a comeback on the back of the fact that Facebook appears to have saturated.

We wrote a week or so back that this is the first quarter in the US and Europe that Facebook has lost regular users, based on numbers extracted from the Facebook advertising reporting system.

The new Google offering accepts something that older people find fundamentally difficult about Facebook, and this is that you have to create your own differences manually between one group of friends and another. Younger people tend to have a single version of who they are, which everyone is allowed to see, on the strict understanding that their teachers and parents aren’t among those people. Younger people are trying to work out who they are, older people already have split personalities. Older people have issues with this ‘ they may have children and want to manage the level of personal detail they see, they may have sports pals which they share off color jokes with and work mates which would blanch at their home life.

Ask a gay guy who plays football, but who hasn’t come out yet, just how he positions himself on Facebook ‘ to the jocks, to his mother, to his workmates, to his partner – and you’ll see what we mean. Similarly ask a couple who wife swap how they present themselves to their children and their workmates and brothers and sisters? Not all of us can afford to be just one person and in the end everyone is complex and needs a more complex, layered, social tool. Most right now use multiple tools, which is perhaps why there is room for LinkedIn alongside Facebook.

This is why the Google idea for its social network Google+ (Google Plus) intrigues us, because it is based on something it calls Circles and that gets older users over the issue of the bland straightforwardness of Facebook. Just splitting your life into business and leisure you might get a combination of Facebook and LinkedIn, but Google+ promises to make that experience drag and drop, and multi-layered. This will work as long as people are okay with Google knowing this much about them.

Google says in a blog that ‘Not all relationships are created equal. So in life we share one thing with college buddies, another with parents, and almost nothing with our boss,’ and interestingly at Faultline we have phrased it virtually the same with our own criticisms of Facebook in the past. It added, ”today’s online services turn friendship into fast food’wrapping everyone in friend paper’and sharing really suffers.’

Google targets Facebook as sloppy, scary, insensitive and turns conversations into public performances and brings on stage fright and says that the answer is circles, where each circle of friends can be kept apart, offering a different persona, complete with separate messages and images, to each group.

Leaving that aside for a moment we have to look at Google successes and its ability to think outside the box. Search is its obvious success, and Adsense advertising is another. Then there is the massive momentum behind Android and the shift to mobile search, so that Google has managed to invade the operating system space, even when previously dominated by Microsoft and Apple and it has done the same with a browser in Chrome.

Even Google Voice has become a strong telephony option and other initiatives like Google Docs may not be quite so successful, but the people that continue to use it love it. YouTube is one of its biggest successes, and that has a life and direction of its own. Our point is that Google is not a one trick pony and that it has come at technical internet problems in a number of areas and been strong enough and clever enough to carve a space for itself. So is this something that can lead to the downfall of Facebook? Perhaps not, but it could lead to at least another viable alternative.

This could be perhaps more like the Chrome browser, which has garnered a 10% market share in the browser space, not enough to dominate, but enough to prevent browser control leading people away from other Google products, like Android.

Facebook has already shown that it is a threat to Google and to YouTube in particular, when it began showing box office release films through its service, something which is still at the experimental stage. We see this as potentially a huge blow to the Cinema industry. Everyone these days reaches for Facebook or something similar when they are watching video ‘ TV or film, and merging the two experiences into one could mean that Facebook develops a substantial video delivery capability as part of its network. From there to competing with YouTube is not a lot of steps, and Google must be aware of it.

So while Apple, Microsoft and Nokia, all see Google as the enemy, Google itself has nightmares where people don’t ask a search engine what to do any more, but instead ask their friends, through Facebook ‘ hence Google+.

Other features the service will have include Sparks, a feature to create feeds of online content based on the user’s interests, so already video awareness and video recommendation are going to be built in and we can see there may be ways for this to manifest itself on Google TV, as yet not exactly one of Google’s successes, but still full of promise.

Other concepts are Hangouts which allows users to have video chats with up to ten contacts online, which is a direct rip off from Skype and there is already a mobile version of the service ready to go on Android Market, which plays up against Apple’s Facetime app.

This mobile version adds features such as Huddle, for group messaging, and Instant Upload for storing images from a camera to the cloud, competing with Flickr or Ovi or any number of others services, plus locations services to show where you are when you make a post (if you decide to turn that feature on with all the fuss about location data at Apple and Google). So far Google+ starts just as a field trial and is open by invitation only, so could someone please invite us.

As we picked through write ups of the service they fell largely into two schools of thought, those who say that Social Networks are totally different from search and Google should stick to its knitting, and those which say that search is often used when it would be better to ask your friends, (which of these two movies is better?) and so Google would be mad not to get into it. It will be interesting to see how Facebook responds.