So if Google now plans to give away its VoIP and instant messaging client, Google Talk, for free, how is it going to make money out of the service?
The truth is that voice and IM both appear to be loss leaders for the Google Gmail free email service. Google Talk, launched this week, boasts that it doesn’t use irritating screen clutter, allow pop-ups or ads of any kind, but it ties the user’s account into a Gmail account. No Gmail, no Google Talk.
Gmail does allow advertising, although it focuses on relevancy, and reads the content of your email and, like its Google Adsense advertising on member’s web sites, offers only text advertising that is directly relevant to the email user.
It’s probably only a matter of time before Google feels safe enough to do the same with IM and perhaps voice, although it is no mean feat to analyze the content of a spoken conversation (it needs a good voice recognition system) and serve relevant adverts by text to mobile phones.
But right now in beta, both voice and IM are ad free. Google must expect a huge surge in its email revenues on the back of this, although it doesn’t break out its advertising revenues to the extent that you can tell how much came from Gmail.
But what it does break out is how many adverts are served from servers its control and owns, versus those that come from its partners. In the end the cost of providing those services and servers itself is far lower than the payments it has to make to other partners, especially the larger partners.
Those companies that have built up their own brand and web traffic need to charge a hefty price for that traffic, so the margin is less good for Google. It has had to walk the line between fast new advertising serving options through these partnership and building its own direct base. The table above gives an idea of how that’s been progressing at Google.
To some extent it has carefully managed to control the growth of its partnership revenues to be slower than its direct revenues. One of the things that these new products do for Google is places a huge amount of advertising back into its direct category.
Gmail advertising is delivered from servers that Google manages, so if the price of free voice and IM is that customers have to take out a Gmail mailbox, this is unlikely to put potential voice and IM customers off.
The result is like Skype with advertising, delivered by an existing popular brand and similar to Skype, Google is expected to rapidly deliver the ability for calls to leave the VoIP world and enter the PSTN telephone network and the various cellular networks, at dramatically lower prices than existing phone tariffs ‘ possibly using existing wholesalers.
The truth is that Google is unlikely to continue its growth in adverts if it relies purely on the search process. It does that well and leads the market, and while growth in global internet usage is still going up fast, it is closer to 50% growth this year against 100% plus last year. Much of this growth is outside the US, while almost 50% of the world’s advertising is sold within the US. In other words Google needed a new revenue platform to take more of the US market, and this appears to be it.
Watch out for data on the number of sign ups that may begin to emerge over the coming weeks/months, presuming the move is as successful as Google expects.
Google’s original business model consisted of licensing its search engine services to other web sites and it was only in the first quarter of 2000 that it introduced its first advertising program.
In the fourth quarter of the same year Google launched AdWords, adding context sensitive advertising on its web sites and later added AdWords exclusively on a cost-per-click basis. But although it brought out its Adsense service for offering much the same on partner web sites, much later in 2002, by last year this made up 50% of the company’s revenue, until it decided to reign it in so as not to dilute its margin.
Google Talk comes as a downloadable Windows application and key features include what Google describes as superior voice quality through just a computer microphone and speaker, a simple intuitive user interface and a contact list that is shared with Gmail, so there’s no need to maintain different contacts lists.
Google hopes to use Gmail for viral marketing by getting existing Gmail customers to begin inviting others by clicking ‘Add friend’ from the Google Talk interface. Those invited to Google Talk will automatically get a free Gmail account, if they don’t already have one.
Google says that its instant messaging client can talk to other IM clients including those from Trillian, Adium, iChat, GAIM, and Psi.
The company is also working with EarthLink to federate with their Vling communications service and with Sipphone on federating their Gizmo Project.
Another way that Google wants to spread the word of Google Talk is via a mobile phone. US cellphone users can enter their mobile phone number at Gmail and get an invitation code via a text message which enables them to open an account on their phone, presumably using an SMS carrier for the IM portion of the traffic. But it seems unlikely that it will be able to offer VoIP voice over a mobile, since the guaranteed bandwidth is too small. One way it might do this is to offer a service over another company’s network as an MVNO, using the bandwidth mostly as VoIP, but it would be inefficient and offering a cheap MVNO phone using normal cellular voice would be better.
Which leads us nicely onto the major issue which Google has not publicly addressed, which is quality of service. Like Skype, it is offering a free service with no influence over the line or last mile connection. So Google cannot guarantee the quality of that connection or that the voice packets will arrive in the right sequence, or in real time. But if it’s free, then who’s to complain.
Selling VoIP is mostly about brand. Specialist Vonage doesn’t have any special strength or technology, and was simply first into the space and then it has pushed its brand hard. Google would have all the promotion it needs from its own sites, and already has a huge brand.