Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

5 January 2012

Google partially bests Oracle as patents are invalidated

The US Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) has invalidated the majority of an Oracle patent at the heart of its suit against Google over the Android OS. Oracle is expected to appeal the decision. The decision document labels the invalidation as a ‘final response,’ but this doesn’t make it a final ruling and there is an appeals process. With this decision and some earlier invalidations, there have been 27 specific claims that have been preliminarily rejected on re-examination, weakening the Oracle case considerably.

A very important thing to note on these is that the rejections are because of prior art, not obviousness, which means that the claims were rejected because they were already covered by a patent or already in use at the time of their supposed invention. Because of the type of rejection, it is likely that the preliminary re-examination decisions will be upheld. The prior art rejections also give Google an opening to argue against any willful infringement. Google’s attorneys can say that they didn’t believe the patents were valid, and they can use the USPTO decisions as backup. There are still two remaining patents Google has asked to be re-examined in this manner. The re-examination process will likely last another month or two with a full, long trial to follow. In the end of it, if Google loses ‘ most are placing bets on Google losing on at least one point ‘ its next piece of negotiation will be to get Oracle to accept a single payment so it can avoid being charged a fee on every single Android device. This looks even more important as Google’s senior VP for mobile Andy Rubin said that 3.7 million Android devices were activated the weekend of Christmas Eve and Christmas Day.

The spat stems from Java patents and copyrights Oracle gained when it bought out Sun Microsystems, a process that wrapped up in 2010. Android’s framework for apps is based on Java, and there’s a dispute over how Android uses Java. Apps for the mobile OS are written in Java, but the OS uses a virtual machine called Dalvik to run them instead of using the Java Virtual Machine. Dalvik was built specifically for Android because it’s optimized for devices that have battery limitations, a small amount of available RAM and relatively slow processors. The licensing for all of these related patents from Oracle’s Java property are available for free, but the free licensing has specifications that prevent them from being applied because of the use of Dalvik.

Some reports, however, say that the only reason a suit was brought is because of a fight between the two companies that happened because of Google’s decision not to run the mobile variant of Java. The Java mobile edition (Java ME) is only licensed commercially, so the Dalvik variant effectively removed any opportunity Oracle would have had to license Java ME to anyone. In defense of the suit, Google said that Dalvik is a clean room implementation, meaning that it was written completely without looking at Sun’s implementation of Java. Dalvik seems to fit this bill as it was built with portions of previous clean room implementations, most notably one by the Apache Software Foundation. The problem is that Google also added significantly to these existing clean room versions. There is a chance that the work Google did was also clean room code, but Oracle says that the chance is nonexistent since some of the workers on this project for Google were employees who came from Sun. Unfortunately for Google, early testimony from one former Sun employee seems to verify Oracle’s claim. Oracle is suing for both copyright and patent infringement, so Google will continue to argue that any possible infringements were for function not creativity, so the patents Oracle is seeking remedy should not qualify for copyright protection. Now that the trial is coming soon, Google is attempting to invalidate as many Oracle patent claims as possible.