IBC in September provided quite a lot of evidence that encoding, origin servers and CDNs and adaptive bit rate servers, could all come together and lead to a consolidation across the pay TV video equipment community.
Elemental, previously only in encoding, at the time launched its own origin server, something Harmonic had already done in the past, and which included its own just in time packager and unified video management. Edgeware too in September went from a point product supplier to a system supplier, by doing something similar, adding an origin server and cloud storage to what had traditionally been a CDN edge cache product line.
The more we move servers to a generic cloud, the more opportunity there is to overlap with a parallel provider’s area of expertise.
So it makes sense that at some point one of these players were going to add both encryption and key passing, and start up against the DRM specialists, and that’s precisely what Harmonic had tried to do at this year’s CES. Or rather this is the other way around with Harmonic working alongside Microsoft’s existing PlayReady server, and integrating the two.
Harmonic had been very early into this diversification with what is now called its ProMedia range or Origin Multiscreen servers, but which was once acquired as part of Rhozet, way back in 2007. It was that deal which pre-dates adaptive bit rate techniques, but where part of the problem, that of creating video which was appropriate for a multitude of handset screens, was catered for.
Harmonic highlights the simplification of workflow as one very good reason to take this step, but in what has become a multi-rights world, this will only work for a subset of content providers, those who run end to end with PlayReady rather than offering a higher level of both resolution and security to set tops, than they offer to handsets and tablets.
Another problem that this solution is going to come up against is the splintering of the three (if not four) major islands of DRM – Microsoft with Playready, Google with Widevine, Apple with Fairplay and potentially Adobe as well.
Many tablet and phone only design wins in multiscreen video have come courtesy of PlayReady, mostly because it was ready and waiting and did not cost a fortune to license, after Microsoft had spent years and years updating its DRM technology (since Windows Media DRM). PlayReady now natively supports multiple domains and allows for multiple devices in one home to use the same licensing process, making DRM less onerous for the consumer and allowing content to move from device to device.
But as the various browser owners begin to dig into video played in the browser, without a partner app, and therefore feel they can force the issue over what DRM is supported, we are destined to have one dominant DRM per browser. This means there will be a business case for each DRM server to produce multiple keys for multiple DRM systems, and therefore a need to be integrated with PlayReady, Fairplay, Widevine and potentially a fourth DRM where a proprietary conditional access or specialist TV DRM is also used with a set top box. Some people in the DRM community have already moaned to Faultline about the way this shuts them out of the market, enforces increased complexity on content owners, and moves the video market to a semi-monopoly position.
Particularly vulnerable is PlayReady, simple because it has so much market share, and a share that does not reflect its browser market share. A simple move from Apple to prevent PlayReady working on its iOS devices, would create an immediate need for almost all multiscreen content services to redevelop their DRM.
Still, for now PlayReady is dominant on general purpose devices and it makes sense for Harmonic and Microsoft to partner on this step. But it won’t be too long before Harmonic will be forced into new DRM implementations depending upon how browser DRM standardization progresses.
Microsoft seems to be trying to partner with real time encoder makers like Harmonic and everyone else in the video eco-system, in order to get as many of them onside creating PlayReady systems, knowing that its market share in browsers has gone down badly, and anticipating the market change.
Chris Santini, director media strategy, Microsoft said, “This technology collaboration plays off the strengths of both companies, simplifying the security and delivery of live, VOD, and cloud DVR services while ensuring enhanced protection of high-value content.”
It looks to us like it will make it easier for customers to choose Microsoft Azure cloud as well. It helps that Harmonic ProMedia Origin and ProMedia X Origin are software-based servers which already support packaging in Apple HLS, Adobe HDS, Microsoft Smooth Streaming, and MPEG-DASH.
Meanwhile in an entirely separate announcement ViXS Systems a specialist in media processing, has also cut a deal with Harmonic, just to demonstrate a hybrid HEVC, MPEG-DASH technology, which it calls HybridDASH. The two companies will demonstrate 1080i broadcast video delivery using HEVC compression.