This week at IBC there was some skin placed on the bones of the UPC Horizon box, something which now has so much hype about it, it could never possibly live up to the expectations observers have placed on it. It may however live up to those placed on it by UPC and its parent Liberty Global.
Whatever the actual benefits, it was a subject that visitors at IBC could hardly get away from, what with UPC CEO Mike Fries keynoting on the subject.
So far most European operators have been unable to articulate real strategy for sending video over the internet, now that it is not only possible, but positively encouraged by every announcement at IBC, and every supplier architecture. They have perhaps looked at the Horizon announcement looking to take the best from it, perhaps find some clues to their own use of OTT.
About the simplest format of OTT is the TV Everywhere architecture ‘ this preserves revenues for TV channel bundles, by replicating them in an over the top format, for no extra payment. You have these channels anyway, have them on your tablet too. For the most part in the US this has been about preventing the cutting of the cord ‘ it is a churn prevention mechanism, little more.
There is an underlying truth here ‘ pay TV would be hugely less expensive if the underlying architecture was the internet, and you could buy into the internet from any supplier you liked. But there has long been a sub-truth of this, a sort of corollary, which is that broadband costs nowhere near as much as it should, because companies offering it also make money from broadband services such as TV. If you move TV to the internet, the internet will have to get more expensive ‘ someone has to pay for all that new broadband plant and infrastructure.
But Europe, for the most part is not ready to simply think that the US has got it right, because Europe is different. Cable networks, including those from the mighty Liberty Global, are nowhere near being entirely digital. There are a few that are, but in large territories, the larger networks are roughly 50:50
The mission in the US for cable companies might be to fight cord cutting, but in Europe it is to shift people who stubbornly stick with lower priced analog despite incentives to move to digital video. That holds back networks from broadband and voice sales, from using smartTVs, and from interactivity, but also from the bandwidth harvesting of techniques like switched video.
At first it seems a strange idea that Liberty Global can affect all of this with an offering which really only appeals to the top end of its market ‘ to the most digital of customers, but we note that it is planned at first for UPC Netherlands where 47% of its 1.9 million customers are still analog, and its very next ports of call are its operations at UnityMedia in Germany and Cablecom in Switzerland, which are 64% and 66% analog. Make no mistake, the device was planned as a digitization accelerator.
The box goes into a consumer trial at UPC Netherlands and commercial roll-out will follow shortly in the Netherlands and then move swiftly on to Switzerland and Germany. By the time it finally arrives the Horizon box will have been delayed by almost a year, but the whole idea has broadened and now a variety of different systems will be on offer, with or without a hard disk and with a client set top coming during 2012 so that it can have multi-room functionality.
Liberty Global has added to the technology partners involved since last year’s initial announcement and these now include the original four, Samsung who makes the final box, Intel with the CE4100 chip inside, NDs who has brought the entire project together and delivered middleware and the Snowflake UI and Nagra’s conditional access, plus newcomers ioko now part of part of Kit Digital which built the service platform, thePlatform (part of Comcast) which supplied the content management system and Metrological Media Innovations, which has supplied the App Store software
During the development UPC described the device as a Google TV killer, thinking that Google box would potentially arrive in Europe before this did. Of course Google’s box, when it does arrive, can be attached to any broadband line, and needs no pay TV subscription, so in what way this can kill Google TV we have no idea. This is more, as we have said repeatedly, a way of keeping top end UPC customers from cutting the cord, and additionally a full TV Everywhere service (to any box including PCs) that will only go to digital UPC subscribers, providing them with a strong reason to upgrade.
The Horizon box will offer broadcast content, plus web content on what UPC calls an open Apps platform (we wonder what will happen if a rival wants to offer a paid video service over the web as an App?) but primarily this will be made up of a 3,000 strong VoD offering ‘ whether paid or not UPC was unclear, so we suspect both. An SDK will come shortly so that others can join those 60 first up Apps
The box providers cloud based search and recommendation and we assume the recommendation engine, since it hasn’t come from a partner, is part of the Snowflake project from NDS. There are separate copies of the Apps for tablets and
Smartphones, and these can also operate as a remote control.
The box connects around the home with a MoCA connection (chips from Entropic we assume) and Celeno video optimized WiFi and the outputs are DLNA certified.
To people around the world the most important step has been to get content to play on an iPad, and in this implementation that comes from a content portal in the web, so could have been achieved quite simply with off the shelf offerings, geo coordinated so that paid content can only be consumed in the home. We know that NDS has been working on a mechanism so that the iPad is TV channel aware, knows what you are watching and offers you additional content to the iPad. To us this means that the content that you can actually consume on the smaller portable devices is unlikely to be anything like the same as the TV, and perhaps only VoD and no channels. Some of the Apps support the major social networks.
The announcement that Unity Media will also be taking this box is now extremely confusing to Liberty Global customers. In May last year Unity Media, then still independent, began offering an MHP based set top, which allowed broadcast and broadband to be converged, taking an MHP software stack from Alticast, on a device designed by EchoStar. Applications were coming out of Belgian company Zappware and it used OpenTV middleware, like much of the rest of UPC across Europe. We know this project has not yet been cancelled at Unity and wonder if perhaps UPC is keeping a foot in both camps in case the uptake of its Horizon box is slower than it hoped for, something that will largely depend on price and of course reliability.
The same can be said of Telenet, Liberty Global’s service in Belgium. Here MHP is already used. Telenet has 2.25 million subscribers and 1 million remain analog, so it would have been a great candidate for the Horizon box.
The proof will be in the uptake, both of the TV Everywhere service, the box and most importantly, the acceleration to a full digital platform.
The problem for the rest of European cable is that their pockets are not so deep as Liberty’s and this move way leave more of them unable to launch their own parallel strategy, and once its effectiveness is established, that will weaken smaller cable suppliers across the region making them ripe for consolidation, if they weren’t already.