When we launched our first tablet report (not just us at Rethink, but when all of us analysts produced our first tablet report) we all thought that was that. Then as the dust cleared we all came out with another projection, mostly because every tablet maker out there decided to change their plans to respond to the first iPad. iSuppli has this week finally realized that these projections now need to be quarterly as the world tries to understand the tablet phenomena and compete, succeeds, or partially succeeds or fails, and Apple responds ‘ and tablets continue to loom larger and larger in all our lives.
Our own area at Faultline, that of video delivery and consumption patterns, is becoming radically influenced by the mere existence of the iPad and all its attendant copiers.
As Apple’s rivals stumble, Apple is set to increase its iPad shipments faster than previously expected, said iSuppli retaining 74% of the market during 2011 and Apple will still have as much as 43% market share by 2015. But it is the size of the market, almost bigger than the PC market that shows the way the wind is blowing.
Global media tablet shipments will be 60 million units in 2011, up from 17.4 million in 2010 and this will go to 275.3 million units by 2015 this new iSuppli adjustment says. They are just figures and like all figures offered by analysts, ourselves included, are subject to change when the wind changes direction.
But right now this is the thrust of every change for tablet shipments ‘ the market is bigger than everyone thought and Apple will retain a larger share than everyone thought. Our first revision was entitled ‘Tablets 2.0’This time think bigger’ and subtitled ‘Taking bites out of Apple.’ But few of those biting at Apple’s market share have managed to eat very much so far.
The departure of Hewlett-Packard from the group sniping at Apple’s heels highlights a dramatic change for technology companies everywhere. HP even seems to want out of PCs, although it’s not abundantly clear on the topic, because it seems it’s too tough to make money in PCs. So how is it that Apple is generating phenomenal profits from devices which are only expected to be as well established as PCs in another 4 to five years?
And right in there are a number of observations just waiting to tumble out. You don’t yet need an iPad or other Tablet for work, but you do need a PC. You definitely don’t need a tablet to stay in touch on Facebook all day, but you do need a phone connection. You can’t make calls on a Tablet, you find it hard to type things on a tablet, and you can’t get all those enterprise apps or even the Microsoft products you are used to on a tablet. All of which is why most of us do not have Tablets. Yet. But the world assumes that all that will change.
Of course there are other reasons we don’t have tablets yet (you can stop reading if you have one). For some people, they are so busy working in the way that they have worked for years, that it simply doesn’t occur to them to try to move to a tablet. Let’s remember that the PC revolution was pushed as a set of productivity improvements, but actually the relationship between work and PCs was far more complex. We are perhaps more productive, but we use the time we save checking our email or Facebook pages, or looking up things on Wikipedia that win us arguments.
Today we have a world that cannot get off automated portable devices, there is an interdependency. But we’re not sure everyone is more productive ‘ just tied in.
Other people haven’t bought into tablets because they are too expensive, they are too breakable, they are too heavy to carry (funnily enough the device is harder to hold in your hands than it is to put a laptop on a desk).
We come back to our universal CE observation ‘ new things sell if you want one, can afford one and they really take off when you see someone else who has one. That final jealously ingredient cuts in when someone has one who in your opinion, should not have got one before you. A kind of keeping up with the Jones’ techno-lust takes over.
Let’s just look at the key facts. Apple’s tablet revenues last quarter were $6 billion out of $28.5 billion. The company is overall worth $345 billion. Hewlett Packard’s Personal Systems Group did just $9.4 billion in the same period out of a total of $21 billion. The company is worth $50 billion or about one seventh the value of Apple, despite them being roughly equivalent in size.
There is an expression used in investment circles, ‘it’s all in the price,’ meaning that investors have already taking into account new events, even if they haven’t yet happened, and have used that to either increase or decrease the price of a stock.
So now we know that it is early days for Apple and tablets, but the presumed growth that iSuppli is talking about is ‘all in the price.’ PCs are harder and harder to make money at and that also is in HP’s price, despite it being the largest PC maker in the world apart, perhaps, from Dell.
So the market for the most established device that everyone relies on, is worth less than a market that almost no-one relies on, but everyone has ownership lust for.
It is against this backdrop and the three or four years leading up to it, that the two conflicting statements came from HP one week apart, with the CEO saying that the company was getting out of PCs, out of Tablets, and out of phones and that WebOS was dead, followed by the divisional head Todd Bradley, who runs HP’s personal systems group saying that the company is looking at ‘strategic’ alternatives to its almost $40 billion a year PC group and that WebOS is not actually dead, just the tablet that HP has just launched on it is dead. Oh yes, and the phones and stuff.
Bradley went on to say that, ‘Over the six years I have led this group, we have grown to become the largest, most profitable PC company in the world with over $41 billion in revenues. For the last seven consecutive quarters we have sequentially year-over-year had profit improvement. What I am passionate about is driving us to be the best PC company in the world and continue to understand the innovation that’s important to both consumers and enterprises. I’m so proud to lead such a phenomenal group of people.’
That does not sounds like a failing or even ailing company? In a world where a $40 billion thriving business, one of the largest of its type in the world, is seen as a liability, this is all about corporate agility. Some companies have got it, others’ don’t. It’s clear that if Apple had remained as the manufacturer of disk based iPods, by now its day would have come and gone. But it had the sense to move on to phones. And now its phones are coming under pressure from well-designed touch phones, it has had the sense to open up a new front ‘ tablets.
So in 10 or 15 years, if by then tablets become a discount based bun-fight, it’s fair to assume that Apple will have elegantly moved on. HP has not moved on but it has fought its corner in PCs ‘ that’s not the same approach at all.
Instead, as an organization HP is most comfortable where its weight and size make money ‘ in services, now the same size as PCs in revenue terms, but more profitable. It’s IT services group is second only to IBM’s and it follows in the footsteps of IBM’s having been built almost a decade later, based on following a company that was in most of its other businesses, typically large server farms for top enterprise clients. Smart IT skilled bodies are the heart and soul of IT services. You cannot have too many cooks if they are all being paid for on a fee plus margin basis.
But that culture does not lend itself to agility. And companies without agility have to stay in business that will still be around in ten years. If HP had invented the iPod, it would still be trying to make the revenue model grow. It would have forgot to move on.
Which is perhaps why the WebOS purchase was always doomed, why any tablet that came out of such a company would have too many cooks and too many costs. There is nothing wrong with WebOS, it is in the wrong place, at the wrong time, now owned by the wrong company. That needs to change.
Palm did NOT have that culture and we did say it was doomed the day that the deal was announced. Finding a way forward for WebOS will be tough, but not impossible, but if it remains within HP it will become one of those pieces of software used in its printers and peripherals, and never targeted at tablets and phones ever again. Instead HP will take it into cars, health monitors and household appliances. Such products require a stripped-down, cloud-oriented OS rather than a full-blown smartphone-style system and these devices will one day speak to each other and need a human UI.
But all the profit from such a cloud OS will almost certainly go to someone like Google, which offers services on them, or to someone like Apple, who creates a high degree of desirability into a device which runs it. HP will make evolutionary steps while the other two have what it takes to make revolutionary steps, due to their agility.
And it seems to us that corporate agility is down to one thing, a CEO that takes a detailed interest in the product he or she creates. HP CEO L’o Apotheker, doesn’t care to do that. Todd Bradley, the ex-CEO of Palm, and the man running the PC Group at HP, thinks he can.
HP execs have traditionally remained close enough to what turns on the customer, and are close to the sale force, who hears what the customer is asking for, but they do not anticipate the experience of consumers using brand new product categories. People who CAN do that are not accountants, they are not visionaries, they are not salesmen, but they have the ability of putting themselves in the position of a customer and imagining trying to use the product. They are then single minded about producing that desired experience. Yes we did just describe Steve Jobs, but he is not the only person in the world that can do that. At least we hope he’s not.
So anyway HP is not closing its WebOS operation. It will continue to develop WebOS and begin to license it to other companies to use in their products.
The TouchPad tablets and Pre smartphones are definitively gone (and there is a fire-sale to rid HP of stock) and that decision was made by a leadership team that cannot imagine creating a $6 billion a quarter business out of a new device in just over a year, the way people at Apple have grown to expect to be able to do. You might argue, as the CEO of HP has argued this past week, that this would cost HP a lot of money and that money can be more sensibly spent elsewhere. But we would argue differently.
This remains a culture thing. If we go back to one of our first assignments at Faultline in 2003, we were asked to go along to HP’s European HQ in Munich and talk about the future of the PC to its PC team.
At the time we were beginning to see wireless speeds in WiFi, but also in other technologies such as UWB, that would challenge the internal bus speed on a PC. We suggested that the future PC would be portable, big enough to hold in your hand, with a screen big enough to watch movies on, but without any peripherals, which would work, but be connected by wireless. It would not have disk drives, but use lighter flash memory and would talk to corporate storage drives for backing up of enterprise data, and would double as a workstation and media delivery device and you would be able to take it home.
The device would be always connected to the web, have a lightweight operating system that was not Windows and become a personal helper. We didn’t know that we were describing most of the attributes of the iPad, and we never guessed at touch screen capability, not back then.
Feeling fairly pleased with ourselves, we expected a bit of awe and a pat on the back, but the person who had hired us was grumpy and we asked why, ‘We were rather hoping you’d talk about a future that would happen in our lifetimes, not some star-trek vision. We wanted to know what features would sell PCs next year.’
This showed us that HP was a company that asked its customers what they wanted and tried their hardest to deliver it. Steve Jobs at Apple wouldn’t have got very far with that approach, he knows better than any consumer what is possible and has showed us that the trick is work out how a consumer might feel and how he might want his product to work, once he knows what new technologies can deliver.
This is typical of older companies, they become obsessed with incremental change in the right direction, evolution and not revolution and that process can be presided over by accountants and sales people and people with marketing degrees. It can only innovate by buying businesses that have already been through their innovation stage, such as Autonomy, which the HP has just shelled out $10.3 billion to buy this week.
In the end, only technologists can create $6 billion a quarter businesses overnight in technology. And only technologists, in agile organizations, who are not overly burdened by the expectation of accountants. It’s a mindset, and it has to have backup from the very top. All of which pointed us as the fate of WebOS the day HP stepped to buy it.
The new initiative to find a home for the PC division of HP will result in inevitable failure. Who wants to buy a $40 billion business that the owners cannot run well enough and makes products that the world relies on, but has no love of. In 12 minutes (never mind 12 weeks) you might think of all the companies of sufficient size that could feasibly take this project on, and you find that after you have crossed off Samsung, or a Chinese government backed player or a collection of ODMs, you’ve run out of ideas. We think HP will, and should, spin out a separate stock, giving the company to stockholders, resurrecting the Compaq brand, with a long term PC supply contract to all HP clients. That company might have a chance to develop its own corporate HTC-like or ASUS-like culture where it could innovate at the device level, sufficiently well, that it might actually product a tablet that makes sense.
Of course in order to do that, it must harness services such as Android market, which means submerging WebOS for now, and bringing it back to the fore once Cloudbooks really exist.
WebOS may gain a foothold at Amazon, and it is reportedly being considered by Samsung for future products. But in order to make any kind of commitments, those companies have to consider the technology to be in safe hands. Of course they might buy it themselves, or take a source code license to it, but for our money, all of that is too much of a risk ‘ getting the HP Personal Systems out of HP and into a PC oriented business is perhaps the only way forward to that kind of stability, where such deals CAN be done.
So we can see why the HP execs appear not to be reading from the same page ‘ one of them has high ambitions for the PC Group, while the CEO, a German who was once CEO of the highly ‘corporate’ SAP, L’o Apotheker, could care less, because he has other fish to fry.