Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

3 May 2018

Hulu hints recommendations are dead

Inboxes the world over were bombarded with Hulu announcements from the company’s upfront presentation in New York this week, as the streaming service celebrated surpassing 20 million subscribers in the US by rewarding viewers with new features and treating itself to some fancy new dynamic ad insertion (DAI) technology.

Hulu is also changing the content recommendations game, introducing a new stop suggesting content feature in the UI, nearly five months after its initial demo. Hulu uses an in-house recommendation engine based on technology from California-based content metadata company the Video Genome Project, which it owns, and according to subscriber feedback, the recommendations are regularly inaccurate.

The move is surprising because Hulu has revealed more about its recommendations technology than most major services also using in-house tech, as well as its future plans for the software. Hulu’s recommendation engine has been built using a novel neural network-based collaborative filtering approach, called neural autoregressive distribution estimator for collaborative filtering (CF-NADE). This method is an application of deep learning in recommendation systems, using explicit feedback where users give each item an explicit rating. It says that, while in practice, explicit feedback is rare, but implicit feedback like watch, browse, search and purchase behaviors are abundant. Hulu has previously said adapting CF-NADE to implicit feedback is a future focus, but the new Stop Suggesting button may have halted this.

In November 2016, Hulu acquired the Video Genome Project for an undisclosed fee, integrating its database of over 8 million categorized content titles into Hulu’s live streaming service. Unlike other recommendation engines which simply deliver suggestions based on factors such as genre, actor or director, the Video Genome Project says its own content metadata assigns “genes” to titles, driving down to a deeper level to enhance the video discovery experience – interacting with hundreds of elements like mood, theme, action level and scheduling. In reality, many recommendation products have gone down this route, so it’s far from unique.

Instead of investing its R&D budget into furthering these content recommendation algorithms, Hulu has seemingly thrown in the towel by handing control over to users – a move which may not be as defeatist as it first sounds. Could Hulu be about to can its Video Genome Project unit? For the sake of recommendation software vendors, we hope not – although we struggle to see a recommendation blocker becoming a de facto feature of streaming services.

“We want you to be in control of the experience. If you don’t like something, you should be able to tell us,” said Hulu’s Head of Experience, Ben Smith.

Crucially, Hulu did not declare how many of the 20 million subs have signed up to its one-year old Hulu with Live TV offering, which complements the core VoD business. Installing new DAI technology could suggest one of two things, either the virtual MVPD service is performing below expectations and therefore needs an extra boost, or the live service has performed particularly well, leading Hulu to grab momentum by the horns to increase advertising revenues.

Over the coming months, Hulu says it will integrate DAI capabilities into select cable networks, followed by additional live content. It then plans to introduce a download feature for ad-supported content for on-the-go viewing while still enabling targeted advertising – claiming to be an industry first. Presumably the DAI gets to work during the download stage, rather than magically enabling advertisers to target viewers without an internet connection, as Hulu suggests, while possibly updating outdated ads when a connection is established.

SVP of advertising sales at Hulu, Peter Naylor, said: “Our launch of the industry’s first ad-supported downloadable content experience is yet another example of how Hulu is innovating viewer-first ad solutions to drive powerful results for brands. With downloadable content, we’re offering brands more ways to connect with engaged viewers who love the experience of watching television, wherever they may be.”

On the content front, news reports have waxed lyrical about Hulu stealing away a licensing deals away from Netflix after signing a multi-year contract with DreamWorks Animation. The deal is for exclusive 2019 theatrical releases in the US, including upcoming movies How to Train Your Dragon: The Hidden World, The Boss Baby 2 and Trolls 2. Hats off to Hulu, but our honest opinion is that Netflix will not bat an eyelid.

As the lines between pay TV and OTT video blur over the coming years, bringing OTT video projects to the forefront of traditional TV businesses, it won’t be surprising to see Hulu’s ownership situation shaken up. Hulu is currently jointly owned by Time Warner’s Turner Broadcasting System (10%), Comcast’s NBCU (30%), Disney-ABC (30%), and Fox Entertainment Group (30%). Each of these will gradually view Hulu more and more as a direct competitor.