Is it only us, but was the simple news this week that Time Warner Cable is working with Humax, not the single most depressing news item this week for the set top industry? Most sources reported the news as a replicated press release, to us it’s the beginning of the end of the US native set top industry.
Previous set top orders from Time Warner Cable have so far always gone to Motorola (now Arris) and Cisco, and not even the UK’s Pace has made big inroads into TWC set top orders, although Pace currently remains the largest set top maker in the world and is a second source at Comcast.
It is bad enough that the set top industry has to cope with the early signs of a shift to Cloud DVRs, HDMI dongles and OTT delivery to general purpose, consumer acquired tablets, smart TVs and smartphones, but by the simple measure of embracing RDK, the usually clever and varied set top manufacturers are globally threatened, not only with homogeneity, but with extinction.
At Faultline we are kind of ambivalent about it. It is true that General Instrument, before it became Motorola, and then jumped to Google and then to Arris, did operate a DRM lock-in on the large US cable TV operators. Perhaps it deserves payback in some karmic fashion.
It has taken US cable almost ten years to shake itself free of the twin lock-ins, created by Scientific Atlanta (now Cisco) and Motorola (now Arris) when they offered expensive set tops, above market price, as the only devices which would work with their ‘fairly basic’ conditional access servers.
Cable asked for and received the help of the FCC, in its CableCard specification, and now, as cable firms embrace OTT, such as the Comcast Xfinity services, there is an opportunity to finally reach for commodity equipment and software pricing in all areas of the technology ‘ in conditional access, set top hardware and in middleware. The outcome could mean large scale orders for CE manufacturers who offer economies of scale, but who also demand huge orders before they become interested, usually at the 1 million devices or more mark.
Humax is a South Korean consumer electronics firm, and its typical fare are devices which are retail, such as low end DTT set tops in broadcast centric countries. Pricing in these devices is down at the sub $75 level, and that’s at retail, with a 30% or more retail margin. Imagine what these guys can offer if the software is already specified and maintained within an RDK that can balloon to offer the entire middleware stack.
The statement from Time Warner Cable this week said simply that it was working with Humax, the first of the CE manufacturers who was encouraged to take a license to RDK, on an IP box to work with the TWC next generation Cloud Navigator.
It is understood that TWC, like many other cable operators, is moving to the position where it has a home media headless gateway, which takes care of termination and router functions and initial stream decryption and storage. Such a gateway mostly does not connect directly to a TV, but it connects via a cheap IP set top, to each TV in the home. This looks like the first bulk order for those cheap IP set tops.
These will now work with the TWC Cloud Navigator service which consists of a new HTML 5 cloud-based navigation guide and a new UI with enhanced search and recommendation. In other words this is the core of TWC’s next gen TV experience, in the way that Xfinity is being developed for Comcast.
In a way both Comcast and TWC are taking a leaf out of the Japanese operator’s handbook, closely defining their future devices and commissioning them in a beauty contest between applicants. That way the most advanced services come from companies like NTT in Japan, and the device makers cannot innovate in the slightest ‘ something that has made them fairly toothless outside of Japan.
In the current ‘cloud’ obsessed environment, innovation is now contained in software ‘ and in RDK the software on the devices is now owned by the cable companies and software in the cloud provides the service differentiation, which is why we have been pushing UI and Recommendation software as the most important for the past few years, as well as cloud rendering services.
As we say, we are ambivalent here. Perhaps this move is perfect in that if Comcast and TWC ‘ post merger, do things this way, then one of their biggest ever expenses ‘ CPE (Customer Premises Equipment) – will fall dramatically, and the companies may decide to lower pay TV prices and share that gain with the consumer, or better still invest it in customer care and use it as a weapon against the telcos to gain more market share.
But we don’t think so. There is an institutional blindness in US cable companies to how they are perceived by the US public ‘ brought about by the low churn rates for broadband, rather than TV, which consumers clearly cannot live without and will not cancel despite poor support services. So RDK will lead to some innovation at the OTT level, and commodity costs across the board, which will lead to windfall profits. In the case of a dominant merged Comcast TWC entity, that might also see the end of a local set top industry.
And if Time Warner Cable turns to Humax for support services for its set tops, it is likely that such requests will fall on deaf ears ‘ most cable companies have given up entirely creating set top software for smart TVs, due to the indifference from smart TV CE manufacturers to supporting applications on 5 or 6 operating systems at once. CE manufacturers are not geared up to operating or supporting help desks and tend work a ‘return to base’ support model. Humax is no different.
Back in December Samsung licensed the RDK, some months after Humax, and should be just a few months behind it in delivering compliant set tops.
We do understand that in the interests of keeping healthy competition alive that the US cable operators may also later choose to work with Arris and Cisco as well. But the fact that Samsung and Humax deal on such a large scale of orders, suggests that they may drain the bulk of orders out of even these large MSOs and then push the products out, unchanged to other smaller US cable cablecos.
We suspect the harder to build boxes, with higher margins, will remain with traditional suppliers for at least one generation, and these smaller IP devices will go to CE manufacturers, but whichever way this plays out standardized devices, means higher volume purchasing agreements and lower ASPs even on home media gateways.
The emergence of Samsung as a viable contender in pay TV in the US has already been testified to by a variety of US analysts, which talk about market share being eroded from the Arris acquired Motorola Home subsidiary, in favor of both Samsung and Pace. Cisco has recently fallen from grace and from a position where a year ago it had challenged Pace as the global leader in set tops, it has fallen away slightly.
‘We’re very excited as this is the first implementation of the RDK for Time Warner Cable and steers us towards the future of an all IP service,’ said Matthew Zelesko, Time Warner Cable’s Senior Vice President, Converged Technology Group. ‘The RDK continues to evolve thanks to the collaboration and joint efforts of the RDK community. We look forward to the continued development of the RDK and will work together to enhance it as a strategic platform for next generation Set-Top Boxes and devices.’
The RDK has 125 licensees already and when we first spoke to manufacturers about it they all openly welcomed it, although we felts we heard a number of them appearing to curse under their breath.
The same CE manufacturers will be less loyal to the existing set top SoC vendors and although Broadcom and others have rushed to embrace RDK, its emergence could threaten the global pecking order here as well. However the reliance on these existing chip makers will continue for home media gateways, just being defined in the US. For instance we understand that the Comcast XG5 unveiled in January, has turned into a fight between Arris and Pace with both offering reference designs which uses Intel Puma 6 DOCSIS chips and a Broadcom SoC.
Recently Liberty Global joined the Comcast TWC joint venture in RDK Venture, and when we realize that Samsung completed over a year ago the long term project to deliver Liberty the Horizon home media gateway, based on Intel chips, we can already see the effects of the major CE vendors entering set top market soaking up volume.
Samsung confirmed in December that Comcast has already received a batch of Samsung set tops which are RDK-based. Time Warner Cable is already a Samsung customer (in a minor way we think) while in the US Cablevision and Bright House Networks are known to take some Samsung devices. In Europe Com Hem in Sweden and Virgin Media in the UK have also started sourcing set-tops and gateways from Samsung. LG Electronics also has an RDK license and has yet to declare any wins in the market.