Over the last two weeks, Faultline has made a case that classic fixed line IPTV is far more expensive to build out in high volumes than widely believed, and that both pure IP hybrids and less than pure hybrids, which use one broadcast route to deliver TV services, and another to produce interactivity, could turn out to be cheaper.
Now in the final part on our analysis of IPTV hybrids, Faultline will look at content and advertising and what’s happening to the Eco-system that TV finds itself in.
If we design an IPTV system without looking at what’s happening to content, we will be ignoring the most important part of the entire system.
So first let’s just look at the life of a major motion picture in the existing model for exploitation of content. Motion pictures are consistently the most requested part of any IPTV service, so just how they are exploited is quite important.
All diagrams are available in the PDF version
Originally film companies made films, they got the major studios to back them and distribute them. They went first to Cinemas, then to retailers in the form of DVDs, but also to Pay per view on pay TV systems, and then dropped down to the lower revenue levels of DVD rental and repeats on cable and Broadcast TV.
But the number of ways that a film can get into the home is going up exponentially. Initially there was internet piracy. Then there are legitimate internet download services and iTunes. Of course the Pay TV sector has been woken up by IPTV, and VoD streaming and VoD trickle feed is beginning to emerge. File formats have changed and been compressed by a factor of about 2.5 to 1 beyond MPEG 2.
Video Search engines are creating new short forms of entertainment and increasingly these will act as a route to market for film production companies.
For every film released, there 10 films that are filmed and for every one that is filmed, about 10 sets of film rights are bought from writers and authors.
There are about 100 US films released each year from Hollywood, with about 30 made by the big studios, and the rest part funded and distributed by them.
Overnight, using the internet as a route to market, there could suddenly be 1,000 a year as more films actually get released and this flood of content will change the landscape considerably, for instance many more films would change the way VoD tends to be used.
The arrival of the Prosumer (Professionally equipped consumer) and their contributions to content are also going have an increasing effect. There will be news services driven from content recorded on mobile phones. There will be short films, home grown documentaries.
Today there are High Definition camcorders with professional features for just $6,000, which output MPEG 2 or MPEG 4 automatically. In a matter of a few short years these will be $200 items and everyone will have one.
Mobile TV is starting during 2006, and although it will rely on existing content at first, it will spark new content relationships.
There will be MORE films and more entertainment, on more devices, going over more networks, and this will throw up challenges to existing content creators
Robert Iger CEO of Disney stood up a few weeks back and said that the only thing studios could NOT do was stick with the way things are today.
Now let’s take a little look at what this all might do to advertising, using the US as an example. The way in which US TV channels make their money is split roughly 66% advertising and 33% carriage fees.
A company like Viacom which owns 40 TV channels including MTV and Nickelodeon, earns $15 billion in content revenues and has $8.4 billion in content costs and makes $4.2 billion in profit. It all looks very rosy.
Now or in the future the content company can still reach 96 million US homes by partnering with more sources of TV delivery, but the make up of that will change (see diagram below).
Content companies could actually reach even more peopole if they partner with mobile TV delivery, as long as they have content that is considered right for mobile TV.
There will be pressure on carriage fees to stay the same or go up despite subscriber losses. Cable will resist this, but as it becomes a smaller part of the total pie, its negotiating power is harmed, and it actually may end up paying more.
But as TV advertising is challenged by ‘other’ activites such as mobile TV, internet usage, watching DVDs and DVRs and playing on more and more sophisticated games consoles, less of the total advertising revenue pie ($60 billion is currently spent on TV advertising in the US) will go to TV. Internet advertising will rise from $12 billion this year to $15 billion next, and yet global ad revenues will only rise by 6%. Much of that internet advertising spend will come from TV, and TV can potentially go down in advertising revenues, something it has never done.
The result is that content businesses like Viacom want to pay even less for original content, but charge even more for carriage or else they would begin to shrink their own revenues.
But if at some point Viacom tries to charge more for carriage, that will put a squeeze on existing operators and take the price of entering the market with a new type of TV, up. By getting less for Ad revenue, channel owners want to spread their TV channels around even further.
There are also new film download services, including those announced by Starz, Apple, Google, Sony Clear Channel, 4Flix, Blinkx, AOL, Arvato, LoveFilm, BSkyB, NTL and DirecTV, plus the rumor that Amazon is about to conclude a deal to offer its own service later this year, as are Blockbuster and NetFlix
And there have been many new TV channels which are appearing ENTIRELY on the web with new brands like Sail.tv, TrioTV.com, OutZone.com, BrilliantButCancelled.com, VegTV.com, Bar.tv, Cocktails.tv, Yuks.com, TotalVid.com and JumpTV.com.
So traditional content businesses are looking further afield as new routes to market open up
And these new routes to market are inviting new companies to form, which in short order will grow and consolidate, and what will emerge are new, internet savvy, media groupings. And each of these will want Ad revenue, so the cycle continues.
The problem with all of this is that it makes the business of carrying content more expensive. Established content businesses will try to cut deals with other, new, sources of revenue, such as web delivered TV, file downloads and mobile TV. The outcome is quite radical.
Let’s talk a bit about new sources of content ‘ Let’s just take games.
We know that gaming networks are being built and subscribed to at breakneck speed. The new Microsoft Xbox 360 Live network is signing up customers FASTER than iTunes did when it launched.
There are future scenarios here where millions of video game players take part in global cyber competition. Each battle can be shown in a video representation, and it will end up being shown to millions in IP carried video. It will become a new form of mass entertainment.
So instead of one game taking one TV in one household away from conventional TV and conventional TV advertising. One game could effect millions.
Very simply it is likely that we will view TV services from many different sources including download to buy, subscription downloads, Web TV, mobile VoD, mobile datacasting, mobile multicasting, online DVD rental, portable video players, VoD, in-car DVD players, cable, IPTV, free to air terrestrial digital and others.
TV viewing will fragment and become multi-sourced and delivered to multiple devices over multiple network types. This ‘splintering’ process shares what revenue there is among more and more tiers. It could end up producing uncertainty of revenues, and reduce the ambition of content companies to produce ‘blockbuster’ movies or to risk expensive productions. In that case quality would quickly fall away from content only to be replaced by much larger volumes, of much less good content.
It is because of this that the current obsession with reality TV will extend and we will look more and more for ‘user contributions.’ That global gaming tournament example is one such form of reality entertainment that is coming.
So with more networks, each spending less money, and chasing fewer concurrent viewers between them, and offering less expensive content from more sources, this will mean a dark age in content production and there could be LESS good TV than there is today. It will certainly be harder to find anything good.
Now think about this, if content goes through this process of redefining itself just at a time when most of the world’s Telcos have invested billions of dollars in building a real time video delivery network (IPTV) suddenly we have heavily indebted Pure IPTV businesses and less indebted hybrid and other video delivery businesses. In stagnant times heavily indebted businesses fail either through corporate failure or through share price falls.
Finally let’s look at another source of threat for IPTV in the cellphone once it is merged with the cheap storage device.
Consumers want content which can be acquired anywhere, on any network and to be viewed from wherever they are right now.
Unencrypted TV can already be copied to a Sony PSP and watched on the bus, and onto an iPod. You can buy UMD disks for the PSP at retail. Pay TV networks, every single one of them, from Comcast, to DirecTV, to EchoStar, to BSkyB, to European and Eastern IPTV systems, are all planning to offer DRM protected copying from the set top to portable devices so consumers can watch TV on the move.
Files can be downloaded via broadband either directly to a mobile device or to a PC and then copied to that device. And mobile TV is coming in at least three formats ‘ existing unicasts over cellular, datacast over a separate network and multicast, more efficiently over cellular.
Our belief is that this will lead to the mass uptake of using the handset as a portable DVR, with a 25 GB hard drive in your handset that can carry a subset of your home network content.
Samsung put the first hard drive into a Korean mobile phone at the beginning of 2005. Now this is beginning to move out of the Korean market.
Handset makers are aware of what’s going on, operators are aware of it, and chip makers that drive capabilities in this market are focused on it.
In the diagram below we’ve mapped capacities of 1 inch disk drives with gravity sensors, which stop dropped phones having their hard drives damaged. Gravity sensors only got small enough to put in a mobile phone at the beginning of 2005. The capacity of such drives are going up rapidly, while the price per gigabyte falls rapidly. Capacities move from 2 GBs to 24 GBs over this period with prices falling to $10 per GB.
The average disk drive price floats between $200 and $300 throughout this period and the prices we have are mostly for low volumes.
It is likely that in high volumes handset makers can achieve far lower pricing. Although average handset prices are just $120 or so, top end phones can vary from $400 to $600 to operators, so there is scope for these handsets to include top end disk drives in the existing cellular business model.
Mobile content is marching inexorably. At the moment mobile content is an eight VGA, offered with a low frame rate. During the course of this year it will launch as Quarter VGA and a high frame rate, as each of the mobile TV services launch. By 2007 cellular devices will be able to hold Standard Definition TV signals and by 2008 they will include HD content and the processing power to drive a HD TV directly.
Texas Instruments OMAP 3 architecture, which is already defined and which was launched at this year’s 3GSM anticipates Ultra Wide Band content copying through the air between a phone and a home DVR, at speeds up to 1 Gbps. This, Texas says, will not soak too much battery power by 2008, just as UWB is likely to get global spectrum approval.
At that point it will take about 8 seconds to copy a film from your home DVR to your phone using UWB, wired or wirelessly.
We see scenarios where simple point and click commands can be used to push video content from a home server to a mobile phone in the time it takes to put your coat and shoes on and get out the door. Playing from a phone would be just as easy.
This really will begin a number of new paradigms in how we go about consuming video.
The humble Electronic Program Guide will need a complete reinvention. It will need to be personalized. It will need to sense your phone and its content and it will need to have an understanding of your favorite programs. We will need ways of searching the web, or video web services you have subscribed to. Broadcast programming may cease to exist at some point in all of this.
So what’s our point? The point is that all of this detracts from the IPTV and triple play. Content becomes ubiquitous, so the need to have a single centralized, high prices pay TV service reduces.
If that reduces, then the need for a triple play service reduces. And if that happens, the huge investments made now will lay like rocks on the balance sheet of the companies that make those investments.
You can argue that if Telcos don’t make these investments they are dead anyway. So we believe that the trick is to make investments which will offer ubiquitous content now. Which will deliver it cheaply, even if that means using a hybrid approach with what’s already in place, and which will anticipate portable and handheld device involvement.
So we would conclude that hybrids will emerge and may be cheaper than pure fixed IP plays. That while fixed access, pure IP, allows interaction between services, hybrids can be pure IP too and allow the same level of interaction. There are threats coming from mobile video and storage improvements which relate to video being available everywhere.
The key advice is that TV operators need to design networks for fast payback and immediate profit, before their business model changes. User created content is coming whether we like it or not and no strategy is future proof.