IBM has predicted the end of TV was we know it, showing irrefutable evidence of the impending collapse of the US TV industry revenues which will likely drop $18 billion of advertising revenue by 2009.
This process is detailed in a new, freely downloadable report that describes in graphic detail the next, potentially disastrous years of the Televison industry, and has just emerged from a section of IBM’s Business Consulting arm called the IBM Institute for Business Value.
Being Faultline, and given that the Faultline concept devised three years ago reached more or less the same conclusions as this report, we can say a loud ‘I told you so.’ But this 28 page report is far from ‘me too’ and makes some genuinely valid new points.
It is carefully constructed, and well argued, with the ideas coming from 65 interviews with senior industry executives, Wall Street analysts, economists and technology visionaries, plus added research from the Economist Intelligence Unit which carried out another 108 interviews across cable, satellite, telco, broadcast and TV networks executives from Europe, Asia and North America.
The easiest way to find the repot it so put ‘IBM Institute for Business Value’ into Google
What surprised us so much is that executives from the industry that is likely to be torn apart, knows what is coming and is rapidly trying for formulate strategies to avoid the worst of the impacts.
Fundamentally it is the old argument about diversifying new video models such as DVR, web TV and video downloads, creating a stratification of fragmented TV services, with the existing $60 billion of US TV advertising revenue being spread over more and more players.
What IBM posits will initially happen is that the world will split into two types of individuals, those that remain largely passive in the living room and those that expect content anytime, anywhere through multiple channels. This latter grouping, driven by both the young and the gadget conscious, will demand platform agnostic content, mobility of media experiences, individualized pricing schemes and an end to the traditional concept of release windows.
IBM says not to panic though. TV viewing is essentially growing. We have been talking in Faultline about ‘lost TV hours’ in the order of 10% viewing hours lost per annum to TV. IBM says no, viewing is actually going up, not down, as long as you include the viewing of DVDs, downloaded files and DVR held content. Of course it’s almost impossible to force anyone to watch advertising on these formats, so yes, IBM expects a drop of around $18 billion of advertising revenue by 2009.
The youth audience continues to log in 3 hours and 51 minutes of TV hours per day which is three to four times as many minutes per day as either computers (at one hour and two minutes, on average) or video games (boys at one hour and thirty-four minutes; girls at forty
minutes, on average).
In fact it is the appeal of controlling better what you can watch, using DVRs and the like, which is driving TV viewing up.
But IBM points to an already huge disparity in TV advertising, with the appeal of national broadcast programming still significantly ahead of cable, even though cable reaches more viewers, for longer periods. Eventually that disparity will go away.
IBM said that in 2005, 57% of US TV viewership was on cable networks versus broadcast, but it only gets 30% of the advertising revenues.
This is also happening in other countries. See figure 1 on Pdf version.
As DVRs are installed in more and more homes, in the US, UK, Germany, France, Spain and Italy, adskipping is also taking off as, one by one, viewers opt out of advertising content. Ad-skipping is expected to lead to huge losses in US TV annual advertising revenues by 2009, potentially reaching $18 billion annually in the US, and $1 billion in Europe by 2009. It could treble once again from there by 2014.
There is also a negative impact, yet to arrive on the advertisement models, from all sorts of other on demand TV, like iTunes, Google Video and web downloads.
If consumers move more and more to a process of using search engines to find video, then some of those consumers could drop right off the advertising map altogether.
The report adds, ‘If upgraded TV features don’t prove new value to consumers, competition will devolve to price alone, placing pressure across the value chain.’ Which is a big warning to the new Telco entrants, don’t turn this into a war about pricing, because everyone will lose.
One network executive told IBM, ‘Broadcasting networks will be extinct in fifteen years.’
One of the key points in the survey is that it is the younger viewers that are more familiar with new technology such as DVRs and iPods, so when these are fully grown, they will make up the bulk of the viewing public. By 2012 this effect will create a generational chasm in viewing habits that will gradually see off the passive viewers.
At the end of all this IBM delivers its own message, it wants to make a business out of advising companies in the sector and gives them 6 key pieces of advice.
They must target both types of users, both active and passive and to do that they must take risks with some new business models. Actually they should keep on taking risks and institutionalize the process. IBM describes this as ‘Experiment, develop, refine, rollout, repeat.’
Also the video business must mobilize, and by this IBM says that publishing models must target laptops, as well as handsets as well as offering services where content can be taken on the road in other ways.
IBM advises that this is all done using open and standards based delivery platforms, including interfaces, the process of content ingestion, and encryption and encoding should all use standards. Also middleware, storage, and home networking components should all be offered using standards.
Finally IBM says reorganize your company around these lines so that you can deliver on these pieces of advice.
We leave you with this last graph which shows that companies that want to store video and stream it across a network are seeing equipment prices that are driving video delivery costs to the floor. A sign that will invite yet more and more competition into the sector.
IBM’s final piece of advice is to adapt or succumb. Well some of them will have to succumb we’re afraid.