Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

6 December 2006

Indie films touted as the key to VoD profitability

The big question of Indie films versus Hollywood was raised this week by speaker Aleksandra Bosnjak, a content and media analyst from Ovum, at the IP Video Services Forum in London this week. It is a subject that Faultline analysts have discussed with clients on numerous occasions and it has real bite.

Bosnjak has a career in and around the independent film sector hands on, and is in the middle of raising money for film projects right now, as well as being an analyst in her spare time and she is clearly a fan of Indie film as much as a spokeswoman for it. The only weakness we found in her argument was her conviction that Indie films were just plain better than the formulaic outpourings of Hollywood.

To a certain extent she is demonstrably right. But to counter this the huge promotional spend of Hollywood which creates consumer desire and brand awareness for its product, which is always the Hollywood edge. The discussion though was about a viable film strategy for IPTV, and in particular VoD film services.

‘Indie directors have smaller budgets, but creative freedom, there are strong sectors in France and Germany, and the talk at Cannes this year was all about Pan-European collaboration to make a kind of European Hollywood.

‘If you are building a VoD service you are never going to make money out of the top 100 films. That’s where the piracy is, that what your competitor is selling and that’s what’s already out on DVD,’ said Bosnjak.

The USA dominates VoD both in terms of content and in terms of spend. Right now Bosnjak says that the US makes up some 79% of global VoD by customer spend, and that this will only fall slowly to 54% by 2010. Western Europe in that time would rise from 15% to 20%, while both China/India and Asia Pacific would rise from almost nowhere to each consume some 12% of a much bigger VoD pie.

Current she rates VoD services as bringing in just $1.3 billion globally (See diagram) rising to $8.2 billion by 2010.

Critically the dominance of the US is also reflected in the content, with 87% of FilmFlex content originating from the US; 80% for TPS and Wanadoo (Orange) services. From there it falls through Fastweb, which has 67% of its content from US studios, while Spain’s Imagenio has a mere 40% from the US and a further 30% sourced from the remainder of Europe. French sites Free and TF1 has as little as 35% and 33% of their content from the US.

‘Nobody yet has anything like European wide VoD rights and the major studios offer VoD rights in tiny national packages,’ she added.

The truth is that the bulk of independent content struggles for cinematic release and DVD manufacture and retail space, so it has to offer itself up on better terms to VoD and internet download services, and it’s here that VoD players will make their money. In order to do this the top 100 films may have to be distributed at a loss or a tiny margin, or not at all, she said.