Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 September 2011

Intel MeeGo on the ropes? Or is it just falling out of cellular

As the cellular market completes the ‘falling out of love’ process with Intel’s MeeGo and the community at large has written it off, the Intel Linux variant is perhaps even better placed to keep Android at bay in the set top market and the more people who insert an Intel chip into a set top, the more chance of this coming to pass.

The sudden flurry of rumors around MeeGo’s further demise come from reports from DigiTimes, a Taiwanese newspaper which has a habit of writing off Western technologies ‘ sometimes correctly and sometimes incorrectly – by chatting off the record to local suppliers. The reason simply is a ‘lack of interest from mainstream vendors.’

MeeGo was created from the merger of Nokia’s Maemo and Intel’s Moblin and is highly regarded in developer circles, not only a ‘purer’ form of Linux than Android, but also better geared to running cloud-oriented browsers. Nokia effectively killed its own MeeGo project by adopting WP7, though like Intel, it officially says the OS remains alive within its walls as an open source program. It also released its one-and-only MeeGo smartphone, the N9, largely to test out some of the design features destined for WP7 ‘Mango’ handsets.

Intel has already shrugged off the defection of Nokia and has insisted that MeeGo has a rosy future, and it will target a far broader base of devices than just handsets. It is already strong in the automotive industry, but that’s a small market. Intel had wanted to increase its position in the post-PC device sector, from handsets to tablets to cloudbooks, and MeeGo could have been a way to provide an integrated silicon/software platform for all web enabled products.

LG and ZTE were both said to be very interested in an OS which they could influence more strongly than Android or Windows, but it seems that their interest may not have developed into firm commitment. DigiTimes says that no major OEM has pledged support and that Intel has decided to halt development of MeeGo, at least temporarily, and to focus its R&D resources on prospects with more short term potential – notably further optimization of its mobile chipsets for Android and WP7, areas where it lags far behind say Qualcomm.

We asked Amino, one of the main set top supporters for Intel chips and MeeGo this week if it was seeing any reducing in enthusiasm for the OS in the set top sector? Amino CEO Andrew Burke told us ‘We aren’t seeing that from Intel ‘ there is still a ton of internal support and we have just ported Meego 1.2 to dual core which offers far faster graphics.’ Burke added, ‘If you believe Google is more foe that friend then which open stack choice do you have other than MeeGo?’

‘We are seeing MeeGo speed of development advantages coming through now – upgrading to 1.2 was a couple of weeks work because of the distributed architecture. We are also supporting third party apps much quicker. That was the original vision and it’s finally beginning to pay dividends. Clearly Android offers similar benefits, but it’s the branching that really let’s Android down.’

But joining Amino in the set top market using Intel chips this week, is Turkish WiFi expert AirTies, which last year branched into adding IPTV set top functions as well.

The devices it has announced (see separate story) offers 8 separate tuners, act as multi-room DVRs as well as home gateways, and support a 500 GB Disk drive, all of which makes a pretty good advert for the Intel chips.

Already Netgem in France has Intel CE chips in its set top products and Pace this week has promised to add Intel to its processor offerings on set tops. However all of these, the AirTies, Netgem and Pace devices all use a separately sourced Linux variant, although they all use the Intel Multi-Application Framework for running different apps in parallel, all of which address the screen. Even Amino runs MeeGo without using the Intel SDK, so while Intel chips may continue to make a dent in the set top market, that doesn’t make it a home run for MeeGo quite yet and as its cellular ambitions appear to be in retreat, the fate of MeeGo may well depend on how Intel positions itself to the set top community.