We’re still not sure exactly whether Intel has a hit or a miss with its new Viiv (pronounced ViVe) technology, but it certainly is beginning the effort of moving heaven and earth to put it in front of people.
It said this week that it has signed 40 partners, which is actually not very many given the cumber of companies in this segment, to work with Viiv.
Viiv is the remote controlled PC launched back in August, set to hit the market in the first quarter next year, which should live in your living room, look like a TV set top or Hi-Fi stack, and have a fast boot and replace DVRs, DVDs, and set tops by doing all of their jobs at once.
It needs Microsoft’s Media Center software to run and apart from the look and the remote control, it’s just that, a Media Center PC. Will the addition of deals with 40 software and content businesses and the introduction of a Viiv logo that says, “Enjoy with Intel Viiv technology”
change that?
The partners include Arvato, Bellrock Media Japan, BSkyB, Canal Plus, LoveFilm, Medion, Movielink, Telecom Italia, TiVo and T-Online, many of whom are known for their work in bringing film downloads to PCs. TiVo is already taking its DVR content to media center PCs with its TiVoToGo software and Arvato, the Bertelsmann subsidiary has already contracted with Medion, a German consumer electronics company, to start a German film download service, and will launch more such deals across Europe.
They have nothing to lose, but perhaps not enough to gain, from a PC move into the living room. The truth is that film downloads should play on a TV, not a PC screen, that’s what everybody wants and we’re not sure this changes that.
We know that film downloads are coming and that they will hit during early 2006. Yes Intel could help this process by creating specialist PC form factors, perhaps with Dell and Hewlett Packard and other PC manufacturers like Toshiba. But if these devices cost the same amount of money and are as difficult to set up as XP Media Center was, then it’s just another $2,000 TV set, which is why the XP Media Center initially failed.
Intel plans to spend $100s of millions on advertising pushing the Viiv branding and signing up vendors for it, but this is all about price and it seems to us that Intel doesn’t decide on the price, and that if its PC making partners price this too low, then they will undermine their existing PC sales, since the Viiv devices are PCs as well.
One of the claims for the Viiv is that it can copy to portable media centers and portable music players, but this is a native function of the Microsoft Windows Media DRM system that is embedded on some of these players, and has nothing to do with Intel’s Viiv.
There were comments at the launch like ‘there are 38 million broadband connected PCs in the US, that’s like 38 million set top,’ but of course it’s not. First off, all those PCs can currently connect to P2P file sharing systems and legal downloading services already, and they have to be altered significantly (replaced) to use Viiv.
Certainly Intel has added some important bells and whistles, the Viiv’s integrated media server ‘engine’ can reformat various digital content files so they can be viewed on a selection of devices, as long as those devices support the Windows DRM. Let’s hope that some of those devices are TVs.
But Apple at least doesn’t have to respond to this launch, because it already has when it launched the Video iPod. It came out simultaneously with a $1,299 iMac G5, that runs with a 6 button remote control and a special interface for viewing from distance. It also supports video conferencing out of the box and comes free with the Photo Booth application. And we understand that a DVR version of the Mac Mini at around $500 is on the cards for next year.
This is the way Intel needs to go and it will have photo software on the device, but the company will always have a price dilemma, make it too cheap, like $300, and people will convert it and use it instead of a PC cannibalizing existing revenues. Make it too expensive and no-one buys it.
At the same time both Microsoft with its Xbox 360, and next year Sony with its PS3, are both targeting this exact same space, and these devices are going to be in the $300 to $400 range, and do a lot more than the Viiv, especially on the gaming front, despite the fact that companies like capcom, DISCover’s My Games, Exent Technologies, Metaboli, Ourgame, Square Enix and Ubisoft are all supporting Viiv, taking Intel head to head with its software partner Microsoft and the Sony PlayStation range.
Microsoft had to dump the use of Intel chips in its own first generation Xbox device, primarily because they were being cannibalized as spare PCs.
Viiv PCs will come out in the first quarter of next year and Intel will show them off at the Consumer Electronics Show.