When internet advertising brings in more in revenue than the entire US advertising Upfront for the broadcast TV industry, then the world has changed dramatically. We are almost at the point.
The annual Upfronts for broadcast and cable are roughly $9 billion and $6 billion, and involve about 90% of US TV advertising being pre-purchased for the coming season. But this week the Interactive Advertising Bureau (IAB) released figures showing that internet advertising revenues rose nearly 33% to over $9.6 billion.
This exceeds even the heady days of dotcom mania and shows that the dotcom boom wasn’t so much erroneous as just too early. Fourth quarter internet advertising revenues were a record $2.69 billion, making it the highest quarter ever reported.
Now we wouldn’t want a hail of email telling us that we aren’t comparing apples with apples, so it must be pointed out that total global advertising is around $350 billion, and that just under half of that is spent in the US, and that these internet figures are global spends, not US spends.
But it is likely that the internet spending split is much the same, with just under half of it spent in the US. That would mean that internet advertising is on the verge of catching up with cable TV advertising, and has broadcast advertising well within its sights.
With US radio advertising revenues falling dramatically, and the 13,000 US radio stations being revalued downwards by all their owners, the impact of real time advertising ‘ TV and Radio ‘ is falling rapidly the US and advertising agencies looking for a replacement revenues stream have had to come up with the internet.
Advertising spend on outdoor and newspaper and magazine advertising in the US, and in many other sectors, is more than holding up, but there is an inevitable shift to move the impact of brand building to whatever it is that the modern buying consumer is doing with his or her time. That has left advertisers chasing advertising ideas on Digital Video Recorders, Cinema, DVD viewing and games platforms, none of which are ideal for advertising and all of which are eating into the way people use their time, detracting from TV viewing hours.
The internet is the one place where advertiser can easily track down ‘viewers’ in the right demographics (even if collecting demographic data is tough for internet advertising).
In continental Europe where TV advertising is under huge price pressure, it is likely that the shift to internet advertising is even more dramatic when compared to total TV advertising, which is just a few $ billion per country per annum in the major European countries.
This scenario, something we have been pointing at within Faultline these past few years, suggests a continued and accelerating shift to DVR based advertising and especially in-game advertising along with this shift to the internet.
While traditional gamers say they will desert advertising if it invades their media, advertising agencies and games companies have absolutely no choice. Games producers barely break even on games titles at the moment and accepting advertising opens up much needed revenue opportunities. If people are leaving TV to spend more time playing platform games, and shifting to paid TV environments in order to get better quality programming, then advertising agencies too have no choice, they must pursue consumer attention, wherever it moves. If the gaming community becomes disenchanted with its games, they can always move back to watching the TV.
After all many people will say that advertising has destroyed, or at least diluted, the enjoyment in TV, and much as it is not desirable to consumers, we expect much the same will happen in other media, including games.
Meanwhile Internet advertising is the one key new area that has got its act together and which is still growing radically.
Consumer advertisers continue to represent the largest category of internet advertisers accounting for 49% of 2004 revenues, up significantly from the 37% reported last time.
The largest sub-categories under the consumer umbrella include retail, automotive, leisure, entertainment and packaged goods.
And internet advertising is not anywhere near hitting a bottleneck. The increased adoption of broadband, going up by anything from 40% to 100% a year, depending on which territory you are looking at, will continue to grow internet advertising revenues for at least the next 4 to 5 years.