Netflix, behind a barrage of phony rhetoric, increased its prices by 50% or more, in the process outraging the US public with many of them swearing never to use the service again. The reasons it gave were that it was separating DVD offers from streaming offers, you can buy one or the other or both, but not a single bundle that includes both. The company risks losing a huge number of customers overnight, but seems confident that this will not happen.
On the Netflix Facebook site around 27,000 people had registered comments from a simple ‘Goodbye’ Netflix to rants of abuse and outrage when we last checked it, but it was rising by the second.
Netflix has always said that its new streaming customers were not cannibalizing older DVD customers and had a life of their own. Now they are backing those observations up with a price change that jeopardizes the entire operation. The move came as a surprise to the Stock Market which didn’t know how to interpret it, and there were high volumes of trading but no real change to the company’s share price at first. This later settled into a general belief that the move was a good thing and investors piled into the stock.
Very simply, either Netflix has done its homework and all it will get is 50% more revenue, or it hasn’t and it will lose subscribers completely or have them choose a single service where before they enjoyed both.
In a bid to make the DVD version more attractive Netflix will offer its lowest ever priced DVD plan, dropping to $7.99 (from a previous low of $8.99) for unlimited DVDs in a month, having them one at a time. The next plan, allowing 2 DVDs out at a time is now $11.99 , whereas previously that also included unlimited streaming as well.
Netflix said the reasons for the moves were to better reflect the costs of each type of service and to give members a choice. But the truth is that customers opting for both services will face a 50% price increase to have the same service in two bundles for the 2 DVD at a time service ($18 instead of $12) and for one DVD at a time plus streaming it will jump from $9 to $16, more like a 80% increase.
Netflix made it clear that it would no longer offer unlimited plans which include both streaming and DVDs by mail. For new Netflix members, the changes will be effective immediately, for existing members, the new pricing will start on or after September 1.
‘Netflix members love watching instantly, but we’ve come to recognize there is still a very large continuing demand for DVDs by mail,’ said Andy Rendich, Netflix Chief Service and Operations Officer. ‘By better reflecting the underlying costs and offering our lowest prices ever for unlimited DVD, we hope to provide a great value to our current and future DVD-by-mail members.’
There are several forces operating here. Initially the streaming service was free but the payments to studios came primarily from churn reduction at the DVD rental. At the time it was introduced the streaming service was not seen as a viable service on its own and that position has been copied around the globe, conspicuously at LoveFiLM in Europe, now part of Amazon, which had an exceptionally high churn rate approaching 80% per annum at one point.
But Netflix has grown from being a 1% to 2% margin business, partly by having such a vast number of DVDs available and partly because it has eased the pressure to deliver DVDs by post, as streaming took off. The Netflix postal costs have fallen dramatically, and at the same time the peering charges that its ISP Level 3 has been charged, have skyrocketed.
Technically these peering charges are supposed to be self-adjusting. The more traffic that you end up sending from one tier one ISP to a rival network, the more money you pay and you take off the traffic that comes your way from that ISP. Comcast is known to have actually changed its charges to Level 3 the ISP supporting Netflix, and Level 3 complained bitterly that for the first time in a 20 year commercial internet history, one peer was charging more to another tier 1 peer, asymmetrically. Nothing more has been heard of this complaint despite the FCC being asked to step in, but we have to have some sympathy with Comcast (although we denounced its attitude at the time) because the Netflix traffic could (and we emphasize could) dramatically change its price equation as an ISP. If, say 20% of the traffic you carry is from one, rather small ISP peer, then the economics of your peering relationship come under close examination. It has to remain profitable to agree to carry traffic to and from that peer, or the pricing relationships of the internet become broken.
What was upsetting about that price hike is that it was one way, it was unilaterally imposed outside of existing peering agreements with others, it was only charged for one ISP, and it was as a direct result of a service which competes with Comcast’s main business. There are little details known about the price hike, except what Level 3 was prepared to say in public.
But the day after such a deal became public, it would have been reasonable for every other major ISP, led by AT&T and Verizon and the top four cable operators, to ask for the same pricing. So if the Comcast price hike was 50% (just guessing) then it was a 50% increase on 17.4 million broadband lines Comcast supplies out of 90 million installed US broadband lines, so 19% of broadband lines. This translates to a mere 8% or 9% total increase in the Netflix streaming bill.
But when all the other ISPs come together and also increase their peering charges, then that may raise the costs of sending internet video for Netflix by a full 50%, and that might mean that it is time to align costs with service pricing.
But if Netflix hasn’t increased the cost of its streaming service, which remains at $7.99, how is it saving money? There are many ways that it can save money. If some subscribers stick to online and cancel DVD rental, the number of DVD copies that Netflix needs to hold of each movie will go down, cutting its DVD purchasing costs. The question then is whether or not this will lead to an increase in streaming from those customers, and more ISP charges for Netflix? We don’t think so. We think that much of the reason is to move away from the necessity of holding quite so many DVDs, just in case the combined service customers suddenly make DVD demands.
This will have been happening anyway at Netflix, as it only has streaming rights to about 20% of the DVD titles it holds. So the process would have been to look for a film you want online and when it’s not there, look for it in DVDs and order it.
To cut this down, Netflix will have to substantially increase its efforts to license more films online, and it may be ready to seriously up the percentage of films available in that way.
Another thing that Netflix may have realized is that half as many customers, but with all of them using online only, would lead to greatly increased profits. It may be prepared to sacrifice a large number of sign ups, to drive more profit. If a number of customers continue to use the DVD only service either in parallel with an online deal or in preference to it, then the increase in revenues, and the decrease in the number of DVD titles it will have to hold either increase revenues or keeps them still, while decreasing costs.
There are in fact lots of ways in which this moves serves Netflix well on paper. It might reduce the amount of films that are streamed, cutting ISP online delivery costs, but without actually cutting total online revenues since all $7.99 of all online deals can be applied to the pure online service. How much of the $8.99 combined deals was applied to the online service previously? Perhaps $2 per customer.
We think that Netflix has likely done its homework on this price change and knows full well that there will be a lot of disaffected customers, but that the majority of them will fall back either to a single DVD at a time rental or to an unlimited online plan ‘ each of them $7.99. And Netflix costs will go through the floor, and its customer base will stay roughly the same, or suffer a one off small shrinkage, and then stabilize. Its revenues may take a small tumble too, but not its net income.
We have to remember that during the past year net subscriber additions have trebled at Netflix over the prior year, while the cost of acquiring a new customers has almost halved. As part of that marketing as a % of revenues has fallen. What has gone up are all forms of fulfillment expenses, while churn, the great enemy of this type of business, has been stable at 3.9% a month, slightly lower that it has been for the past two years.
If the ISP peering charges are part and parcel of the rationale of doing this price increase, then there is a magnificent PR opportunity available to Netflix, it might blame the entire ISP community for the price increases and uncover secret negotiations which have almost certainly been ongoing since Comcast changed its peering charges.
That way the price increases would be blamed on the likes of Comcast, AT&T and Verizon and all the anger that is currently being vented at Netflix management might be redirected to those companies, with a resulting negative impact on their TV services. But even if they are something to do with the reason, we do not anticipate Netflix going down the path of blaming its rivals, though it might leak out.
Netflix has an even better offering than it has ever had in the past and has just opened the doors internationally, last year in Canada, this year in Latin America. So this is perhaps an opportunist move, at the end of a long and healthy land grab for market share, to change its margin formula forever, at a time when other online video subscription services are not quite ready to take up the slack in offering quite such a good online service.
Probably only Amazon has any hope of pushing a similar offer behind anything approaching a ‘free’ banner, which it does within its Amazon Prime service. It can perhaps continue to offer free online video with sign up for Prime and attach that to a ‘Switch from Netflix’ campaign. No-one else is really ready for such a campaign and this may have been the last possible moment that Netflix has to adjust its economics forever.
There is also the word that every American finds rather ugly in anti-trust. Netflix was rapidly becoming dominant in both online DVD rental and online video streaming ‘ and yet it was establishing one area of dominance (online) when its costs were interrelated with its existing DVD based semi-monopoly. Separating pricing and costs so that the two services are no longer inter-dependent would have been one of the criticisms that might have been levied at it in any anti-trust court, and now costs are separate that’s not an option.