If IPTV was the main and rather surprise focus at the International Broadcast Conference in Amsterdam last year, one year on the business has had to rapidly mature, and there was definitely a feel, just like in the Lord of the Rings, that dark forces were circling the few islands of normality.
Microsoft IPTV throws a pall over proceedings because in the last year it’s icy grip on large IPTV telco sales has strengthened, and at the same time the understanding of its highly individual technology has grown, but is still far from perfect.
Microsoft has set a new standard for what to expect in an IPTV service, even if Microsoft itself doesn’t plan to deliver much of this prior to 2007, and to that extent IPTV providers throughout the show agreed that the market had, if not stalled, become a little more circumspect.
Where are the mosaic interfaces, in which thumbnail videos are presented on a screen instead of bland text program names? Where is the rapid channel change in IPTV? And where is the picture in picture capability so that two, three or more services can be watched at once?
Well the truth is that these are still only visible on the stands of Microsoft partners, but it doesn’t mean that the IPTV industry is taking the new paradigms lying down.
Middleware player Orca’s CEO Haggai Barel, when we last spoke to him, promised that within 12 months his company would certainly be offering all of the above, and would deliver them before Microsoft does.
At the IBC show these facilities are not on show on the Orca stand. So we presume they will be by next year. Instead Orca was showing a Macromedia Flash version of its Subscriber User Interface, and a new IPTV dashboard for operators to configure and differentiate their TV offerings. The dashboard allows operators to include automatic programming recommendations and lets users create a personalized EPG using a facility called MyTV. This is really just an EPG that shows everything a customer has access to, including DVR content, broadcast content, VoD content that has already been bought, in expiry date order, and pay per view and subscription VoD content, all on one EPG with search, and save search capability.
But Barel sticks to his earlier claims. ‘We will have all those things, but we will achieve them in smarter ways than Microsoft.
The encoder companies Harmonic and Tandberg were both at the show in force, both of which partner with Microsoft in the one area that it has not re-invented for IPTV, and both of which have to work with Microsoft’s mosaic approach.
‘It’s not difficult for us to do, although our competitors can’t do it yet, we just create two or more outputs for every stream. One for viewing as a full screen, one for the mosaic and one for the picture in picture viewing. We can also do another resolution that is just right for DVB-H delivery and another that is for PC streaming.’
Now Faultline can virtually, word perfect, attribute that quote to both Thierry Fautier, Director telco solutions convergent systems for Harmonic and also to Eric Cooney the CEO of Tandberg Television, give or take one or two words of emphasis.
The key thing is that now that they are both being asked to create multiple versions of each video stream, they can offer these services to operators that buy Microsoft IPTV and to those that don’t, giving the other players in IPTV a chance to catch up at least on Mosaic and Picture in picture.
Both companies agree that Scientific Atlanta, which also has some of the encoder contracts at SBC Communications, cannot yet do the necessary rapid compression and encoding, but we have a sneaking suspicion that even if SFA is not quite ready with these capabilities, it will meet its various deadlines for when it needs to have them.
Other ideas emerged when we were talking to US cable specialist BigBand Networks, as it talked about its own offerings such as the Switched Broadcast capabilities on its Broadband Multimedia Service Routers that it perfected for the cable industry, but which it is now targeting at IPTV too.
BigBand does everything in the network, and most of the things it does are all about saving bandwidth, and has two key approaches that it wants to offer to IPTV companies. One is that its intelligent routers can maintain a multicast in a specific region of the network, but only keep the programs that are currently being watched live on the multicast. So if from one particular DSLAM only 50 of the 200 TV programs offered are being watched, it holds back the multicast from the backhaul that is supplying that DSLAM and keeps it from congestion.
It can also do deep packet inspection to ensure that there are as few possible packet resends in an IPTV service, perhaps as few as none. This process doesn’t pick up lost packets, but it does pick up empty or corrupted packets. ‘We’re shocked that IPTV where it is going over copper cable still has a strategy of resending packets. That’s got to cause problems,’ said Fabrice Beer Gabel, Senior director of market development for BigBand, ‘Why not add error resiliency and forward error correction into the signal, rather than rely on retransmission of packets. FEC carries an overhead, but retransmission increases cost at the set top.’
Fast channel change in IPTV networks is, after all, created by the ability to rapidly send I-Frames and buffer frames directly to a set top rather than waiting for them to automatically fill from the next Group of Pictures in a frame sequence. It has become obvious that modern codecs, especially the VC1 codec from Microsoft have up to 200 frames in a cluster, each derived from a single I-Frame (full reference frame), whereas in MPEG 2 this was usually just 12 or 15 frames. This is why Microsoft has to have specialized servers that carry out I-Frame delivery and buffer filling when a channel is changed.
Rumor at the show has it that Microsoft IPTV keeps 15 seconds of data for every channel that is available on a service, in it’s A servers in the network (what happens when you neighbor yells ‘touchdown’ and you halve to wait 15 seconds?) So why can’t a router which holds back a multicast, ready to update any existing broadcast channel, not able to perform the same task, we asked BigBand, to which it replied, ‘I don’t want to talk about how to offer fast channel change yet, but it is possible.’
VC 1 specialist start up Inlet Technologies told us at the show that the SBC Communications IPTV installation, probably the most heavily scrutinized contract of its type, will use the Microsoft inspired VC 1 codec standard for VoD and yet it will use H.264 for broadcasting. It’s no big deal these days to have the set top fitted with a hardware decoder that can tell the difference between the two, and switch in real time. But managing two different types of streams makes little sense to us and merely adds software licensing cost and delivery complexity to a system that is already delayed.
Inlet itself makes VC1 add ons and also bets us that within 60 days there will be draft licensing terms for VC 1. You may remember that this was held up in negotiations with 11 unnamed essential patent holders, and Microsoft, in an MPEG LA licensing group.
Faultline guessed that those 11 were made up largely of the industrial offshoot of Columbia University, France T’l’com, Fujitsu, Matsushita, Philips, Robert Bosch, Samsung, Sharp, Sony, Toshiba, and Victor Company of Japan, because they all have patents in both of the prior MPEG video codecs.
If it is this 11 companies, then there is a huge disincentive to agree a license that allows Microsoft to continue to use the patents for free on PCs.
Inlet is hoping to land some of the work using its tools to hand compress some of the VoD films for SBC, so it has a vested interest in VC 1 marking it through to a license sometime soon.
It would be impossible to catch every IPTV announcement at IBC because there were so many, but we noticed that both the encoder companies Harmonic and Tandberg were citing wins, with Tandberg unveiling its DVB-S2 (the High Definition version of satellite delivery) claiming a 30% improvement in throughput over the previous generation, something confirmed by testing at the European Broadcasting Union.
Tandberg naturally says that it is the only company that can offer all three of the major codecs in both standard and high definition in its encoders, but this is a claim echoed by Harmonic with the launch of its Electra 5000 which it was showing for the first time at the show which does all these formats too.
Another idea that seeped out of a press conference with Cisco was the fact that it is now prepared to configure its core routers to be asynchronous to support networks that are laboring in getting video traffic out to the edge, rather than traveling equally fast in both directions. Cisco made a great play out of the 10s of millions of IPTV subscribers to whom its equipment ultimately routed traffic.
Cisco pictures a world where its Carrier Routing System (CRS 1) is configured in this way with a kind of super head end behind it. It also said that it could now support Dynamic Multicasts ‘ multicasts that never send the same video twice, but simply use data copies that are already queued for sending ‘ and this in turn supports broadcast Source Redundancy ‘ so if two operators are getting the same TV channel sent to them over the same network, it is only sent once.
On the Conditional Access front, perhaps the most significant uncovered at the show, was the fact that Nagravision has taken a license to Microsoft’s Media DRM, so that it can release programs that it has under the control of its own conditional access system, to run on Microsoft platforms such as XP Media Player, Xbox 360 and the portable Media players.
One other conditional access specialist, Ireland’s Latens. ‘Our first customer was Lyse in Norway in 2003 and we downloaded our CA to its existing boxes in its set tops. Lyse at the time had no DRM or other security and had gone VoIP and IPTV with a Tandberg head end, some middleware and a Kreatel Set top,’ said Andy Mathieson, Director of Latens.
‘We can now port our integration software which we call Glue, onto a set top in about 12 weeks including testing, and we can download it in the field. The thing is that there are still about 40 to 50 European IPTV systems out there that just don’t have any kind of DRM or conditional access.
‘Now they are getting letters from studios that are threatening to cut them off from content if they don’t fix the situation. It’s not just good business for us, but they have to consider an entire security agreement. How to handle content within their building, ingest rules, the addition of Macrovision to protect the analog hole. The trouble is in many of these sites, the RFP came from the network guys and they just had a paragraph saying ‘We’d like some DRM if you have it.”
Finally at least one vendor at the show, WiNetworks, was demonstrating high quality video over a WiMAX class broadband wireless network. WiNetworks came to prominence with its patented method for clipping a WiMAX antenna to a satellite dish and offering a return path to the direct to home satellite community.
The fact that the company was at the show talking about a deal with NDS, which already manages many of the conditional access systems for leading satellite players, including those controlled by its parent New Corp, such as DirecTV and BSkyB, means that WiNetworks can offer NDS Videoguard to protect satellite content and VoD content sent over WiMAX, at the same time.
No guesses then who may be the first satellite companies that suddenly decided to employ the WiNetworks technology which threatens to turn the satellite companies into even more formidable opponents of the US cable companies, with the addition of a return path for interactivity, high speed internet and voice. Neither NDS nor WiNetworks could comment on DirecTV or BSkyB’s interest in the technology.