Irdeto Access has hit back at the comments made by competitor Widevine in last week’s Faultline, defending its use of smart cards, denying that they have failed to keep up with the security requirements of major content companies.
Widevine executives suggested last week that IPTV installations are being forced by content companies to adhere to more exacting security requirements than cable and satellite operations and implied that smart cards were not fit for the purpose.
It gives us a good opportunity to look at what Irdeto has to offer and see how a traditional conditional access company plans to deal with these increased security requirements.
Doug Lowther, Irdeto VP of Marketing told us, ‘Conventional conditional access (CA) systems like Pisys (written ‘sys) have been battle hardened and tested over 10 to 15 years of use in the field.’
Lowther argues that many modern DRM systems sometimes lack those years of being in active duty and the result can be less practical protection than CA systems offer.
‘Irdeto now has three generations of smart card CA systems that are all still secure and have been secure since 2000. There have been attempts to hack our system and we’ve detected them. But the overall security effect is created by a combination of regulatory, legal and technological countermeasures and what we try to do at Irdeto is make it uneconomic to hack out CA system. Giving pirates multiple, smaller targets to focus on makes piracy more difficult and more expensive.
‘Any system CAN be hacked. That’s a fact of life in cryptography. It might take 10 MIT professors and a supercomputer, but it can be done. But why would anyone do that unless there was some assurance that the hack would work for a reasonable period of time.
‘The impression Widevine gave was that every smart card system is broken within 2 to 6 weeks and that new smart cards can’t be issued in that time. But we both have a fully software client, if customers prefer that, and a renewable smart card.
‘If a system gets hacked or if we detect an attempt to hack it, it doesn’t mean that the cards have to be changed. Although we have never had to renew our security since 2000, we regularly do software upgrades to the smart card for other reasons. There are always, in any CA system, regular changes both to keys and to the way keys are processed. We can send out new content decryption keys and these have to be decrypted themselves by existing keys. It is not a problem to isolate a single key on a single set top and stop it from working.
‘We can do this, with the agreement of the operator, in a way invisible to the customer,’ said Lowther.
‘And anyway Irdeto has its own SoftClient version which has no smart card at all. So if that’s what a customer insists on, they can have it.’
The SoftClient uses a patented technique called code obfuscation, which Lowther says is used to manipulate and hide any code that is sent across a network, so that if the code gets intercepted, it is unreadable to the hacker, which prevents reverse engineering.
In addition to obfuscation, the Irdeto SoftClient also uses behavioral monitoring, state tracking, node locking and its own trust management system. Irdeto has a number of its own patents for this and licenses some others.
Some recent RFPs do insist on software only approaches in IPTV and Lowther agreed with Widevine on the issue that content companies are insisting on stronger defenses for IPTV content than content sent over cable or satellite.
‘We talk to content companies all the time and they are nervous about IPTV. It’s the word internet that bothers them, they equate it with file sharing and piracy. Really cable and DSL are just two ways of getting content from point A to Point B, and into a set top box.’
Like Widevine, Irdeto is threatened by a Microsoft shutout in the IPTV markets, where it has quickly tied up many of the very large accounts with an entirely new, and untried IPTV system which uses Windows Media DRM.
‘We cannot say whether or not Windows Media DRM is man enough for the job or not, but there are inherent reasons why it is better for the content industry to work with multiple protection systems rather than just one. That’s why we have three CA systems, not just one. That way the whole content industry is not put in jeopardy with a single hack.
‘If everyone used the same system then there would be a huge incentive to crack it.’
So how will Irdeto cope with the increasing trend for CA systems to hand off content to home networks and portable players?
‘We will work with our recent acquisition Lockstream, which hopes to put its DRM client on a number of DVR’s and home networks.
Lockstream brought with it to Irdeto two DRM systems, mostly targeting cellular systems. A proprietary system which is in use at Hutchinson 3G, and more recently an OMA compliant DRM. However many CE companies are looking to the OMA technology for a DRM for other equipment, not just mobile phones.
So Lockstream will also give it an opportunity to straddle the conventional conditional access systems that live on set tops and home networks or portable players. Lowther said ‘We have a number of products under development based around the Lockstream acquisition, allowing content controlled by the CA system to be securely stored in a home network or Digital Video Recorder.’
‘We are also keeping our eye on the DRM interoperability efforts such as Coral and the SVP Alliance,’ said Lowther.
Irdeto Access says it now has 175 customers worldwide using its content security systems. Although the 320 strong Irdeto is based in Amsterdam, it is part of the multinational South African based Naspers group which has holdings in newspapers, ISPs and pay TV in Africa, China, Thailand, Greece and Cyprus. So it seems likely that Irdeto has a relationship with Naspers similar to the one NDS has with News Corp – not an entirely captive market, but definitely a preferred supplier.