It’s been a while since Irdeto has had anything serious to announce in Europe, and while we know that the CEO Graham Kill has returned from China to supervise the company’s turnaround, there is something irksome with the announcement this week that Liberty Global has just begun using Irdeto Multiscreen to protect linear and VoD multiscreen content. What is worrying is what did it use before and what happened to it?
First off the Horizon set top installation at Liberty Global remains shrouded in mystery, and we’re never quite sure what’s in the box. Yes about 12 companies were listed in the original Horizon launch, but at the time we were also told that it offered OTT around the home. The use of an Intel chip with onboard transcoding capabilities made everyone assume that Horizon used DTCP-IP to protect WiFi streams to multiscreen devices, which originated in the Horizon box ‘ well and good. But it may not have, and whatever it used, it should have been protected by something like Inside Secure’s DRM Fusion product, which uses the Arxan hardening toolkit to prevent keys being stolen from DTCP-IP. Given that the implementation was put together by NDS, then perhaps it used the same underpinnings that were used on the NDS OTT protection used for other clients like Sky Go in the UK. Perhaps it is simply that under Cisco this is no longer a priority.
There was also a purely OTT service internally referred to as Orion, which was also discussed, this we took to be a cloud based version of the same content, which was demonstrated at the same time as the Horizon announcement. We noted at the time that it was far inferior in video quality, a little like Horizon-lite, for the have-nots. It has been assumed that this version would be rolled out in territories that could not afford replacement set tops like Horizon, where ARPU was lower in places such as Romania, but that it would also be used by non-Horizon customers in the stronger territories.
Whenever you are dealing with a general purpose architecture like a phone or an iPad, especially one like an Apple device that uses its own security to protect the vendor, and doesn’t make a secure layer available to developers, then you need some way of stopping the keys being read by operating system tools like debuggers.
Irdeto has gone strangely quiet of late on this subject, losing out to Inside Secure in multiple installations that would in the past, you would have thought, been its natural property ‘ with obfuscation and system unit authentication and tamper-proofing – all tools of the trade for its Canadian acquisition Cloakware, and the Philips subsidiary Cryptoworks, acquired in 2007 and 2006 and marketed most recently as ActiveCloak for Media. Now this product has re-emerged as part of Irdeto Rights and it has just won an across the board deal at Liberty Global. That part is not wrong and Irdeto confirms that it has just rolled this out. This is not an 18 month old deal that has been sitting around waiting for approval.
What is wrong is just what product was used before and why was it swapped out. All we have right now is a guess, and we guess that this was a NDS product that’s been swapped out, and the likely reason will be for a weak security audit score, rather than rampant piracy, and that may have meant that Liberty Global was after more recent studio content and was turned down unless it changed the tablet and phone technology. We have put out questions and if we find out we will update this story.
We know you can’t charge a lot for protecting the protection that protects the revenue, and it’s in the order of 25 cents per device, and yet the system has to be downloadable and it has to work with widespread DRM systems like Microsoft’s PlayReady and it needs to add something to the party like device registration through a unique device number and do license limitations and enforce geo-limits as well.
As far as we can work out this system is really for live and VoD direct from the internet, and not transcoded out of the back of the Horizon box, so whatever was in place to protect DTCP-IP must still be there.
Irdeto said that the service is now live in the Netherlands and Ireland with Liberty Global, and will go to other European countries shortly.
‘As the number of connected devices that consumers use to view content increases, operators should be looking to ensure that they are doing their utmost to secure valuable assets and that customers are able to easily access the content they desire on a device of their choosing,’ said Graham Kill, CEO, Irdeto. ‘In selecting Irdeto Rights, Liberty Global has proven that it is committed to protecting premium content, something that Irdeto is proud to be part of.’ Previously Irdeto has only won recent deals with this technology at Orange in Indonesia.