Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

21 September 2005

It’s obvious – Microsoft can kill Google by buying its customers

When Steve Ballmer yelled at a departing Microsoft employee that he would ‘kill Google’ we had no idea just how direct a method he had in mind. Buying all or part of AOL may be the first part of the master plan, as Google relies heavily on the advertising pages that come from Yahoo, since it now syndicates its search to Google.

One estimate suggested that Google would lose as much as $380 million of advertising revenue if AOL dropped its search engine and took on MSNs. That would cut Google’s profit by something like 25%, potentially giving its huge share price something of a tumble.

No wonder Google is thought to be entering the bidding to partner with Time Warner on AOL instead of Microsoft. However the move by Microsoft could still potentially backfire, although with its cash mountain you would expect it to win the day. Google’s only chance is to paint Time Warner a sufficiently rosy future picture of the outcome of AOL partnering with Google. Then perhaps a lot more than that $380 million could be saved.

For instance the new physical fiber network that Google is believed to be in the process of putting together (see separate story), be used to transport more than just voice, advertising and wi-fi traffic. This could also become a conduit for video services, providing another route to market for the remainder of Time Warner’s content? Could the Google Video search capability index all of Time Warner’s precious content and give it another lease of life?

It’s too late for the Google Talk VoIP service to go out to all the AOL customers because AOL has launched its own complete VoIP package service (see separate story). The AOL Time Warner merger had some original logic and perhaps a company as imaginative as Google could make that logic work.

On the other hand Microsoft in June 2003 paid Time Warner $750 million, mostly in settlement of legal disputes, from when AOL inherited the complaints of Netscape, buying that company right in the middle of the Microsoft anti-trust trial.

But the deal also gave AOL rights to use certain Microsoft tools and the two said that they would collaborate on long-term digital media initiatives, some of which they are well into.

That agreement was certainly not a mere settlement of differences but included the Free use of Internet Explorer by AOL for 7 years, collaboration on Windows Media player and DRM software and early access to Microsoft technology for AOL.

And since then the two companies, Time Warner and Microsoft, have become almost inextricably interlinked, working together on standards and buying into companies like ContentGuard together.

So Microsoft must be ahead on this deal as it comes to the table and has the money to tempt Time Warner.

The New York Post has been painting the deal as if it was a 50/50 partnership, with Microsoft buying half of AOL with other statements suggesting that the deal is nothing like that adventurous and is just a form of marketing co-operation.

Yahoo also has time to throw its hat in the ring, and discussion between it and Time Warner has also been reported. AOL has been losing subscription customers rapidly, which is why it recently switched its business from purely subscription based to increasingly advertising based.