We missed the Kaltura Tvinci acquisition last week by a few hours, but thought it is worth saying a few words about it this week. This looks to us like the merger of a successful target, acquired by an unsuccessful predator, looking for a way out. We have to be brutal here.
Kaltura has always gone down the ‘open source’ route and began life creating a Content Management System, which was more suited to today’s adaptive bit rate OTT environment, keeping files as ready to package, to be converted just in time to the right delivery format, be that HLS or IIS Smooth Streaming or Adobe. There are 100s of firms which offered that over the past four years, but this particular company has been mostly web focused, and had few or no design wins with broadcasters or pay TV operators ‘ in other words companies that could pay top dollar. It has relied on its open source credentials to amass 18,000 or so developers to supports it cause. We’re not quite sure of its business model but it looks like it charged a usage license for part of the product which are not open source and for hosting the system. In a sense Kaltura began life as a WordPress for web video.
Last year Kaltura came out with a Netflix in a box, which filled in all the activities between the CMS and the delivery and billing and integration with recommendation systems etc’. It has landed maybe three deals that it can talk about, the largest with Sesame Street to take content direct OTT.
Meanwhile Tvinci, a company that we have said many times has little to recommend it in terms of original IPR, has won better deals based on the remainder of the equation ‘ an end to end service that has found favor at Kabel Kiosk, the Eutelsat OTT subsidiary in Germany, which reaches some 3.5 million homes there. Other deals have been as far afield as Singapore, the Philippines and Latin America and one of these at Singapore’s Mediacorp, was through the invitation of Ericsson, a nice relationship of you can get it.
Tvinci facilitates monetization for OTT video using direct payments for Pay Per View, subscriptions and coupon based business models and can target delivery to any internet enabled device be it a PC, Mac, internet connected TV, set top, games console, smartphone or iPad. The system also maintains recommendations and keeps track of viewing habits and payment preferences.
So this is not the case of tying two bricks together to see if they float, but tying a piece of wood to a brick and see if the wood floats any worse. We might ask if it might float long enough for Ericsson to buy it, but Ericsson has already placed its bets by buying Azuki Systems in the US, a 40 man start-up which has eaten far less money than Kaltura and has been focused on TV Everywhere since day one.
The other thing that Kaltura has been good at is raising money, and it has raised almost $120 million, and most recently raised $47 million in what we thought was a last gasp attempt at breaking even, having tried to change its business model from an open source CMS to a full end to end OTT model.
Clearly that software does not work half as well as Tvinci’s and the 60 people at the Israeli company will now join the Kaltura R&D team in Israel. It turns out that Tvinci also has its own CMS and really going forward there is no need for Kaltura to have Open Source pretensions any longer, and it can just sell software.