YouTube has shrugged off competition with increasing ease over its 10 year history to become totally dominant in distribution of user generated, niche and emerging content, but at the same time the growing revenue opportunities keep attracting new competitors. This year is bringing a new wave including at least one with serious backing and a coherent business plan, which may at least dent YouTube’s armor.
This comes at a time when the online video space as a whole has broadened into four distinct sectors. One we might define as TV Everywhere from established pay TV operators including linear programming, secondly online VoD dominated by Netflix in the US particularly, and thirdly pure play OTT TV services embracing both on demand and live.
YouTube straddles the fourth category which used to be called simply UGC (User Generated Content), but has expanded to include a range of professionally produced material as well, again both music and video, typically from emerging producers. We can almost identify a fifth category comprising ultra-short form video, dominated by Vine with its site for five to six second clips, but this will always be a minor art form. It has more appeal than say the mini-sagas in fiction comprising no more than 50 words, but is still limited in its ability to generate subscription or advertising revenue and is in any case embraced also by YouTube to some extent, so is unlikely to become a major sector.
YouTube itself has faced one competitor, Daily Motion, ever since its emergence in 2005, but that has fallen by the wayside somewhat, with its influence largely confined to its native France. Nevertheless in gaining 120 million monthly visitors and becoming Europe’s largest video website, it had done well enough to attract the attention of Yahoo, which tabled an offer of $300 million for a majority stake in April 2013. That was blocked by the French government, short sightedly because the extra investment could have made it a stronger competitor against YouTube. For Yahoo it has had the effect of refocusing effort more on the VoD sector, but there too it is having a hard time making up much ground given that not only Netflix, but others like Hulu and Amazon are already well established there.
Although coming from a lower base in this sector YouTube may have been more concerned by Comcast’s entry, given its much stronger position in blockbuster English language content, although again that pitched it more against subscription VoD options and it has not gained that much traction. But now the most significant new competitor to emerge for a while is coming in the form of Vessel, a well-endowed start-up with $75 million first round backing from investors and co-founded by someone with clout in the industry, ex Hulu CEO Jason Kilar. He is still an executive of DreamWorks Animation, whose productions include Shrek and Kung Fu Panda. The other co-founder is also ex Hulu, former CTO Richard Tom.
Unlike other competitors, Kilar has set about competing with YouTube in its core lucrative market for exclusive content from emerging stars such as comedian and singer Shane Dawson and video logger Ingrid Nilsen. Kilar’s core business model is simply to lure such stars to his site in return for a better deal than they get on YouTube, where they keep just 55% of ad revenue their content generates. This has been a bone of contention for YouTube artists for several years, so Kilar has been trying to exploit this.
He has however found it hard going convincing stars to abandon a medium with 1.3 billion users that has made many producers and performers rich and famous, for a start-up. Kilar has had to revise his business model and cut his cloth accordingly.
He realized that he could not entice creators or performers completely away from YouTube with its huge audience, so his plan was to offer extra money in return for an exclusive window on Vessel first. This would be paid from a pool comprising 60% of Vessel’s subscription revenue distributed pro-rated by usage, on top of the 70% ad revenue. Meanwhile subscribers would be offered access to this exclusive window for $3 a month for the premium option with just a few ads that the user may be able to select. There will also be a free, fully ad supported version.
But Vessel found few creators willing at this stage to concede Vessel an exclusive window anywhere near as long as the 30 days it had hoped for, and in the end the company had to come right down to three days. On that basis the site opened to creators on December 17th 2014 with the promise of consumer launch early this year, now imminent.
On its site, Vessel claims that videos will earn $50 per 1000 views during this three day early access window, 20 times more than creators earn from free web distribution. After that, creators will continue to earn money through distribution of their videos on the free, ad-supported web, but that will now include other sites such as YouTube as well as Vessel. Kilar concedes that free, ad-supported distribution will continue to play an important role in video and make up a substantial proportion of revenues earned. But the key proposition is of a site geared to that exclusive early window, which Vessel hopes will increase in duration, distinguishing the site from YouTube by having a clearer focus and aiming for a consistent quality of service.
Vessel is also looking to retain and expand its audience by commissioning exclusive content of its own and has signed up actor Alec Baldwin to produce a web series called Love Ride, which will provide relationship advice for couples during taxi rides. Vessel has also managed to poach from YouTube three multi-channel networks (MCNs), Machinima, Tastemade and DanceOn.
Based in San Francisco, Vessel backers include venture capital firms Benchmark Capital and Greylock Partners, as well as Amazon founder Jeff Bezos’ investment firm Bezos Expeditions. It is likely to be the first among a number of new YouTube wannabes to emerge in 2015. It may be the only one to hit the ground running with a range of appealing content already up its sleeve after signing up in total almost 200 of YouTube’s top visual content creators. All the haggling has delayed the launch a bit, but Kilar was anxious to avoid just being another run of the mill YouTube competitor destined to fall quickly by the way side.
Neither Vessel nor any other competitor will derail the YouTube juggernaut. But we do believe that collectively they will contain YouTube’s market share. To an extent this is a natural organic process in that firms with market dominance inevitably leave scope for new competitors to come in with attractive offers to both suppliers and customers. In the case of web services especially there is also an underlying appetite for the next cool site and it could well be that Vessel will be the one to fill up on that sentiment this year.
And while advertisers do like YouTube’s huge volume of users and range of content, there is continuing concern over the consistency of its ad placements. This in turn is generating a growing appetite for new platforms hosting high-quality, well-produced content. It is worth noting that a lot of online video is not that conducive for advertisers, such as clips that are either too short or not brand friendly. The trick then for the likes of Vessel will be to tap this pent up demand for desirable online ad inventory without putting off its own subscribers. Although $2.99 a month may not be a lot, subscribers might wonder why they still have to sit through ads when You Tube is offering an ad free option.
There is certainly plenty for all to play for. In the US alone digital video ad spending increased by about 55% in 2014 to reach almost $6 billion and is set to go on rising almost as fast this year.