Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

24 January 2014

Lantiq cuts vectoring deal with Assia as vectoring market accelerates

The extended partnership between fabless communications chip maker Lantiq and broadband software developer Assia is just one of many recent developments foretelling a boom in VDSL vectoring deployments by major Telcos. This is because the economics of FTTH (Fiber To The Home) only stack up in greenfields or densely populated areas and yet Telcos badly need a bandwidth lift to keep pace with MSOs as they deploy DOCSIS 3.0.

It should have been obvious from the outset that FTTH would not displace copper in the foreseeable future and that Telcos would need to continue investing in new technologies to get more out of their existing copper infrastructures. As it happens VDSL vectoring fits the bill perfectly, since it actually complements rather than competes with the fiber build out strategies most Telcos are engaged in. It is not true as some analysts suggest that VDSL vectoring is an alternative to FTTH, since it will be deployed alongside it by many Telcos, with the latter being preferred in new building developments and a few densely populated areas where it makes economic sense. For new builds FTTH costs no more to install than VDSL and so is a no brainer. For some affluent urban areas where fiber is already quite extensive the extra cost of going the last 100 meters or so may be worth paying, in return for the extra subs that can be charged. But generally that last 100 meters accounts for 70% of the cost of FTTH deployment and as a result it works out at $1,300 per home compared with $250 for VDSL, according to data from Ikanos, one of the main DSL chip makers, which admittedly has an axe to grind.

As such findings became apparent, Telcos either postponed or scaled down FTTH deployment, instead pushing fiber just close enough to enable VDSL with vectoring to be competitive with DOCSIS 3.0 cable offerings. Verizon was one of the first to see the light with its decision to wind down deployment of its fiber based FiOS service in 2010.

Such decisions were aided by the development of vectoring pioneered very much by Assia but with Alcatel-Lucent perhaps making the most headway in terms of installed kit. This can be combined with copper pair bonding, recruiting two pairs when available, as they often are, to double the initial bandwidth. Vectoring then alleviates the impact of cross talk interference between copper pairs in a bundle. Crosstalk reduces the achievable bit rate by making it harder to untangle the signals from the unpredictable background noise. Vectoring makes crosstalk interference predictable by measuring it in real time on each wire, so that it can then, in effect, be cancelled by generating a counter signal. This typically enables bit rates of 100 Mbps downstream and 30 Mbps upstream to be achieved over single copper pairs at distances up to 400 meters, or double that with bonding, which would be sufficient for most prospective applications, including say a few channels of ultra HD.

Further techniques have been developed to go even faster, such as Alcatel-Lucent’s ‘Phantom Mode’, which only works with two pairs, by exploiting electrical differences between the two to create a third channel, increasing downstream speeds to 300 Mbps over 400 meters. But Alcatel-Lucent has now dropped Phantom Mode or at least delayed bringing it to market, saying the extra speed boost is no longer needed because vectoring on its own has worked better than expected in delivering consistently high bit rates over copper pairs up to 1 Km in length.

Another factor is that deploying vectoring alone is disruptive enough, even though it is cost effective in the longer run. Phantom Mode adds yet another complication and is only applicable to connections with two or more pairs, while vectoring operates over single pairs as well. Furthermore Phantom Mode only works once vectoring has been deployed properly and been fully optimized ‘ it is the icing on the vectoring cake.

As it is Telcos have their hands full with vectoring. One general issue is that vectoring is not compatible with Local Loop Unbundling (LLU), which means Telcos have to offer the vectored service to competitors via special bit stream services rather than a direct connection. For this reason regulatory clearance is often required for Telcos to introduce vectoring. This was the case for Deutsche Telekom, which was granted approval in August 2013 by the country’s regulator BNA and the European Commission.

The situation is that cost and ease of deployment have become key competitive factors for VDSL vectoring now that just about all incumbent and major Telcos are either deploying it or considering doing so. Such considerations have shaped Lantiq’s strategy and its collaboration with Assia, which actually started in October 2012 when the two announced they were working together to optimize performance and configuration of vectored VDSL. Soon after that Lantiq received a license to Assia’s intellectual property for its vectored VDSL chipsets. In return Assia gained a license to Lantiq’s intellectual property relating to DSM (Dynamic Spectrum Management).

The latest announcement puts the bones on that cross-licensing deal with firm plans to incorporate Assia’s DSL Expresse Smart Vectoring management software with Lantiq vectored VDSL chipsets. The emphasis now is on helping operators automatically plan, predict, manage and optimize the performance of their vectored VDSL networks, with the minimum of internal engineering effort. The game is already moving from being a value added, engineering intensive exercise towards being commoditized, so that operators do not constantly have to tune their system to obtain the maximum throughput, any more than they have to with fiber.

Lantiq, which has so far shipped almost two million vectored VDSL ports to DSLAM vendors, is one of three dominant players in DSL silicon, alongside Broadcom and Ikanos. Broadcom is the clear overall DSL leader but Ikanos has clung onto number one spot for VDSL, which as we have seen has so far been more of a specialist market. But as we have also shown it is becoming commoditized and at the same time Ikanos off the pace, with its VDSL share slipping from 80% to under 50% over the last three years. True to form Ikanos was first to market among the big three with vectoring, demonstrating its chips based on the ITU’s then emerging G.vector technology in March 2011. This was a multi-chip solution and since then Ikanos has struggled to bring it down into a single chip version swiftly enough.

Broadcom then entered with its own G.vector based chips in October 2013. G.vector represents an attempt to create a standard for mitigating the effects of the Far End Crosstalk (FEXT) through vectoring. As in other departments Broadcom is ready to walk in and dominate the VDSL vectoring market too, having left the early running to Ikanos and of course Alcatel-Lucent, which we suspect it now supplies with chips (we have it confirmed in the Belgacom installation). Lantiq’s antics with Assia are designed to stay in the game with low cost and easily deployable products.

The natural question is which of these three are making chips for Alcatel-Lucent. Broadcom was a major supplier for Alcatel-Lucent’s ADSL solution but none of the companies will confirm what the arrangement is today. Alcatel-Lucent initially developed its own chip sets for vectoring and Phantom Mode but will be looking to one of the three chip makers now that price is critical. Broadcom must now be the favorite.

Alcatel-Lucent is the clear market leader at the system level and well placed to regain the dominance in vectoring it once had in basic ADSL broadband, when its DSLAMs hooked up over 40% of the world’s connections. This slumped to less than 20% under onslaught from the Chinese, especially Huawei and ZTE, but so far Alcatel-Lucent has cleaned up in Europe over vectoring where most of the early adopters are. Customers include Belgacom, Telekom Austria, TDC Denmark and P&T Luxembourg, with some traction elsewhere. China Telecom has been conducting trials with Alcatel-Lucent, while in December 2013 Israeli Telco Bezeq, announced it was deploying the VDSL2 vectoring.

We understand that Lantiq is the chip provider for the Adtran Deutsche Telekom vectoring effort, although this has not been officially confirmed. Remember Adtran acquired Nokia Siemens Networks broadband operation.

Given its relative success in vectoring compared with other sectors it is not surprising Alcatel-Lucent is accelerating execution of its so called Shift Plan, a strategy to reposition the company as a specialist vendor of IP Networking and super broadband, with VDSL2 vectoring center stage.