Toshiba and its US subsidiary, Toshiba America Electronic Components, have escaped the worst possible outcome from the US trial against Lexar, fending off an injunction to immediately stop shipping flash memory into the US.
The judge presiding over the trade secret lawsuit with Lexar denied the injunction despite in March presiding over a Jury trial that found Toshiba guilty, and awarding damages of $465.4 million, about two thirds of Lexar’s existing $681 million annual revenue.
At that time the Californian Superior Court in San Jose found that Toshiba and its US subsidiary, Toshiba America Electronic Components had misappropriated NAND flash-related trade secrets from Lexar.
Lexar also hoped to damage US market leader SanDisk with the injunction, because it sells the technology in some of its controllers, a move that would have immediately brought yet another legal action, which the court has now averted.
This dust up between Toshiba and Lexar happened despite the fact that the two worked together and that Toshiba invented NAND flash and the Japanese invested in Lexar when it was a start up. Emails sent to Toshiba’s HQ, discussing the Lexar research, were taken as conclusive evidence by a US jury while Toshiba insists the jury made a mistake.
‘We are pleased with Judge Komar’s statement that there is no basis for injunctive relief as sought by Lexar in the trade secret lawsuit,’ said Julius G. Christensen, senior vice president and general counsel for Toshiba America Electronic Components. ‘As this litigation moves to its conclusion, we will continue to pursue all legal avenues available to us to correct what we believe to be an erroneous jury verdict in this case.’ An appeal is certain to follow.
Toshiba’s R&D expenditure is around four times the revenues of Lexar, at $2.4 billion and it holds some 50,000 patents, home and abroad, with something like 5,750 of them relating to flash memory and other semiconductor technologies, while Lexar holds just 72. It is virtually impossible that Lexar could make flash memory without infringing on one or two of those patents and the whole case began when Toshiba pointed out to Lexar that it was in breach of its own patents, so this action was a counter suit.
The Japanese electronics conglomerate made an investment in Lexar in 1997 which made it the company’s largest shareholder at the time, effectively funding its business.
Samsung and Sony are both licensees of the Lexar technology, but pay a lot less than the jury award, because the award also included damages for misappropriating trade secrets, not just for royalties
However US market leader SanDisk along with a number of other companies, including Fuji Photo Film, Eastman Kodak, Memorex Products, PNY Technologies and Verbatim have accused Lexar of false and misleading claims for its controller technology in another case that has yet to come to court.
All of the Lexar patents relate to programmable controllers that increase write speeds and reduce overhead, using what it describes as a proprietary indirect mapping methodology, a technique for storing, accessing and erasing information within a flash device.
In March Faultline wrote that the amount of the award is almost certain to be reduced on appeal. Samsung and Sony have never paid more than $17.7 million in any one year to use them. We expect the two to settle out of court for less before the end of an appeal.
This seems to be the stock market’s opinion also given that after the initial court victory it still valued Lexar at less than the amount of the jury award. Currently Lexar is losing money.