Liberty Global grew a tiny fraction this year up 0.2% in real terms as reported to $18.28 billion, but as usual made out that its performance was off the charts. The truth is that many of the markets it operates in are saturated and every one of its major Western European countries showed revenue going backwards – the UK, Germany, Belgium and Switzerland/Austria, and its explanation was merely currency fluctuation. The Netherlands is only going forwards because it is comparing last year’s number without Ziggo’s contribution.
The company always uses what it calls Rebased Revenue Growth, taken to be a restatement based on differences in GAAP principles in different parts of the world, acquisition accounting adjustments and differences between in-house policies and acquired businesses and so it is still claiming growth of 4%. We do not see it and it looks as much to us that the Netherlands business was merged with Vodafone to segregate its accounting from the main business as for any other strategic reason.
In the Netherlands it lost 200,000 video customers, a fact that you cannot blame on currency fluctuation and it has loudly blamed this on Ziggo, and must be partially accounted for by ex-customers at Ziggo who have moved outside the UPC footprint, and do not want to go back to being a Liberty customer.
Given that the Netherlands only represents 4 million out of 22 million video customers, to have 50% of your video losses from that cluster, is a good reason to cut and run. Once Ziggo is pushed into the Vodafone joint venture, Liberty Global will only report what cash is generated by it, it will not consolidate the numbers, and neither will Vodafone.
It is actually worse that these numbers suggest. Video may have lost 400,000 subscribers throughout 2015 but given that in both the Central European region and Latin America it grew video subscribers, the Western European losses are at least 450,000 and may be higher.
What seems to be going on is that actually instead of Liberty Global’s Horizon system attracting new customers, it is a bit like old analog and new digital pay TV – in the old days you shifted as many people from low paying analog to digital as you could and all your losses came from analog. What Liberty is now doing is shifting people to “next generation” TV services from basic video. It claims to have migrated 1.5 million during 2015. It includes Horizon, Virgin TiVo, and an Horizon like system elsewhere and said that it increased its Horizon TV subscriber base by over 800,000, added 350,000 TiVo subscribers in the UK and nearly 140,000 Digital TV subscribers in Belgium with a Horizon-like user interface, and upgraded over 170,000 legacy boxes to its “Horizon-light” platform in the Czech Republic. This now sits at some 4.7 million customers or 29% (up from 22% a year ago) of the total across its footprint. Presumably it counts the Ziggo ActiveVideo supported VoD customers among these which use a cloud rendered UI.
Significantly either the investment community totally bought the idea that Liberty Global is doing fine, or it loved the Vodafone tie-up, because the stock price rose almost 15% over the past few days, with a similar 6% growth for Vodafone stock over the same period.