It seems that Liberty Global is determined to have its legal battle with the Netherlands ACM regulator, and go ahead and present it with a ‘fait accompli’ merger deal with Ziggo.
The resulting merger will give it overnight 60% of the pay TV market by number of homes, more like 70% by ARPU value, and just under 3 million broadband lines. It would immediately take it beyond the incumbent telco KPN, which has only 2.7 million domestic broadband lines and 1.9 million TV customers. On top of this the combination of Liberty Global and Ziggo would dwarf the number of hotspots that KPN owns, given that they have just created 2 million homespot based commercial hotspots during 2013 in the Netherlands.
While the European Commission could not initially get involved this early, it would almost certainly tear apart any deal that was done, if the ACM chooses not to prevent the merger from going ahead.
In the Netherlands the ACM entity was created only in April last year, and its full name is the Autoriteit Consument en Markt, a merger of three previous authorities: the Dutch Competition Authority (the NMa), the Consumer Authority and the Independent Post and Telecommunications Authority. Previously the NMa was very hostile to mergers which created overnight monopolies, but perhaps Liberty Global senses that the merged authority is less likely to object to such a merger. The new authority only takes charge during January 2014 and maybe it thinks it can slip the deal through before the organization finds its feet. Unlikely.
This week KPN has just announced that it will acquire yet another 9% of Reggefiber, taking ownership to 60%, and will consolidate it into its figures for the first time in its next results. In the past the NMa has been criticized for allowing KPN to go about easily acquiring companies that either build out fiber or provide fiber services, given its dominance in the sector.
Today Liberty Global owns some 28.5% of Ziggo and has already made an offer to buy the rest of it, and has gone into a huddle over Christmas with Ziggo management in order to work out the details of a deal. News reports say that this will happen in the 3rd week of January, and it has yet to be decided if Deutsche Telekom ex-CEO Rene Oberman will stay at the company, having just arrived as the new CEO, after the deal is stuck. Ziggo’s market cap is only €6.7 billion, and it rejected an offer above this price for the company from Liberty prior to Christmas.
We maintain that the only way that Liberty Global can win this deal is by letting the ACM block it and counter-suing and doing the same again against the European Commission. As far as we know, no-one has ever successfully managed anything like this and we’re not sure the European Courts system has that much power.
However the ACM may be more interested in the bearing this has on the larger, and more volatile mobile market. Ziggo has just instigated a quad play, built around its triple play fixed line services and a Vodafone MVNO. Combine this with Liberty Global doing much the same, and their combined strength in Homespots, and there is a genuine threat to cellular stability in the country.
In the details of any deal that emerges, we must look closely at any guarantees that Ziggo asks for in the event that the merger is later called off or blocked by the regulator. If it can negotiate such terms, it could be in for a windfall.