Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 May 2014

Liberty Global poised for growth with total focus on quad play

Liberty Global has posted a much better set of figures for Q1 2014 than for the last quarter of 2013, with revenues up 2% at $4.5 billion and operating income up 10% at $582 million, along with an organic gain after discounting acquisitions of 345,000 in RGUs (Revenue Generating Units) to 49 million.

This has provoked some gushing sentiment from stock analysts, with Goldman Sachs for example reckoning the operator’s shares will put on 24% over the near term to reach its target figure of $53, reflecting a strong foundation for growth, which was held back by a number of one off pressures during 2013. One of these was the acquisition of Virgin Media in the UK for $23 billion during the first quarter of 2013, leading to a stumble, with continuing concern over loss of broadband share, which has declined slowly, but steadily from around 25% in 2007 to 20% now, with Sky in the UK having overtaken Virgin.

Against this Virgin Media’s strategy based on its hybrid box co-designed with Tivo has been successful in migrating customers to its next generation connected TV platform, with a further 155,200 added in Q1 to bring the total to 2.1 million, or 56% of its TV base. The strategy remains as originally stated when the Tivo platform was launched in December 2010, to convert the whole base, although with the difference now that the operator is owned by Liberty Global, the rest of which is set on a parallel course but with its home grown Horizon box.

At first it looked like Tivo would lose out as a result of the Liberty Global acquisition, given that Horizon was being rolled out elsewhere, but this would not have made sense since the Tivo deployment was at a more advanced stage. Currently there are just 550,000 Horizon TV customers spread across four countries, the Netherlands, Switzerland, Ireland and Germany, although at an accelerating rate with 250,000 added in Q1. So it made sense not to tamper with Tivo until the Horizon roll out is complete, giving time to plot a convergence course that will involve incorporation of intellectual property from both sides into a combined new platform in around two years’ time.

That at least is the plan at the moment, as was hinted by Tivo’s Chief Financial Officer and senior VP of corporate development and strategy Naveen Chopra at the recent Cable Congress in Amsterdam, when he suggested that his company had developed a closer relationship with Liberty Global since the Virgin Media takeover, having originally failed to get a foot in the door when Horizon was out for tender. Now Tivo is claiming it will not only continue to be involved at Virgin Media but also get a stake through intellectual property around the UI in other Liberty Global territories.

Liberty Global’s overall strategy has crystallized into its likely state for the next few years during Q1, finally moving out of original content with completion of the sale of most of its Chellomedia division in January 2014 to AMC Networks for $1 billion. This mirrored Virgin Media’s earlier exit from the content business by selling its wholly owned TV channels to arch rival Sky early in 2010.

Liberty Global is now operating more evenly across the whole spectrum of quad play, building up its mobile strategy around both WiFi and 4G/LTE to become a fully-fledged MVNO (Mobile Video Network Operator) while also achieving universal fixed line coverage where possible in those countries where it does not have that already.

The other prong is of course multiscreen and hybrid TV within the home around Tivo and Horizon, combined with expansion into OTT, where Virgin Media has led the way, firstly by launching a version of the BBC iPlayer catch up service through its HFC broadcast platform in May 2009 and then providing access to Netflix from November 2013, having also incorporated YouTube.

Liberty Global CEO Mike Fries hinted recently that the operator was considering making Netflix available similarly within its broadcast environment in other countries. But then he added that in the longer term Liberty Global would be looking to launch its own OTT service, having consistently argued that cable operators are well placed to offer everything an online provider such as Netflix can with additional benefits in quality of service and connectivity around the home. For Liberty Global a relationship with Netflix will be a temporary one of convenience that may be annulled once its own OTT service gets going.

This growing emphasis on OTT makes sense in the context not just of the wider industry but also Liberty Global’s own subscriber trends. It has been continuously losing overall video RGUs every quarter since 2007, so that one of the odd wrinkles of its Q1 2014 results was that a further decline of 71,000 video RGUs was its best result over those 7 years. Some of these customers still subscribe to Liberty Global for broadband, having perhaps cut or shaved the cord just for video, but losing these RGUs does dent the overall strategy for dominance in quad play. Liberty Global has continually said that this is part and parcel of converting customers from analog to digital, a process that is still ongoing across its footprint.

This is why OTT will be increasingly important for Liberty Global in attempting to reverse the longstanding decline in video RGUs by offering lower priced packages, rather as some other major operators are already doing, like Sky in the UK with is Now TV.

On the fixed line front, Liberty Global’s main focus has been on securing its acquisition of Ziggo, the Dutch rival to its own UPC Netherlands, which would achieve almost total broadband coverage in the country, given that nearly every home is passed by cable. The deal had been agreed between the companies for $9.3 billion, but the European Union’s antitrust authority decided in March 2014 to conduct a review, since with the combined operator having access to over 90% of the country’s households, it exceeded a threshold for such action. The EU has now decided to move the deal to a phase two investigation to give a further working 105 days to scrutinize it. Liberty Global insists that the deal is therefore on course for completion during the second half of 2014, although we expect either further delaying tactics then or an outright refusal to allow the deal to go ahead.

The issue here is that the deal can only be regarded as anti-competitive within the province of the Netherlands, rather than across Europe as whole as is within the EU’s remit. It is only within the Netherlands where the deal would give the combined company a dominant position in both TV and especially broadband, with KPN the primary competitor. The takeover should therefore fall within the province of the Netherlands Authority for Consumers and Markets, but this is a new body that has only just been formed through a merger between other regulators. It has requested that the European Commission let it handle the case, but Liberty Global has openly stated it wants to work with the European Commission only.

It is not of course up to Liberty Global which regulator it works with, but it is true that the Commission wants to take charge because it considers it will require a lot of work and some experience, while helping prepare a better case to block the merger later at the national Dutch level.

We think therefore the Ziggo takeover is far from done and dusted, although failure would not severely dent Liberty Global’s plans given that now other markets, notably the UK and Germany, have taken over as its most important ones. Growth prospects in the Netherlands are relatively poor.

On mobile, Liberty Global is progressing on several fronts, having recently launched cellular services in Switzerland, and revamped its quad-play offers in the UK around the Virgin Mobile brand and expanded its WiFi-Spots in Belgium and the Netherlands to over 1.5 million locations. Fries indicated that Liberty Global would be looking to provide HetNet services combining WiFi and cellular in those markets where it does have WiFi hot spot capacity. The plan is to expand its WiFi coverage achieved through a combination of home router partitioning and switching on additional public SSIDs in residential gateways to provide external coverage.