Our first thought when Liberty Media said that it would buy Kabel Baden-W’rttembergs (Kabel BW), the third largest German cable operator, was that the opera is not over until the fat lady sings, a thought we shared with you back in March this year, referring to the fact that Liberty Global would have 6.9 million out of the 19.8 million German cable homes once the deal is done.
Liberty Global has already bought UnityMedia, which at the time had 4.6 million TV customers in Germany, and the merged Liberty German operation did appear to be smaller in Germany than Kabel Deutshcland Group (KDG) by some way, given that KDG has 8.5 million German customer homes.
But if you take into account the cashflow, profit and shareholder value, the two units that Liberty would hold throw off far more cash, have far more advanced infrastructure, and therefore need far less investment – so the ownership in Germany would really be one sided in Liberty’s favor. Effectively these are the three largest German cable operators and we expected the cartel office, the Bundeskartellamt to interject and now it has. Many cable operators are technically just campus management teams which have laid cable in MDUs and own the cable, and contract with these three anyway for content.
Of course like most cable operations in Europe, if not the world, neither of these two companies compete head on for customers, since the cable build out allocations have always been offered on a regional basis, with KDG reaching the largest areas in Germany but the other two based in the Baden-W’rttemberg, North Rhine-Westphalia and Hesse regions.
And the statement from the Bundeskartellamt refers directly to this lack of competition. Had it wanted competition back in the bad old days when cable was getting its grip in Germany, the regulators should not have copied the US and allocated license by region ‘ but at the time, overbuilding, the habit of building not one, but two networks in the same region from rivals, made cable unprofitable.
It would have been very difficult for the Bundeskartellamt to confirm this purchase because for years it has said told KDG that it was not allowed to buy Kabel BW or UnityMedia, so how can it let the largest cable operator in Europe buy a dominant position in Germany from having no share in Germany at all two years ago?
You might have thought that the Bundeskartellamt would be happy. It now has two strong rivals slugging it out in the cable sector in Germany, although it would rather have three – but prior suggestions that KDG bought all the other German cable operators, would have meant only one ‘ lined up directly against the all- powerful telco incumbent Deutsche Telekom. But suddenly the Bundeskartellamt may have realized that by not letting KDG bid, it may have crippled a native public company in KDG.
It was in March that Liberty Global seemed to have landed the prize German cable asset in Kabel BW, which everyone in Europe had been talking about since it went up for grabs late in 2010. Few rivals for Kabel BW’s hand could live with Liberty’s financial power, and although we thought Liberty was paying an exceptionally high price, at over €3.1 billion, the deal appeared to secure it the long wished for leadership in the German Pay TV market.
The deal would have taken Liberty Global to over 19 million cable homes across Europe, giving it even more content and equipment buying scale, and making it either dominant or second placed in a number of key, high yielding, markets. Germany is a low ARPU market with KDG averaging around €10 a month per home and Unity Media about €15. Kabel BW is thought to be higher still, but not by a large margin. In other markets such as its first major European stronghold in the Netherlands, Liberty has an ARPU of some €26 a month, while its rival Ziggo has one closer to €33.
The Bundeskartellamt may well have decided that there need to be multiple routes to market for German originated content and it wants these rivals to either overbuild or to offer OTT services against one another, so that there is some genuine competition. It is probably here that Liberty Global has a comeback, and can offer its new Horizon box and its TV Everywhere service outside of its footprint, so it is ready to make Germany more competitive. But it is almost forced to go that route if this deal is knocked back and it only has Unity Media.
Germany has been very slow to see the emergence of satellite DTH (direct to home) TV as a force with only 2.4 million of Germany’s entire 23.5 million pay TV homes. IPTV serves just 1.3 million German homes, the bulk of which are through Deutsche Telekom’s T-Entertain IPTV service and there are about 10 million homes with no pay TV at all, using free to air satellite and DVB-T terrestrial delivery.
However if this deal is not allowed to go ahead, everyone else in Europe will be wondering how else Liberty Global will use the money that was allocated to this deal. It had a run at Ziggo, the largest cable operator in the Netherlands, a move which managed to halt that company’s IPO, although that would have made it an even more dominant force there than the Kabel BW does in Germany, and that deal would never had got approval, even if Liberty had the cash to go through with it.
There is Numericable in France, that would represent a choice dominant cable position for Liberty, but it owned it once before and lost TV homes hand over fist, due to the unexpected power of the four competing IPTV players.
The chances are that Liberty would either open up on a new front in Europe, spend the money in South America where it has some holdings, or use the cash to accelerate its capex spend to make more of its networks digital. It doesn’t have to divert it to a specific acquisition, as it can make its European companies more competitive, a result that might be even worse for regulators everywhere.
The selling owner Swedish Private Equity firm EQT would be in a tough position in terms of finding another exit route, given the parlous state that IPO markets are in right now and may have to bide its time, if the Bundeskartellamt blocks the deal. A final decision will be made on December 15.
Liberty Global bought Unity Media for €3.5 billion in November 2009, including €1.5 billion in debt ‘ so effectively for €2 billion and holds cable companies in the Netherlands, Switzerland, Austria, Ireland, and Belgium, and central Europe in Hungary, Romania, and Slovakia, as well operations as far afield as in Chile.
The Bundeskartellamt informed the parties of its preliminary legal assessment of the project this week, in which it expressed competition concerns and inviting comments or to make offers to dispel its concerns. One area the decision talked about was the idea of these operators supplying TV service throughout Germany and referred to the three leaders as an oligopoly. It had the opinion that if the deal went ahead, it would be even more unlikely for KDG and Liberty to engage in competition with one another.
Another area where Liberty might respond is to promise minimum continued deals with certain TV stations, no content rationalization and a price guarantee for some years to come ‘ but that might make it less profitable and give the initiative to content businesses in renewal negotiations.
Faultline can see that it is possible to get a deal done on this basis, and that the objection by the Bundeskartellamt may entirely be about beginning the negotiating process.