LightSquared refuses to be daunted by its run in with GPS system in the US, and said this week that instead of using the directly neighboring 10 MHz slice of spectrum next to GPS, it will use the next slice over which belongs to Inmarsat. It agreed terms last year with Inmarsat in case of such an eventuality, and says that it has now tested it and proved that ground stations using the spectrum will not interfere with GPS. It has had to turn down the power of the transmitters by 50% in order to be certain that GPS will get no interference.
The Inmarsat spectrum runs from 1526 MHz to 1536 MHz and is further from the upper band used by GPS, which is 1559 MHz to 1610 MHz. The spectrum that LightSquared owns through its purchase of MSV (SkyTerra) is from 1536MHz to 1559MHz, right under the GPS spectrum. It’s likely that some, but not all of that spectrum, could be used under certain conditions without affecting GPS, but LightSquared right now needs a PR win and relief of publicity pressure on its efforts.
The truth is that this entire fiasco has come about because GPS is such a weak signal and so GPS receivers have to be immensely sensitive, and that’s all due to where technology was when the GPS satellite first went up. A new GS satellite will be too disruptive, although both Russia and China are planning one.
But that is not the story done and dusted. This is important to Faultline readers because it is about US nationwide broadband capability using LTE and that will invariably include video delivery. The existence or non-existence of LightSquared is likely to keep US operators honest when it comes to LTE pricing ‘ otherwise it will diverge dramatically from pricing outside the US because it will be in the hands of a duopoly, and likely become very expensive.
The problems are manifold for LightSquared. It can probably get by with 10 MHz of spectrum for about two years and it will have to pursue other ways of filtering out interference from GPS when it uses the ATC (Ancillary Terrestrial Component) of its other spectrum, when it uses its satellite spectrum from ground transmitters, as the FCC has allowed it to do. But perceptions about the viability of LightSquared may change radically if it cannot free up the slice of spectrum that is seen to be interfering with GPS.
The other issue is that with a lower EIRP (transmission power) some of the ground base stations will have to be closer together ‘ base stations are either spaced based on how far their signal will clearly reach or on how much traffic is anticipated at each base station. In cities base stations can be turned down quite a bit and not affect performance because they can only cope with a certain number of calls or data from each sub-channel. The base stations need to be dense because the people are densely populated. As you try to cover more sparsely populated areas, lower radiated power becomes a problem. This will add something like 20% to 30% to the LightSquared build out costs, and it will need some form of technical fix on its spectrum soon, and potentially a way of safely turning up the power.
The right solution is perhaps to use the MSS S-Band spectrum in 2 GHz that it has been chasing at TerreStar and before that at DBSD, which went to Dish Networks for $1 billion. The TerreStar spectrum will be finally auctioned with Dish in the driving seat, next week. Between the two this totals 40 MHz of spectrum neighboring the 3G spectrum and it has some of (but not yet all) of the same waivers to be used with both satellite and ground stations, that the L-Band spectrum has ‘ but no chance of interfering with GPS.
Prior to the announcement two days ago that it would fall back on the Inmarsat spectrum LightSquared bought itself two weeks by asking the FCC to delay announcing any ruling, so that it could come up with a solution to the GPS issue. One idea was to put filters on all its transmitters, another was to use only some of the LightSquared owned spectrum.
The company asked the FCC for the delay before a binding decision was made from the report from the National Public Safety Telecommunications Council’s working group which has tested the GPS interference.
The new due date of July 1 was requested ‘to conduct more tests,’ but realistically LightSquared was just trying to come up with a strategy that would not leave it in ruins and it has now already done that with the Inmarsat announcement. It said it would use the time to review ‘alternative frequency plans’ for its network.
Quite clearly, even if LightSquared begins a build out with only some of its spectrum, leaving a larger buffer between its L-Band spectrum and the GPS signals, it will still have to prove that the new configuration offers no interfere to GPS, so it will need all of that two weeks.
As if to make a statement that nothing really bad is likely to happen to its best friend LightSquared, Bloomberg was leaked the fact that Sprint has now signed a deal with Lightsquared. This has to be one of the cellular world’s worst kept secrets ‘ a deal which will means it shoulders some of the costs to help build out the LightSquared network and as a result it will get privileged rates to become the network’s largest LTE wholesale customer. US newspapers have put a value of $20 billion on the 15 year deal with Sprint. This means that discussions between Sprint and Clearwire have foundered and although it will continue to use the Clearwire network for now, eventually Sprint will go purely to Lightsquared for LTE.
But LightSquared will need every penny of any funds from Sprint, not just to alleviate its build out costs, but because it now has turned down the power on its transmissions, and will incur higher build out costs.
Interestingly AT&T’s bid to buy T-Mobile USA has hinged on whether or not there remains sufficient competition in the US cellular market after such a deal. Much of the pro-AT&T deal rhetoric has cited LightSquared as a viable wholesale competitor. If Lightsquared fails to ever build a network, it would create a far more polarized US cellular environment, in which the AT&T bid comes under even greater scrutiny. More conditions might be attached to it, if approved but if LightSquared dies, AT&T may find its route to buying T-Mobile blocked or at least held up.
There is the potential for a shining white knight on the horizon in the form of Dish Network and its maverick chairman Charlie Ergen. He has chased down two pieces of S-Band spectrum, out of the way of L-Band in 2 GHz, and free of any concerns about GPS interference. One deal he has landed for 20 MHz bought at a cost of $1 billion from DBSD, part of ICO Communications, and the other he has made a firm offer and leading bid on, for the assets of TerreStar last week, offering almost $1.4 billion to a bankruptcy court for another 20 MHz slice. Lightsquared has been chasing the same spectrum, but doesn’t have the money to outbid Dish. The final auction is on June 30, and now Lightsquared has even more motive to weigh in to make a bigger bid. Perhaps the announcement of the Sprint deal will leverage more money for LighSquared, but it’s unlikely and the smart money says Dish ends up with this spectrum.
Any number of other bidders might also bid for the spectrum in partnership with LightSquared, who could then lease it, in return for LTE services. Even Dish may be tempted to go into partnership with LightSquared, though it is likely to exact a tidy price for such a deal, as it brings not one, but two 20 MHz chunks of spectrum to the party. Dish does not have enough money to build a full LTE network of its own.
Dish can also bring to bear other assets, including those held by sister company EchoStar, which include the original video streaming patents from Move Networks, the placeshifting portfolio of Sling Media and perhaps more relevant to LightSquared, Hughes Communications which EchoStar bought for $1.3 billion in February, which among other things includes two way broadband access from satellites and tons of IPR in satellite delivery technology.
Dish may barter the S-Band spectrum for a shareholding in LightSquared, rights to all LightSquared ground to satellite capacity, video streaming to all LightSquared devices or a broadband wireless MVNO ‘ or all of the above, given how desperate Lightsquared might become to resolve its GPS problem and shore up its future.
Sanjiv Ahuja, LightSquared Chairman and CEO said in the announcement about the Inmarsat spectrum, ‘This is a solution which ensures that tens of millions of GPS users won’t be affected by LightSquared’s launch. At the same time, this plan offers a clear path for LightSquared to move forward with the launch of a nationwide wireless network that will introduce world class broadband service to rural and underserved areas which still find themselves on the wrong side of the digital divide.’
That’s all very well Sanjiv, but if you turn down the power on your network, how are you going to build out underserved areas in terrestrial LTE? Or will you now deliver that from a satellite, complete with all its propagation delays?